austrian flag

Constitution of Austria

Adopted 1930, Amended up to 2014

Chapter I

General Provisions. European Union

A- General Provisions

Art. 1. Austria is a democratic republic. Its law emanates from the people.

Art. 2.

(1) Austria is a federal state.

(2) The Federal State is composed of the autonomous provinces of Burgenland, Carinthia, Lower Austria, Upper Austria, Salzburg, Styria, Tirol, Vorarlberg and Vienna.

(3) Changes in the composition of the provinces or a restriction of the involvement of the provinces provided for in this para and in art 3 also require constitutional regulations of the provinces.

Art. 3.

(1) The federal territory comprises the territories of the federal provinces.

(2) State treaties changing the federal boundaries may only be concluded with the approval of the provinces affected.

(3) Modifications of boundaries within the federal territory require concurrent laws of the Federation and the provinces affected. Ratifications of boundaries within the federal territory only require concurrent laws of the provinces affected.

(4) Resolutions of the National Council on modifications of boundaries ac-cording to para 2 and 3, to the extent they do not concern rectification of boundaries, require at least the votes of half of the members and the majority of two thirds of the votes cast.

Art. 4.

(1) The federal territory is a uniform currency, economic and customs area.

(2) Intermediate customs barriers or other traffic restrictions may not be established within federal territory.

Art. 5.

(1) The federal capital and seat of the highest federal authorities is Vienna.

(2) For the duration of extraordinary circumstances the Federal President can, at the request of the Federal Government, relocate the seat of the highest federal authorities to another location in the federal territory.

Art. 6.

(1) For the Republic of Austria there is a uniform nationality.

(2) Nationals are citizens of the province where they have their principal domicile; province-laws can however stipulate that also nationals who have a domicile, but not their principal domicile, in the province are citizens of that province.

(3) A person’s principal domicile is established in the place where he has settled with the intention, provable or emerging from the circumstances, of setting up there the centre of his relations of life. If this requirement is, on the basis of an overall consideration of a person’s professional, economic and social relations of life, met by more than one domicile, this person has to designate as his principal domicile the one which he has the closest relationship to.

(4) In the matters to hold the election of the Federal President, of elections for the general representative bodies and the European Parliament, the election of the mayor by those to elect the municipal council, in the matters to hold popular initiatives, referenda and consultations of the people on the basis of the federal constitution or the constitution of a province as well as in matters of the direct participation of those entitled to elect the municipal council in handling the matters of their own sphere of competence of the municipality, for the duration of a detention or arrest in the sense of the Federal Constitutional Act on the Protection of Personal Liberty, promulgated in Federal Law Gazette No. 684/1988, the last residences outside the place of the arrest or detention and the last main residence outside the place of the arrest or detention that a person had before the arrest or detention are deemed to be the residences or the main residence, respectively, of the person arrested or detained.

Art. 7.

(1) All nationals are equal before the law. Privileges based upon birth, sex, estate, class or religion are excluded. No one shall be discriminated against because of his disability. The Republic (Federation, provinces and municipalities) commits itself to ensuring the equal treatment of disabled and non-disabled persons in all spheres of everyday life.

(2) The Federation, provinces and municipalities subscribe to the defacto equality of men and women. Measures to promote factual equality of women and men, particularly by eliminating actually existing inequalities, are admissible.

(3) Official designations can be applied in such a way as to indicate the sex of the officer holder. The same holds good for titles, academic degrees and descriptions of occupations.

(4) Public employees, including members of the federal army, are guaranteed the unrestricted exercise of their political rights.

Art. 8.

(1) German is the official language of the Republic without prejudice to the rights provided by federal law for linguistic minorities.

(2) The Republic (Federation, provinces and municipalities) subscribe to its linguistic and cultural multiplicity having grown, expressed in the autochthonous ethnic groups. Language and culture, existence and preservation of these ethnic groups are to be respected, safeguarded and to be supported.

(3) The Austrian sign language is recognized as independent language. Details are regulated by the laws.

Art. 8a.

(1) The colours of the Republic of Austria are red-white-red. The flag consists of three identically broad horizontal stripes of which the intermediate is white, the upper and the lower are red.

(2) The coat of arms of the Republic of Austria (the Federal coat of arms) consists of an unfettered, single-headed, black, gilt-armed and red-tongued eagle on whose breast is imposed a red shield intersected by a silver crosspiece. On its head the eagle bears a mural crown with three visible battlements. A sundered iron chain rings both talons. The right holds a golden sickle with inward turned blade, the left a golden hammer.

(3) Detailed provisions, in particular as to safeguard of the colours, the coat of arms, and the seal of the Republic, are settled by federal law.

Art. 9.

(1) The generally recognized rules of international law are regarded as integral parts of federal law.

(2) By Law or state treaty having been approved according to Art. 50 para 1 may be transferred specific federal competences to other states or intergovernmental organizations. The same way the activity of agents of foreign states or intergovernmental organizations inside Austria and the activity of Austrian agents abroad may be regulated as well as the transfer of single federal competences of other states or intergovernmental organizations to Austrian agents be provided for. Within this frame it may be provided for that Austrian agents shall be subject to the authority of agents of other states or intergovernmental organizations or such be subject to the authority of Austrian agents.

Art. 9a.

(1) Austria subscribes to comprehensive national defence. Its task is to preserve the external independence as well as its inviolability and its unity, especially as regards the maintenance and defence of permanent neutrality. In this connection, too, the constitutional establishments and their capacity to function as well as the democratic freedoms of residents are to be safeguarded and defended against attacks from outside.

(2) Universal national defence comprises military, intellectual, civil and economic national defence.

(3) Every male national is liable to military service. Female nationals may render voluntary service in the Federal Army as soldiers and have the right to terminate such service.

(4) Conscientious objectors who refuse the fulfilment of compulsory military service and are exonerated therefrom must perform an alternative service (civilian service).

Art. 10.

(1) The Federation has powers of legislation and execution in the following matters:

1- the Federal Constitution, in particular elections to the National Council, and popular initiatives, referenda and consultations of the people as provided by the Federal Constitution; the constitutional jurisdiction; the administrative jurisdiction with the exception of the organization of the administrative courts of the provinces:

1a- Elections for the European parliament; European citizen action groups;

2- external affairs including political and economic representation with regard to other countries, in particular the conclusion of international treaties, notwithstanding province-competence in accordance with art. 16 para 1; demarcation of frontiers; trade in goods and livestock with other countries; customs;

3- regulation and control of entry into and exit from the federal territory; immigration and emigration including the right of abode for humanitarian reasons; passports; residence prohibition, expulsion and deportation; asylum; extradition

4- Federal finances, in particular taxes to be collected exclusively or in part on behalf of the Federation; monopolies;

5- the monetary, credit, stock exchange and banking system; the weights and measures, standards and hallmark system;

6- civil law affairs, including the rules relating to economic association but excluding regulations which render real property transactions, legal acquisition on death by individuals outside the circle of legal heirs not excepted, with aliens and transactions in built-up real property or such as is ear-marked for development subject to restrictions by the administrative authorities; private endowment affairs; criminal law, excluding administrative penal law and administrative penal procedure in matters which fall within the autonomous sphere of competence of the provinces; administration of justice; establishments for the protection of society against criminal or otherwise dangerous elements; copyright; press affairs; expropriation in so far as it does not concern matters falling within the autonomous sphere of competence of the provinces; matters pertaining to notaries, lawyers, and related professions;

7- the maintenance of peace, order and security including the extension of primary assistance in general, but excluding local public safety matters; the right of association and assembly; matters pertaining to personal status, including the registration of births, marriages and deaths, and change of name; aliens police and residence registration; matters pertaining to weapons, ammunition and explosives, and the use of fire-arms;

8- matters pertaining to trade and industry; public advertising and commercial brokerage; restraint of unfair competition; antitrust law patent matters and the protection of designs, trade-marks, and other commodity descriptions; matters pertaining to patent agents; matters pertaining to civil engineering; chambers of commerce, trade, and industry; establishment of professional associations in so far as they extend to the federal territory as a whole, but with the exception of those in the field of agriculture and forestry;

9- traffic- system relating to the railways, aviation and shipping in so far as the last of these does not fall under art. 11; motor traffic; matters, with exception of the highway police, which concern roads declared by federal law as Federal highways on account of their importance for transit traffic; river and navigation police in so far as these do not fall under art. 11; the postal and telecommunications system; environmental compatibility evaluation for projects relating to these matters where material effects on the environment are to be anticipated;

10- mining; forestry, including drifting; water rights; control and conservation of waters for the safe diversion of floods or for shipping and raft transport; regulation of torrents; construction and maintenance of waterways; regulation and standardization of electrical plants and establishments as well as safety measures in this field; provisions pertaining to electric power transmission in so far as the transmission extends over two or more provinces; matters pertaining to steam and other power-driven engines; surveying;

11- labour-legislation in so far as it does not fall under art. 12; social and contractual insurance; nursing care allowance; social compensation legislation; chambers of labour with the exception of those relating to agriculture and forestry;

12- public health with the exception of burial and disposal of the dead and municipal sanitation and first aid services, but only sanitary supervision with respect to hospitals, nursing homes, health resorts and natural curative resources; measures to counter factors hazardous to the environment through the transgression of the emission limit; clear air maintenance notwithstanding the competence of the provinces for heating installations; refuse disposal in respect of dangerous refuse, but in respect of other refuse only in so far as a need for the issue of uniform regulations exists; veterinary affairs; nutrition affairs, including foodstuffs inspection; regulation of commercial transactions in seed and plant commodities, in fodder and fertilizer as well as plant preservatives, and in plant safety appliances including their admission and, in the case of seed and plant commodities, likewise their acceptance;

13- archive and library services for the sciences and specialist purposes; matters pertaining to federal collections and establishments serving the arts and sciences; matters pertaining to the federal theatres with the exception of building affairs; the preservation of monuments; religious affairs; census as well as – allowing for the rights of the provinces to engage within their own territory in every kind of statistical activity – other statistics in so far as they do not serve the interests of one province only; endowments and foundations when their purposes extend beyond a single province’s sphere of interests and they have hitherto not been autonomously administered by the provinces;

14- organization and command of the federal police; settlement of the conditions pertaining to the establishment and organization of other protective forces with the exception of the municipal constabularies; settlement of the conditions pertaining to the armament of the protective forces and their right to make use of their weapons.

15- military affairs; matters pertaining to civilian service; war damage measures; care of war graves; whatever measures seem necessary by reason or in consequence of war to ensure the uniform conduct of economic affairs, in particular with regard to the population’s supply with essentials;

16- the establishment of federal authorities and other federal agencies; service code for and staff representation rights of federal employees;

17- population policy in so far as it concerns the grant of children’s allowances and the creation of burden equalization on behalf of families;

18- (Note repealed by F.L.G. I No. 12/2012)

(2) In federal laws on the right of succession to undivided farm estate as well as in federal laws promulgated in accordance with para 1 sub-para 10 above province-legislatures can be empowered to issue implementing provisions with respect to individual provisions which must be specifically designated. The provisions of art. 15 para 6 shall be analogously applied to this provincial legislation. Execution of the implementing laws issued in such cases lies with the Federation, but the enabling ordinances, in so far as they relate to the implementing provisions of the province-law, need foregoing agreement with the provincial government concerned.

(3) The Federation must allow the provinces opportunity to present their views before its conclusion of treaties which within the meaning of art. 16 render necessary enabling measures or affect the autonomous sphere of competence of the provinces in another way. Is the Federation in possession of a uniform comment by the provinces, the Federation is bound thereby when concluding the state treaty. It may deviate therefrom only for compelling foreign policy reasons; the Federation must advise the provinces of these reasons without delay.

(4) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. No. 1013/1994)

(5) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. No. 1013/1994)

(6) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. No. 1013/1994)

Art. 11.

(1) In the following matters legislation is the business of the Federation, execution that of the provinces:

1- nationality;

2- professional-associations in so far as they do not fall under art. 10, but with the exception of those in the field of agriculture and forestry as well as in the field of alpine guidance and skiing instruction and in that of sport instruction falling within provinces autonomous competence;

3- social housing affairs except for the promotion of domestic dwelling construction and domestic rehabilitation;

4- road police;

5- sanitation;

6- inland shipping as regards shipping licenses, shipping facilities and compulsory measures pertaining to such facilities in so far as it does not apply to the Danube, Lake Constance, Lake Neusiedl, and boundary stretches of other frontier waters; river and navigation police on inland waters with the exception of the Danube, Lake Constance, Lake Neusiedl, and boundary stretches of other frontier waters;

7- Environmental impact assessment for projects relating to these matters where material effects on the environment are to be anticipated; in so far as a need for the issue of uniform regulations is considered to exist, the approval of such projects.

8- Animal protection, to the extent not being in the competence of federal legislation according to other regulations, with the exception of the exercise of hunting or fishing.

(2) In so far as a need for the issue of uniform regulations is considered to exist, the administrative procedure, the general provisions of administrative penal law, the administrative penal procedure and the administrative execution also in matters where legislation lies with the provinces, are prescribed by federal law; divergent regulations can be made in federal or province laws settling the individual spheres of administration only when they are requisite for regularization of the matter in hand.

(3) Enabling ordinances to the federal laws promulgated in accordance with paras 1 and 2 above shall be issued, save as otherwise provided in these laws, by the Federation. The manner of publication for enabling ordinances whose issue by the provinces in matters concerning para 1, sub-paras 4 and 6 above is empowered by federal law can be prescribed by federal law.

(4) The application of the laws promulgated pursuant to para 2 and the enabling ordinances issued hereto lies with the Federation or the provinces, depending on whether the business which forms the subject of the procedure is a matter for execution by the Federation or the provinces.

(5) Federal laws can lay down uniform output limits for atmospheric pollutants in so far as a need for the issue of uniform regulations exists. These may not be exceeded in the federal and province regulations prescribed for the individual sectors of the administration.

(6) In so far as a need for the issue of uniform regulations is considered to exist, federal law shall likewise prescribe the citizens´ participation procedure for projects to be governed by federal law, the participation in the administrative procedures subsequent to a citizens’ participation procedure, and consideration of the results of the citizens’ participation procedure at the time of the issue of the requisite permissions for the projects in question as well as the approval of the projects specified in art. 10 para 1 sub-para 9. In respect of the execution of these regulations para 4 applies.

(7) In the matters specified in para 1 sub-para 7 and 8 the following powers are vested in the federal government and in the individual federal ministries as against a province government:

1- the power to inspect via federal agencies documents of the province authorities;

2- the power to demand the transmission of reports respecting the execution of laws and ordinances issued by the Federation;

3- the power to demand for the preparation of the issue of laws and ordinances by the Federation all information necessary respecting execution;

4- the power in certain instances to demand information and the presentation of documents in so far as this is necessary for the exercise of other powers.

Art. 12.

(1) In the following matters legislation as regards principles is the business of the Federation, the issue of implementing laws and execution the business of the provinces:

1- social-welfare; population policy in so far as it does not fall under art. 10; public social and welfare establishments; maternity, infant and adolescent welfare; hospitals and nursing homes; requirements to be imposed for health reasons on health resorts, sanatoria, and health establishments; natural curative resources;

2- public institutions for the adjustment of disputes out of court;

3- land reform, in particular land consolidation measures and resettlement;

4- the protection of plants against diseases and pests;

5- matters-pertaining to electric power in so far as they do not fall under art. 10;

6- labour-legislation and the protection of workers and employees in so far as it is a matter of workers and employees engaged in agriculture and forestry.

 (2) Fundamental laws and fundamental provisions in federal legislation shall be expressly specified as such.

Art. 13.

(1) The competences of the Federation and the provinces in the field of taxation will be prescribed in a special federal constitutional law (“Constitutional Finance Law”).

(2) The Federation, the provinces and the municipalities must aim at the securement of an overall balance and sustainable balanced budgets in the conduct of their economic affairs. They have to coordinate their budgeting with regard to these goals.

(3) Federation, provinces and municipalities have to aim at the equal status of women and men in the budgeting.

Art. 14.

(1) Save as provided otherwise in the following paragraphs, legislation and execution in the field of schooling and in the field of education in matters pertaining to pupil and student hostels are the business of the Federation. The matters settled in art. 14a do not belong to schooling and education within the meaning of this article.

(2) Save as provided otherwise by para 4 sub-para a below, legislation is the business of the Federation, execution the business of the provinces in matters pertaining to the service code for and staff representation rights of teachers at public compulsory schools. Such federal laws can empower provincial legislatures to issue implementing provisions to individual provisions which shall be precisely specified; in these instances the provisions of art. 15 para 6 apply analogously. The enabling ordinances in respect of such federation laws, save as provided otherwise herein, shall be issued by the Federation.

(3) In the following matters legislation as regards principles is the business of the Federation, the issue of implementing laws and execution the business of the provinces:

(a) composition and organisation, including their members’ appointment and remuneration, of the boards to be constituted as part of the federal school authorities;

(b) framework organization (structure, organizational forms, establishment, maintenance, dissolution, local districts, sizes of classes and instruction periods) of public compulsory schools;

(c) framework organization of publicly maintained student hostels provided exclusively or mainly for pupils of compulsory schools;

(d) professional-employment qualifications for kindergarten teachers and educational assistants to be employed by the provinces, municipalities, or municipal associations at the centres and student hostels provided exclusively or mainly for pupils of compulsory schools.

(4) In the following matters legislation and execution is the business of the provinces:

(a) competence of authorities, on the basis of laws promulgated pursuant to para 2 above, to exercise the service prerogative over teachers at public compulsory schools; the provincial laws shall provide that the federal school authorities must participate in appointments, other selections for service positions, and awards as well as in eligibility and disciplinary proceedings. The participation in appointments, other selections for service positions, and awards shall at all events comprise a right of nomination on the part of the primary level federal school authority; provincial legislation can provide that the relevant federal school authority shall supervise teachers at public compulsory schools and, in doing so, are bound by the instructions of the provincial Government;

(b) the-kindergarten system and the day-homes system.

(5) In the following matters legislation and execution are, in deviation from the provisions of paras 2 to 4 above, the business of the Federation:

(a) public practice schools, demonstration kindergartens, demonstration day-homes and demonstration student hostels attached to a public school for the purpose of practical instruction as provided by the curriculum;

(b) publicly maintained student hostels intended exclusively or mainly for pupils of the practice schools mentioned in sub-para a above;

(c) the service-code for and staff representation rights of teachers, educational assistants and kindergarten teachers at the public institutions mentioned in sub-paras a and b above.

(5a) Democracy, humanity, solidarity, peace and justice as well as openness and tolerance towards people are the elementary values of the school, based on which it secures for the whole population, independent from origin, social situation and financial background a maximum of educational level, permanently safe-guarding and developing optimal quality. In a partnership-like cooperation between pupils, parents and teachers, children and juveniles are to be allowed the optimal intellectual, mental and physical development to let them become healthy, self-confident, happy, performance-oriented, dutiful, talented and creative humans capable to take over responsibility for themselves, fellow human beings, environment and following generations, oriented in social, religious and moral values. Any juvenile shall in accordance with his development and educational course be led to independent judgement and social understanding, be open to political, religious and ideological thinking of others and become capable to participate in the cultural and economic life of Austria, Europe and the world and participate in the common tasks of mankind, in love for freedom and peace.

(6) Schools are institutions in which pupils shall be educated together according to a comprehensive fixed curriculum and in which, in connection with the imparting of knowledge and skills, a comprehensive educational goal is strived for. Public schools are those schools which are established and maintained by authorities so required by law. The Federation is the authority so required by law in so far as legislation and execution in matters pertaining to the establishment, maintenance and dissolution of public schools are the business of the Federation. The province or, according to the provincial statutory provisions, the municipality or a municipal association is the authority so required by law in so far as legislation or implementing legislation and execution in matters pertaining to establishment, maintenance and dissolution of public schools are the business of the province. Admission to public school is open to all without distinction of birth, sex, race, estate, class, language and religion, and in other respects within the limits of the statutory requirements. The same applies analogously to kindergartens, day homes and student hostels.

(6a) Legislation has to provide a differentiated school system which is organized according to the educational program at least in general educational and vocational schools and according to the level of education in primary and secondary schools, in which further adequate distinguishing shall be provided for the secondary schools.

 (7) Private schools are other than public schools; they shall be accorded public status according to the statutory provisions.

 (7a) The compulsory school attendance is at least nine years and also compulsory vocational school attendance exists.

(8) The Federation is entitled, in matters which in accordance with paras 2 and 3 appertain to the execution by the provinces, to obtain information about adherence to the laws and ordinances issued on the basis of these paragraphs and can for this purpose delegate officials to the schools and student hostels. Should shortcomings be observed, the governor can be instructed (Art. 20 para 1) to re-dress the shortcomings within an appropriate deadline. The governor must see to the redress of the shortcomings according to the statutory provisions and, to effect the execution of such instructions, is bound also to employ the means at his disposal in his capacity as an authority-acting on behalf of the province in its autonomous sphere of competence.

(9) The general rules in Arts. 10 and 21 as to the distribution of competences for legislation and execution regarding conditions of service with the Federation, the provinces, the municipalities and the municipal associations apply in respect of the service code for teachers, educational assistants and kindergarten teachers, save as provided otherwise by the preceding paragraphs. The same applies to the staff representation rights of teachers, educational assistants, and kindergarten teachers.

(10) In matters pertaining to the free attendance of schools, and the relation-ship between school and the churches (religious societies) including religious instruction at school, the National Council, in so far as matters pertaining to universities and tertiary-level education institution are not concerned, can vote federal legislation only in the presence of at least half the members and by a two thirds majority of the votes cast. The same applies if the principles of para 6a shall be left aside and to the ratification of state treaties negotiated in the matters mentioned above and which fall into the category specified in art. 50.

(11) (Note: repealed by art. I sub-para 2 BVG, F. L. G. No. 316/1975)

Art. 14a.

(1) Save as provided otherwise in the following paragraphs, legislation and execution are the business of the provinces with regard to agricultural and forestry schooling as well as with regard to agricultural and forestry education in matters pertaining to student hostels and in matters pertaining to the service code for and staff representation rights of teachers and educational assistants at the schools and student hostels falling under this article. Matters pertaining to university and tertiary-level training do not fall under agricultural and forestry schooling.

(2) Legislation and execution is the business of the Federation in the following matters:

(a) secondary agricultural and forestry schools and schools for the training and supplementary training of teachers at agricultural and forestry schools;

(b) technical colleges for the training of forestry employees;

(c) public agricultural and forestry technical colleges linked organizationally to one of the public schools mentioned in sub-paras a and b above or to a federal agricultural and forestry research institute to ensure provision of the demonstrations scheduled in the curricula;

(d) student hostels exclusively or mainly designated for pupils of the schools mentioned in sub-paras a to c above;

(e) service code for and staff representational rights of the teachers and educational assistants in the establishments mentioned in sub-paras a to d above;

(f) subsidies for staff expenditure of the denominational agricultural and forestry schools;

(g) Federal agricultural and forestry institutes linked organizationally to an agricultural and forestry school supported by the Federation to ensure provision of the demonstrations scheduled in the curricula of these schools.

(3) Save as it concerns matters mentioned in para 2 above, legislation is the business of the Federation, execution the business of the provinces in matters of

(a) religious instruction;

(b) the service code for and staff representation rights of teachers at public agricultural and forestry vocational schools and technical colleges and of educational assistants at publicly maintained student hostels exclusively or mainly designated for pupils of these schools, excepting however matters of official competence for the exercise of the service prerogative over these teachers and educational assistants.

Provincial legislature can be authorized in federal laws promulgated by reason of the provisions under sub-para b above to issue implementing provisions for individual regulations which shall be precisely specified; in this connection the provisions of art. 15 para 6 apply analogously. Enabling ordinances for the federal laws shall, save as otherwise provided there, be issued by the Federation.

(4) Legislation as regards principles is the business of the Federation, the issue of implementing laws and execution is the business of the provinces

(a) as regards the agricultural and forestry vocational schools in matters pertaining to definitions of the instructional objective, the obligatory subjects, and free tuition as well as in matters pertaining to compulsory schooling and the transfer from the school in one province to the school in another province;

(b) as regards the agricultural and forestry technical colleges in matters pertaining to the definition of admission prerequisites, instructional objective, organizational forms, extent of the teaching and obligatory subjects, free tuition, and the transfer from the school in one province to the school in another province;

(c) in matters pertaining to the public status of private agricultural and forestry vocational schools and training colleges with the exception of schools falling under para 2 sub-para b above;

(d) as regards the organization and competence of advisory boards who in the matters pertaining to para 1 above participate in the execution by the provinces.

(5) The establishment of the agricultural and forestry technical colleges and research institutes specified under para 2 sub-paras c and g above is only admissible if the provincial government of the province in which the vocational school resp. technical college is to have its location has agreed to the establishment. This agreement is not requisite if the establishment concerns an agricultural and forestry school which is to be organizationally linked to a school for the training and supplementary training of teachers and agricultural and forestry schools to ensure provision of the demonstrations scheduled in their curricula.

(6) It lies within the competence of the Federation to see to the observance of the regulations issued by it in matters whose execution in accordance with paras 3 and 4 appertains to the provinces.

(7) The provisions of art. 14 paras Abs. 5a, 6, 6a, 7, 7a and 9 analogously also hold good for the spheres specified

(8) Art. 14 para 10 holds good analogously.

Article 14b.

(1) Legislation as regards matters of public tendering, to the extent not being subject to para 3, is the business of the Federation.

(2) The execution in the matters of para 1 is

1- Business of the Federation regarding

(a) the award of contracts by the Federation;

(b) the award of contracts by endowments, funds and institutions in the sense of art. 126b para 1;

(c) the award of contracts by enterprises in the sense of art. 126b para 2, if the financial share or the influence of the Federation caused by other financial or other economic or organizational measures, is at least equal to the financial share or the influence of the provinces;

(d) the award of contracts by self-administering bodies corporate established by federal law;

(e) the-award of contracts by legal entities not mentioned in lit. a to d and sub-para 2 lit. a to d;

(aa) financed by the Federation, if the financial contribution of the Federation is at least equal to the one of the provinces;

(bb) which regarding the management are subject to the control by the Federation, to the extent the award is not subject to (aa) or sub-para 2 lit. e (aa);

(cc) whose administrative-, managing- or supervising bodies consist of members having been appointed by the Federation, if the Federation has appointed at least an equal number of members like the provinces, to the extent the award is not subject to (aa) or (bb) or sub-para 2 lit. e (aa) or (bb);

(f) the-joint award of contracts by the Federation and the provinces, to the extent not being subject to sub-para 1 lit. f as well as the joint award of contracts by several provinces.

(g) the award of contracts by legal entities not being named in lit a to f and sub-para 2;

2- the business of the provinces regarding

(a) the award of contracts by the province, the municipalities and associations of municipalities;

(b) the-award of contracts by endowments, funds and institution in the sense of art. 127 para 1 and of art. 127 a para 1 and 8;

(c) the-award of contracts by enterprises in the sense of art. 126b para 2, to the extend it is not subject to sub-para 1 lit c, as well as the award of contracts by enterprises in the sense of art. 127 para 3 and of art. 127a para 3 and 8;

(d) the award of contracts by self-governing legal entities created by provincial law;

(e) the-award of contracts by legal entities not being named in sub-para 1 lit. a through d and lit. a through d;

(aa) being financed by the province alone or jointly with the Federation or other provinces, to the extent not being subject to sub-para 1 lit. e (aa);

(bb) which regarding its management are subject to the control by the province, to the extent the award is not subject to sub-para 1 lit. e (aa) or (bb) or (aa);

(cc) whose administrative-, managing- or supervisory bodies consist of members having been appointed by the province to the extent, not being subject to sub-para 1 lit. e (aa) to (cc) or (aa) or (bb);

(f) the-joint award of contracts by the Federation and the provinces, to the extent not being subject to sub-para 1 lit. f as well as the joint award of contracts by several provinces.

Municipalities, without regard to the number of its inhabitants, are deemed to be legal entities which in the sense of sub-para 1 lit. b and c and of sub-para 2 lit. b and c are subject to the jurisdiction of the public audit office. In the frame of sub-para 1 lit. b, c, e and f employers in the sense of sub-para 1 shall be allocated to the Federation and employers in the sense of sub-para 2 to the respective province. If according to sub-para 2 lit. c, e or f several provinces are involved, the competence for the execution depends on the preponderance of the criterion which is or ac-cording to the respective litera (sublitera) of sub-para 1 would be relevant for the delimitation of the competence for execution of the Federation from the one of the provinces, then from the seat of the employers, then from the focal location of the business activity of employers, then from the seat (main residence) of the awarding institution; if, however, the competence can thus not be determined, the participating province is competent which at the time of the institution of the award procedure is or has most recently been chairing the Federal Council.

(3) Business of the provinces is the legislation and execution in the matters of review in the frame of awarding of contracts by employers in the sense of para 2 sub-para 2.

(4) The Federation has to grant the provinces opportunity to participate in the preparation of draft bills in the matters of para 1. Federal laws under para 1 to be promulgated, governing matters whose execution is business of the provinces, may only be published upon approval of the provinces.

(5) Execution ordinances to federal laws under para 1 promulgated are to be issued by the Federation, to the extent these laws do not provide otherwise. Para 4 and art. 42a are to be applied accordingly to such execution ordinances.

(6) Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette. I No. 51/2012)

Art. 15.

(1) In so far as a matter is not expressly assigned by the Federal Constitution to the Federation for legislation or also execution, it remains within the provinces autonomous sphere of competence.

(2) In matters of local public security administration, that is that part of public security administration which exclusively or preponderantly affects the interests of the local community personified by the municipality and which, like preservation of public decency and defence against the improper creation of noise, can suitably be undertaken by the community within its local boundaries, the Federation has authority to supervise the conduct of these matters by the municipality and to re-dress any observed shortcomings by instructions to the governor (art. 103). Inspectoral authorities of the Federation can for this purpose be delegated to the municipality; in each and every case the governor shall be informed hereof.

(3) The provisions of provinces legislation in matters pertaining to theatres and cinemas, public shows, performances and entertainments shall assign, for areas of a municipality, in which the police directorate of a land simultaneously is security authority of first instance, to the police directorate of the province, at least the superintendence of the events, in so far as this does not extend to technical operation, building police and fire police considerations, and the participation by the administration in the initial stage of grant of licences as stipulated by such legislation.

(4) To what extent executive responsibility matters in the domain of the road police, except the local traffic police (art. 118 para 3 sub-para 4) and the river and navigation police on the Danube, Lake Constance, Lake Neusiedl, and boundary stretches of other frontier waters, for areas of a municipality in which the police directorate of a province simultaneously is security authority of first instance, shall be assigned to the police directorate of the province, shall be prescribed in corresponding laws of the Federation and the province concerned.

(5) (Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012)

(6) In so far as only legislation as regards principles has been reserved to the Federation, detailed implementation within the framework laid down by federal law is incumbent on provincial legislatures. The federal law can fix for the issue of the implementing legislation a deadline which may not, without the consent of the Federal Council, be shorter than six months and not longer than one year. If a province does not observe this deadline, competence for the issue of the implementing legislation passes from that province to the Federation. As soon as the province has issued the implementing legislation, the Federation becomes ineffective. If the Federation has not established any principles, provincial legislation is free to settle such matters. As soon as the Federation has established principles, the provisions of provincial legislation shall within the deadline to be appointed by federal law be adjusted to the legislation as regards the principle law.

(7) (Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012)

(8) In matters reserved to federal legislation in conformity with arts. 11 and 12, the Federation is entitled to control the observance of the regulations it has issued.

(9) Within the scope of their legislation provinces are authorized to make necessary provisions also in the field of criminal and civil law to regulate a matter.

(10) Provincial legislation which alters or settles along new lines the existent organization of the ordinary public administration in the provinces, may only been promulgated with the consent of the Federal Government. In such provincial legislation cross-district border cooperation of district administrative authorities including towns with own charter (art. 116 para 3) especially also the transfer of competence of authorities may be provided,

1- if it concerns procedures, which are not frequent and require a high extent of expertise, or.

2- in order to facilitate the handling of competences out of office hours for the general public

Art. 15a.

(1) The Federation and the provinces may conclude agreements among themselves about matters within their respective sphere of competence. The conclusion of such agreements in the name of the Federation is, depending on the subject, incumbent on the Federal Government or the federal ministers. Agreements which are to be binding also on the authorities of the federal legislature can be concluded by the Federal Government only with the approval of the National Council. Art. 50 para 3 shall by analogy be applied to such resolutions of the National Council; they shall be published in the Federal Law Gazette.

(2) Agreements between the provinces can only be made about matters pertaining to their autonomous sphere of competence and must without delay be brought to the Federal Government’s knowledge.

(3) The principles of international law concerning treaties shall apply to agreements within the meaning of para 1 above. The same holds good for agreements within the meaning of para 2 above save as provided otherwise by corresponding constitutional laws of the provinces in question.

Art. 16.

(1) In matters within their own sphere of competence the provinces can conclude treaties with states, or their constituent states, bordering on Austria.

(2) The governor must inform the Federal Government before the initiation of negotiations about such a treaty. The Federal Government’s approval must be obtained by the Governor before their conclusion. The approval is deemed to have been given if the Federal Government has not within eight weeks from the day that the request for approval has reached the Federal Chancellery told the governor that approval is withheld. The authorization to initiate negotiations and to conclude the treaty is incumbent on the Federal President after the recommendation of the provincial Government and with the countersignature of the governor.

(3) Treaties concluded by a province in accordance with para 1 above shall be revoked upon request by the Federal Government. If a province does not duly comply with this obligation, competence in the matter passes to the Federation.

(4) The provinces are bound to take measures which within their autonomous sphere of competence become necessary for the implementation of treaties; should a province fail to comply punctually with this obligation, competence for such measures, in particular for the issue of the necessary laws, passes to the Federation. A measure taken by the Federation pursuant to this provision, in particular the issue of such a law or the issue of such an ordinance becomes ineffective as soon as the province has taken the requisite action.

(5) In the same way the Federation is, in the case of implementation of treaties, entitled to supervision also in such matters as belong to the provinces´ own sphere of competence. The powers vested in the Federation as against the provinces are in this instance the same as in matters pertaining to indirect federal administration (art. 102).

(6) (Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette No. 1013/1994)

Art. 17. The provisions of arts. 10 to 15 with regard to competence of legislation and execution in no way affect the position of the Federation and the provinces as the holders of civil rights.

Art. 18.

(1) The entire public administration shall be based on law.

(2) Every administrative authority can on the basis of law issue ordinances within its sphere of competence.

(3) If the immediate issue of measures, which require, in accordance with the Constitution, a resolution by the National Council, becomes necessary to prevent obvious and irreparable damage to the community at a time when the National Council is not assembled, cannot meet in time, or is impeded from action by events beyond its control, the Federal President can at the recommendation of the Federal Government and on his and their responsibility take these measures by way of provisional law amending ordinances. The Federal Government must pre-sent its recommendation with the consent of the standing sub-committee to be appointed by the main committee of the National Council (article 55, para 2). Such an ordinance requires the countersignature of the Federal Government.

(4) Every ordinance issued in accordance with para 3 above shall without delay be submitted by the Federal Government to the National Council which if it is not in session at this time shall be convened by the Federal President, but if it is in session by the President of the National Council on one of the eight days following the submission. Within four weeks of the submission the National Council must either vote a corresponding federal law in place of the ordinance or pass a resolution demanding that the ordinance immediately become invalidated. In the latter case the Federal Government must immediately meet this demand. In order that the resolution of the National Council may be adopted in time, the President shall at the latest submit the motion to the vote on the last day but one before expiry of the four weeks deadline; detailed provisions shall be made in the Federal Law on the National Council’s Standing Orders. If the ordinance is, in accordance with the previous provisions, rescinded by the Federal Government, the legal provisions which had been invalidated by the ordinance enter into force effective again on the day of entry into force of the rescission.

(5) The ordinances specified in para 3 above may not contain an amendment to provisions of federal constitutional law and may have for their subject neither a permanent financial burden on the Federation nor a financial burden on the provinces or municipalities nor financial commitments for citizens nor an alienation of federal assets nor measures pertaining to matters specified in art. 10 para 1 sub-para 11 nor, finally, such as concern the right of collective association or rent protection.

Art. 19.

(1) The highest executive authorities are the Federal President, the federal ministers and the state secretaries, and the members of the provincial Governments.

(2) The admissibility of activities in the private sector of the economy by the authorities specified in para 1 above and other public functionaries can be restricted by federal law.

Art. 20.

(1) Under the direction of the highest executive officer of the Federation and the provinces elected executive officer, appointed professional executive officer or contractually appointed executive officer conduct the administration in accordance with the provisions of the laws. They are responsible to their superiors for the exercise of their office and, save as provided otherwise by laws pursuant to para 2, bound by the instructions of these. The subordinate officer can refuse compliance with an instruction if the instruction was given by an executive officer not competent in the matter or compliance would infringe the criminal code.

(2) By law executive officer may

1- for expert review,

2- to control if the administration is in accordance with the law,

3- with arbitration-, mediation- and representation of interests agenda,

4- to safeguard competition and implement economic inspection,

5- to supervise and regulate electronic media and to support the media,

6- to implement certain matters of service- and disciplinary rules,

7- to implement and organize elections, or,

8- to the extent necessary according to the law of the European Union, be dispensed from being bound by instructions of their superior executive officers. Provincial constitutional laws may create further categories of executive officers being not bound by instructions. By law a right of supervision of the highest executive officers adequate to the task of the executive officers being not bound by instructions is to be provided, at least the right of information about all acts of the activity of the executive officers being not bound by instructions and – to the extent the organs are not subject to sub-para 2, 5 and 8 – the right to remove executive officers not bound by instructions from office.

(3) All executive officers entrusted with federal, provinces and municipal administrative duties as well as the executive officers of other public law corporate bodies are, save as otherwise provided by law, pledged to confidentiality about all facts of which they have obtained knowledge exclusively from their official activity and which have to be kept confidential in the interest of the maintenance of public peace, order and security, of comprehensive national defence, of external relations, in the interest of a public law corporate body, for the preparation of a ruling or in the preponderant interest of the parties involved (official confidentiality). Official secrecy does not exist for executive officers appoint-ed by a popular representative body if it expressly asks for such information.

(4) All executive officers entrusted with Federation, provinces and municipal administrative duties as well as the executive officers of other public law corporate bodies shall impart information about matters pertaining to their sphere of competence in so far as this does not conflict with a legal obligation to maintain confidentiality; an onus on professional associations to supply information extends only to members of their respective organizations and this inasmuch as fulfilment of their statutory functions is not impeded. The detailed regulations are, as regards the federal authorities and the self-administration to be settled by federal law in respect of legislation and execution, the business of the Federation; as regards the provinces and municipal authorities and the self-administration to be settled by provincial legislation in respect of framework legislation, they are the business of the Federation while the implemental legislation and execution are provincial business.

Art. 21.

(1) Legislation and execution in matters pertaining to the service code, including the regulations on service contracts, for and staff representation rights of employees of the provinces, the municipalities, and the municipal associations are, save as provided otherwise in the case of all these matters by para 2 below, by art. 14 para 2 and para 3 sub-para d and para 5 sub-para c and art. 14a para 2 sub-para e and para 3 sub-para b incumbent on the provinces. Disputes arising from contractual employment are settled by the courts of justice.

(2) Legislation and execution in matters pertaining to employee protection for functionaries (para 1) and to staff representation of provincial functionaries, in so far as they are not engaged in enterprises, are incumbent on the provinces. In so far as in accordance with the first sentence the provinces are not competent, the aforementioned matters fall within the competence of the Federation.

(3) Save as provided otherwise by this law, the service prerogative with regard to employees of the Federation is exercised by the highest authorities of the Federation. The service prerogative with regard to employees of the provinces is exercised by the highest authorities of the provinces; in so far as this law provides for appropriate exceptions with regard to employees of the Federation, it may be laid down by provincial constitutional law that the service prerogative with regard to employees of the province is exercised by equivalent authorities.

(4) The possibility of an alternation of service between the Federation, the provinces, the municipalities, and the municipal associations remains guaranteed at all times to public employees. Legal provisions, according to which times of service are taken into account differently depending on whether they were served with the Federation, a province, a municipality- or a municipal association, are inadmissible. In order to enable the service code, the staff representation regulations and the employee protection scheme of the Federation, the provinces, and the municipalities to develop along equal lines, the Federation and the provinces shall inform each other about their plans in these matters.

(5) Legislation can provide that

1- civil servants are appointed temporarily for the performance of particular directorial functions or in cases where due to the nature of the duty this is necessary;

2- after expiry of the temporary term or upon change in the organization of the authorities or of the service code structures by law no appointment is necessary;

3- no appointment is necessary in cases of transfer or change in the employment in so far as competence for the appointment is assigned pursuant to art. 66 para 1.

(6) In the cases of para 5 nobody is entitled to an equal position.

Art. 22. All authorities of the Federation, the provinces, the municipalities and the municipality associations as well as the other self-administering entities are bound within the framework of their legal sphere of competence to render each other mutual assistance.

Art. 23.

(1) The Federation, the provinces the municipalities and the other bodies and institutions established under public law are liable for the injury which persons acting on their behalf in execution of the laws have by illegal behaviour culpably inflicted on whomsoever.

(2) Persons acting on behalf of one of the legal entities specified in para 1 above are liable to it, in so far as intent or gross negligence can be laid to their charge, for the injury for which the legal entity has indemnified the injured party.

(3) Persons acting on behalf of one of the legal entities specified in para 1 above are liable for the injury which in execution of the laws they have by illegal behaviour inflicted directly on the legal entity.

(4) The detailed provisions with respect to paras 1 to 3 above will be made by federal law.

(5) A federal law can also provide to what extent special provisions deviating from the principles laid down in paras 1 to 3 above apply in the field of the postal and telecommunication systems.

B- European Union

Art. 23a.

(1) The members of the European Parliament shall in Austria be elected in accordance with the principles of proportional representation on the basis of equal, direct, personal, free and secret suffrage be men and women who have completed their sixteenth year of life on the day of election and on the day appointed for election are either endowed with Austrian nationality and not excluded from suffrage under the provisos of European Union law or endowed with the nationality of another member state of the European Union and qualified to vote under the provisos of European Union Law.

(2) Federal territory constitutes for elections to the European Parliament a single electoral body.

(3) Eligible for election are all those in Austria entitled to vote for the European Parliament having completed their eighteenth year of life on the day of election.

(4) Art. 26 para 5 to 8 is to be applied accordingly.

(5) (Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette I No. 27/2007)

(6) (Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette I No. 27/2007)

Art. 23b.

(1) Public employees who seek a seat in the European Parliament shall be granted the time necessary for the canvassing of votes. Public employees who have been elected to membership of the European Parliament shall for the duration of their duties be suspended from office accompanied by loss of their emoluments. The detailed provisions will be settled by law.

(2) University teachers can continue their activity in research and teaching and their examination activity also while they belong to the European Parliament. The emoluments for such activity shall be calculated in accordance with the services actually performed, but may not exceed twenty-five per cent of a university teacher’s salary.

(3) In so far as this Federal constitutional law stipulates the incompatibility of functions with membership or former membership of the National Council, these functions shall also be incompatible with membership or former membership of the European Parliament.

Art. 23c.

(1) The making of the Austrian presentations for the nomination of members of the European Commission, of members of the Court of Justice, the European Union, of members of the Court auf Auditors, of members of the economic and social committee, of members of the committee of regions and their deputies and of members of the managing committee of the European Investment Bank is incumbent upon the Federal Government.

(2) Before making the presentations for the nomination of members of the European Commission, the Court of Justice, the Court of Auditors and the managing committee of the European Investment Bank the Federal Government has to inform the national council and the Federal President whom it intends to present. The Federal Government shall reach agreement with the main committee of the National Council.

(3) Before making the presentations for the nomination of members of the economic and social committee the Federal Government shall seek proposals from the statutory and other professional bodies of the various groups constituting the economic and social community.

(4) The presentations for the nomination of members of the committee of regions and their deputies shall be made by the Federal Government on the basis of presentations from the provinces as well as from the Austrian Association of Municipalities and the Austrian Communal Association. Each province is to present a member and its deputy; the other members and their deputies are to be presented by the Austrian Municipal Association and the Austrian Communal Association.

(5) The Federal Government shall inform the National Council whom it named pursuant to paras 3 and 4 and the Federal Council whom it named pursuant to paras 2, 3 and 4..

Art. 23d.

(1) The Federation must inform the provinces without delay regarding all projects within the framework of the European Union which affect the provinces autonomous sphere of competence or could otherwise be of interest to them and it must allow them opportunity to present their views within a reasonable interval to be fixed by the Federation. Such comments shall be addressed to the Federal Chancellery. The same holds good for the municipalities in so far as their own sphere of competence or other important interests of the municipalities are affected. Representation of the municipalities is in these matters incumbent on the Austrian Association of Cities and Towns (Austrian Municipal Federation) and the Austrian Association of municipalities (Austrian Communal Federation) (art. 115 para 3).

(2) If the provinces have presented a uniform comment on a project concerning matters where legislation is provincial business, the Federation may in negotiations with and voting in the European Union only deviate from the uniform comment for compelling integration and foreign policy reasons. The Federation must advise the provinces of these reasons without delay.

(3) If a project affects also matters where legislation is provincial business, the Federal Government can assign the right to participate in the meetings of the Council and in such frame to negotiate the project and cast a vote, to a member of a Land Government having been nominated by one of the provinces. The exercise of this authority through the representative of the provinces will be effected in cooperation and in coordination with the competent federal minister; para 2 also applies to him. In matters pertaining to federal legislation the provinces representative is responsible to the National Council, in matters pertaining to provincial legislation to the provincial legislatures in accordance in respect with art. 142.

(4) The more detailed provisions in respect of paras 1 to 3 above shall be established in an agreement between the Federation and the provinces (art. 15a para 1).

(5) The provinces are bound to take measures which, within their autonomous sphere of competence, become necessary for the implementation of juridical acts within the framework of European integration; should a province fail to comply punctually with this obligation and this be established against Austria by a court within the framework of the European Union, the competence for such measures, in particular the issuance of the necessary laws, passes to the Federation. A measure taken by the Federation pursuant to this provision, in particular the issue of such a law or the issue of such an ordinance, becomes invalid as soon as the province has taken the requisite action.

Art. 23e.

(1) The competent federal minister shall without delay inform the National Council and the Federal Council about all projects within the framework of the European Union and afford them opportunity to vent their opinion.

(2) The competent federal minister has to inform the National Council and the Federal Council expressly and timely on an upcoming resolution of the European Council or the Council concerning

1- the change from unanimity to a qualified majority or

2- the change from a special legislation procedure to the regular legislation procedure so that the National Council and the Federal Council are able to act within their competences according to this article.

(3) If the National Council has presented comments to a project aimed at passing a legal act which would affect the passing of federal acts in the field governed by the legal act, the competent federal minister may deviate in negotiations and votings in the European Union from such comment only for deviating integrating and foreign political reasons. If the competent federal minister intends to deviate from the comment of the National Council he has to contact the national Council again. If the project is aimed at passing a binding legal act which either requires the passing of federal constitutional regulations or contains rules which can only be passed by such regulations, such deviation is only admissible if the National Council does not object within adequate time. The competent federal minister has to report to the National Council immediately after the voting in the European Union and eventually name the reasons, for which he deviated from the comment.

(4) If the Federal Council has presented comments to a project aimed at pass-ing a binding legal act which either requires the passing of Federal Constitutional regulations limiting the competence of the provinces in legislation and executive powers according to art. 44 para 2, or contains regulations which can only be passed by such regulations, the competent federal minister may deviate from such comment in negotiations or voting in the European Union only for compelling international and foreign political reasons. A deviation however is only admissible if the Federal Council does not object within adequate time. The competent federal minister has to report to the Federal Council immediately after the voting in the European Union and to eventually name the reasons for which he deviated from such comment.

Art. 23f.

(1) The National Council and the Federal Council exert the competences assigned to the National Parliaments in the Treaty on European Union, the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union and the protocols attached to these treaties, as amended.

(2) Any federal minister reports to the National Council and the Federal Council at the beginning of each year on the projects of the Council and the European Commission to be expected in this year and also on the Austrian position to such projects to be expected.

(3) Further duties of information are to be determined by federal law.

(4) The National Council and the Federal Council may express their wishes on projects of the European Union in comments to the organs of the European Union.

Art. 23g.

(1) The National Council and the Federal Council present their view in a founded comment to a drafted legal act in the frame of the European Union, for which reason the draft is incompatible with the subsidiarity principle.

(2) The National Council and the Federal Council can ask the competent federal minister to make a statement on the compatibility of drafts according to para 1 with the subsidiarity principle, which, in general, has to be presented within two weeks after the request has been served.

(3) The Federal Council is to inform the Provincial Parliaments immediately on all drafts according to para 1 and give them the opportunity to make comments. When resolving a founded statement according to para 1, the Federal Council has to consider the comments of the Provincial Parliaments and to inform them on such resolutions.

Art. 23h.

(1) The National Council and the Federal Council may resolve to raise claim against a legal act in the frame of the European Union at the Court of the European Union for violating the subsidiarity principle.

(2) The office of the Federal Chancellor sends the claim in the name of the National Council or the Federal Council immediately to the Court of the European Union.

Art. 23i.

(1) The Austrian member in the European Council may agree to an initiative according to article 8 para 7 of the Treaty on the European Union as amended by the Lisbon agreement only having been authorized by the National Council, with the approval of the Federal Council, on the basis of a proposal of the Federal Government. Such resolutions of the National Council and the Federal Council each require the presence of at least of the half of the number of members and a majority of two thirds of the votes cast.

(2) To the extent the law of the European Union for the National Parliaments provides the possibility of the refusal of an initiative or a proposal concerning

1- the change from unanimity to a qualified majority or

2- the change from a special legislation procedure to the regular legislation procedure,

the National Council, with the approval of the Federal Council, may refuse such initiative or proposal within the terms provided by the law of the European Union.

(3) Resolutions of the Council by which new categories of own means of the European Union shall be established, require the authorization by the National Council and the approval of the Federal Council; art. 50 para 4 second phrase is to be applied accordingly. Other resolutions of the Council determining regulations on the system of own means of the European Union require the approval by the National Council. Art. 23e para 2 is to be applied accordingly.

(4) Art. 50 para 4 is to be applied accordingly to other resolutions of the European Council or the Council, which enter into force according to the law of the European Union only after approval by the member states in accordance with their respective constitutional rules.

(5) Resolutions of the National Council and of the Federal Council under this article are to be published by the Federal Chancellor in the Federal Law Gazette.

Art. 23j.

(1) Austria participates in the common foreign and security policy of the European Union on the basis of title V chapter 1 and 2 of the Treaty on the European Union, as amended by the Lisbon-agreement, which provides in article 3 para 5 and in art. 21 para 1 especially the observance of resp. respect for the principles of the charter of the United Nations. This includes the participation in duties according to art. 43 para 1 of this contract and measures by which the economic and financial relations to one or several third countries are suspended, restricted or completely severed. Art. 50 para 4 is to be applied accordingly to resolutions of the European council concerning a common defence.

(2) Article 23e para 3 is to be applied accordingly to resolutions in the frame of the common foreign and security policy of the European Union on the basis of Title V chapter 2 of the contract on the European Union as amended by the Lis-bon-agreement.

(3) The right of vote concerning resolutions on the start of a mission out of the European Union, the tasks of military consultation and support, tasks of conflict prevention and maintaining peace or combat operations in the frame of crisis management, including peace-making measures and operations to stabilize the situation after conflicts, as well as on decisions under art. 42 para 2 of the Treaty on the European Union, as amended by the Treaty of Lisbon concerning the step by step determination of a joint defence policy, is to be exerted by coordination between the Federal Chancellor and the minister competent for foreign relations.

(4) If the decision to be adopted is likely to entail an obligation for Austria to dispatch units or individual persons, measures to be taken in accordance with para 3 may be approved only with the reservation that this still requires the conduct of the procedure provided for under constitutional law governing the dispatch of units or individual persons to other countries.

Art. 23k.

(1) More detailed provisions regarding art. 23e, 23f para 1, 2 and 4 as well as 23g to 23j are made by federal act on the standing order of the National Council and the standing order of the Federal Council..

(2) The competences of the National Council under art. 23e, 23f para 4, 23g and 23j para 2 are incumbent on its main committee. The federal law on the standing order of the National Council may provide, that the main committee elects a permanent subcommittee, to which art. 55 para 3 applies accordingly. The main committee may confer competences to this permanent subcommittee under to the first phrase. Such transfer can be revoked completely or partially any time. By the federal law on the standing order of the National Council competences of the main committee may be transferred under the first phrase to the National Council or to the permanent subcommittee of the main council according to the second phrase.

(3) Competences of the Federal Council under art. 23e, 23f, para 4 and 23g may be transferred by the standing order of the Federal Council to a committee it has to elect.

Chapter II

Federal Legislation

A- The National Council

Art. 24. The legislative power of the Federation is exercised by the National Council jointly with the Federal Council.

Art. 25.

(1) The seat of the National Council is Vienna, the federal capital.

(2) For the duration of extraordinary circumstances the Federal President can at the request of the Federal Government convoke the National Council elsewhere within the federal territory.

Art. 26.

(1) The National Council is elected by the federal people in accordance with the principles of proportional representation on the basis of equal, direct, personal, free and secret suffrage by men and women who have completed their sixteenth year of life on the day of election.

(2) The federal territory will be divided into self-contained constituencies whose boundaries may not overlap the provincial boundaries; these constituencies shall be sub-divided into self-contained regional constituencies. The number of deputies will be divided among the qualified voters of the constituencies (electoral bodies) in proportion to the number of nationals who in accordance with the result of the last census had their principal domicile in a particular constituency plus the number of those who on the day of the census did not have their principal domicile in federal territory, but were entered on the electoral register of a municipality pertaining to that particular constituency; the number of deputies allocated to a constituency will be divided in the same way among the regional constituencies. The National Council electoral regulations shall provide for a final distribution procedure relating to the whole federal territory whereby in accordance with the principles of proportional representation which ensures a balance between the seats allocated to the parties standing for election in the constituencies and the distribution of the as yet unallocated seats. A division of the electorate into other electoral bodies is not admissible.

(3) The day of election must be a Sunday or a statutory holiday. If other circumstances arise that impede the start, the continuation or the conclusion of the election, the electoral board can prolong to the next day or adjourn the election

(4) Eligible for election are those being entitled to vote for the National Council, who are in the possession of the Austrian nationality on the key date and have completed their eighteenth year of life on the day of election.

(5) Exclusion from the right to vote or eligibility, also to respectively varying extent may only be provided by federal law as consequence of a final sentence by the courts.

(6) Persons entitled to vote presumably prevented on the day of election to cast their vote before the electoral authority, for example for absence, for reasons of health or staying abroad may make use of their right to vote by postal ballot upon application indicating the reason. The identity of the applicant is to be proven prima facie. The qualified voter has to declare by signature in lieu of oath, that the vote has been cast personally and confidentially.

(7) The electoral register will be drawn up by the municipalities as part of their assigned sphere of competence.

(8) Further details of the electoral procedure are determined by federal law.

Art. 26a. The implementation and organization of the elections to the European Parliament, the National Council, the Federal President and of referenda and consultations of the people as well as the participation in the control of popular initiatives as well as the participation in the implementation of European citizens’ action groups is incumbent to election authorities being constituted anew before each election to the National Council. Members of the campaigning parties have to sit in the election authority, as committee members, having a vote, in the federal election authority also active or retired judges; the number of committee members is to be determined in the election rules to the National Council. The members not being judges shall be appointed on the basis of proposals of the campaigning par-ties corresponding to their proportion in the preceding election to the National Council. Parties represented in the recently elected National Council not being entitled to the appointment of committee members are however entitled to propose a committee member for the federal election authority.

Art. 27.

(1) The legislative period of the National Council lasts five years, calculated from the day of its first meeting, but in any case until the day on which the new National Council meets.

(2) The newly elected National Council shall be convened by the Federal President within thirty days after the election. The latter shall be so arranged by the Federal Government as to enable the newly elected National Council to meet on the day after the expiry of the fifth year of the legislative period.

Art. 28.

(1) The Federal President convokes the National Council each year for an ordinary session which shall not begin before 15 September and not last longer than 15 July the following year.

(2) The Federal President can also convoke the National Council for extraordinary sessions. If the Federal Government or at least one third of the members of the National- or the Federal Council so demands, the Federal President is bound to convoke the National Council for an extraordinary session to meet moreover with-in two weeks of the demand reaching him; the convocation needs no countersignature. A request by members of the National Council or by the Federal Council does not require a recommendation by the Federal Government.

(3) The Federal President declares sessions of the National Council closed in pursuance of a vote by the National Council.

(4) Upon the opening of a new National Council session within the same legislative period work will be continued in accordance with the stage reached at the close of the last session. At the end of a session individual committees can be instructed by the National Council to continue their work. From the beginning of a legislative period popular initiatives and citizens’ initiatives submitted to the National Council are regarded as business for the newly elected National Council. The federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders can determine the same for further business.

(5) During a session the President of the National Council convokes the individual sittings. If during a session the number of members stipulated by the federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders or the Federal Government so demands, the President is bound to convoke a sitting. More detailed provisions are settled by the federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders which shall also prescribe a period within which the National Council must convene.

(6) The federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders shall lay down special provisions for its convocation in the event of the elected President’s being precluded from the performance of their office or being deprived of their functions.

Art. 29.

(1) The Federal President can dissolve the National Council, but he may avail himself of this prerogative only once for the same reason. In such case the new election shall be so arranged by the Federal Government that the newly elected National Council can at the latest meet on the hundredth day after the dis-solution.

(2) Before expiry of a legislative period the National Council can vote its own dissolution by simple law.

(3) After a dissolution pursuant to para 2 above as well as after expiry of the period for which the National Council has been elected, the legislative period lasts until the day on which the newly elected National Council meets.

Art. 30.

(1) The National Council elects the President, the Second and Third Presidents from among its members.

(2) The business of the National Council is conducted in pursuance of a special federal law. The Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders can only be passed in the presence of half the members and by a two thirds majority of the votes cast.

(3) The parliamentary staff, which is subordinate to the President of the National Council, is competent for the assistance with parliamentary tasks and the conduct of administrative matters within the scope of the authorities of the federation’s legislature as well as of similar tasks and administrative matters concerning the members of the European Parliament having been elected in Austria. The internal organization of the parliamentary staff for matters pertaining to the Federal Council shall be settled in agreement with the chairman of the Federal Council who is likewise invested with authority to issue instructions as to implementation of the functions assigned to the Federal Council on the basis of the law.

(4) The nomination of parliamentary staff employees and all other competences in personnel matters lie with the President of the National Council.

(5) The President of the National Council can second Parliamentary Staff employees to parliamentary parties for help in the fulfilment of parliamentary duties.

(6) The President of the National Council is the highest administrative authority in the execution of the administrative matters for which he is in accordance with this article competent and he exercises these powers in his own right. He mag issue ordinances inasmuch as these exclusively concern administrative matters regulated by this article.

Art. 31. Save as otherwise provided in this law or as otherwise laid down in the Federal law on the Standing Orders with regard to individual matters, the presence of at least one third of the members and an absolute majority of the votes cast is requisite to a vote by the National Council.

Art. 32.

(1) The sessions of the National Council are public.

(2) The public shall be excluded if the chairman or the number of members established in the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders so demands and the National Council votes this after the withdrawal of the audience.

Art. 33. No one shall be called to account for publishing the accounts of proceedings in the public sessions of the National Council and its committees.

B- The Federal Council

Art. 34.

(1) Pursuant to the following provisions, the provinces are represented in the Federal Council in proportion to the number of nationals in each Land.

(2) The province with the largest number of citizens delegates twelve members, every other province as many as the ratio in which its nationals stand to those in the first-mentioned province, with remainders which exceed half the coefficient counting as full. Every province is however entitled to a representation of at least three members. A substitute will be appointed for each member.

(3) The number of members to be delegated by each province accordingly will be laid down after every general census by the Federal President.

Art. 35.

(1) The members of the Federal Council and their substitutes are elected by the Provincial Parliament for the duration of their respective legislative periods in accordance with the principle of proportional representation but at least one seat must fall to the party having the second largest number of seats in a Provincial Parliament or, should several parties have the same number of seats, the second highest number of votes at the last election to the Provincial Parliament. When the claims of several parties are equal, the issue shall be decided by lot.

(2) The members of the Federal Council need not belong to the Provincial Parliament which delegates them; they must however be eligible for that Provincial Parliament.

(3) After expiry of the legislative period of a Provincial Parliament or after its dissolution the members delegated by it to the Federal Council remain in office until such time as the new Provincial Parliament has held the election to the Federal Council.

(4) The provisions of Arts. 34 and 35 can only be amended – apart from the majority of votes requisite in general to the adoption of a resolution there – if in the Federal Council the majority of the representatives from at least four provinces has approved the amendment.

Art. 36.

(1) The provinces succeed each other in alphabetical order every six months in the chairmanship of the Federal Council.

(2) As chairman acts the top-listed representative of the province designated for the chair, whose mandate goes to the party having the largest number of seats in the Provincial Parliament or, if several parties have an equal number of seats, had the highest number of voters in the most recent Provincial Parliament election; in case of equal entitlements of several parties the decision is made by lot. However, the Provincial Parliament can resolve, that the chair shall be held by another representative of the province, whose mandate in the Federal Council is with the same party; such resolution however requires the approval of the majority of those members of the Provincial Parliament, whose mandates in the Provincial Parliament are with this party. The appointment of the deputies of the chairman is governed by the Federal Council´s Standing Orders. The chairman carries the title “President of the Federal Council”, his deputies carry the title “Vice-President of the Federal Council”.

(3) The Federal Council will be convoked by its chairman at the seat of the National Council. The chairman is bound immediately to convoke the Federal Council if at least one quarter of its members or if the Federal Government so demands.

(4) The Governors are entitled to participate in all Federal Council proceedings. In accordance with the specific rules of the Federal Council’s Standing Orders they have at their request always the right to be heard on business relating to their province.

Art. 37.

(1) Save as otherwise provided by this law or as otherwise laid down in the Federal Council’s Standing Orders in regard to individual matters, the presence of at least one third of the members and an absolute majority of the votes cast is requisite for a resolution by the Federal Council.

(2) The Federal Council furnishes itself with Standing Orders by way of resolution. This resolution can only be adopted in the presence of half the members with a two thirds majority of the votes cast. Provisions effectual also beyond the internal scope of the Federal Council can be made in the Standing Orders in so far as this is requisite for its handling of business. The Standing Orders have the status of a federal law; they shall be published by the Federal Chancellor in the Federal Law Gazette.

(3) The meetings of the Federal Council are public. Nevertheless the public can, pursuant to the provisions of the Standing Orders, be excluded by resolution. The provisions of Art. 33 apply also to public meetings of the Federal Council and its committees.

C- The Federal Assembly

Art. 38. The National Council and the Federal Council meet as the Federal Assembly in joint public session at the seat of the National Council for the affirmation of the Federal President as well as for the adoption of a resolution on a declaration of war.

Art. 39.

(1) Apart from the cases stated in Art. 60 para 6 Art. 63 para 2, Art. 64 para 4 and Art. 68 para 2, the Federal Assembly is convoked by the Federal President. The chairmanship alternates between the President of the National Council and the chairman of the Federal Council, beginning with the former.

(2) The Federal Law on the National Council’s Standing Orders is applied analogously in the Federal Assembly.

(3) The provisions of Art. 33 hold good also for the sessions of the Federal Assembly.

Art. 40.

(1) The resolutions of the Federal Assembly are authenticated by its chairman and countersigned by the Federal Chancellor.

(2) The resolutions of the Federal Assembly upon a declaration of war shall be officially published by the Federal Chancellor.

D- Federal Legislative Procedure

Art. 41.

(1) Legislative proposals are submitted to the National Council as motions by its members, by the Federal Council or by one third of the Federal Council’s members, and as bills by the Federal Government.

(2) Every motion by 100,000 voters or by one sixth each of the voters in three provinces (henceforth called “popular initiative”) shall be submitted by the federal electoral board to the National Council for action. The right to vote, as to popular initiatives, appertains to those who on the last day of registration for National Council suffrage and have their principal domicile in a municipality in federal territory. The popular initiative must concern a matter to be settled by federal law and can be put forward in the form of a draft law.

(3) The detailed provisions on the procedure for the popular initiative shall be made by federal Law.

Art. 42.

(1) Every enactment of the National Council shall without delay be conveyed by its President to the Federal Council.

(2) Save as otherwise provided by constitutional law, an enactment can be authenticated and published only if the Federal Council has not raised a reasoned objection to this enactment.

(3) This objection must be conveyed to the National Council in writing by the chairman of the Federal Council within eight weeks of the enactment’s arrival; the Federal Chancellor shall be informed thereof.

(4) If the National Council in the presence of at least half its members once more carries its original resolution, this shall be authenticated and published. If the Federal Council resolves not to raise any objection or if no reasoned objection is raised within the deadline laid down in para 3 above, the enactment shall be authenticated and published.

(5) The Federal Council has no claim to participation in so far as National Council enactments concern the National Council’s Standing Orders, the dissolution of the National Council, a federal law providing detailed regulations on the making of the Federal finance frame law, the Federal finance law and on the household of the Federation a Federal finance law, a temporary provision consonant with Art. 51a para 4 or a disposal of federal property, the assumption or conversion of a federal liability, the contraction or the conversion of a federal monetary debt, the sanction of a final federal budget account.

Art. 42a. To the extent an enactment of the National Council requires the approval of the provinces, it is to be notified by the Federal Chancellor according to Art. 42 immediately after the procedure has been closed to the offices of the provincial governments of the provinces concerned. The approval is deemed to be granted if the Governor of the province does not notify the Federal Chancellor within eight weeks after the day on which the enactment has been served to the office of the government of the province, that the approval is denied. Before expiration of this period the enactment may only be published if the Governors of the provinces concerned have notified the express approval by the province.

Art. 43. If the National Council so resolves or if the majority of members of the National Council so demands, every enactment of the National Council shall be submitted to a referendum upon conclusion of the procedure pursuant to Art. 42 resp. pursuant to Art. 42a but before its authentication by the Federal President.

Art. 44.

(1) Constitutional laws or constitutional provisions contained in simple laws can be passed by the National Council only in the presence of at least half the members and by a two thirds majority of the votes cast; they shall be explicitly specified as such (“constitutional law”, “constitutional provision”).

(2) Constitutional laws or constitutional provisions contained in simple laws restricting the competence of the provinces in legislation or execution require furthermore the approval of the Federal Council which must be imparted in the presence of at least half the members and by a two thirds majority of the votes cast.

(3) Any total revision of the Federal Constitution shall upon conclusion of the procedure pursuant to Art. 42 above but before its authentication by the Federal President be submitted to a referendum by the federal people whereas any partial revision requires this only if one third of the members of the National Council or the Federal Council so demands.

Art. 45.

(1) For a referendum the absolute majority of the validly cast votes is decisive.

(2) The result of a referendum shall be officially announced.

Art. 46.

(1) A referendum takes place at the order of the Federal President.

(2) Entitled to vote in referenda is who possesses the suffrage to the National Council on the day of the referendum

(3) The detailed provisions on the procedure for the plebiscite shall be made by federal Law. Art. 26 para 6 is to be applied accordingly.

Art. 47.

(1) The constitutional enactment of federal laws is authenticated by the Federal President.

(2) The submission for authentication is effected by the Federal Chancellor.

3) The authentication shall be countersigned by the Federal Chancellor.

Art. 48. Federal laws and state treaties having been approved according to Art. 50 para 1 will be published with reference to their adoption by the National Council, federal laws based upon a referendum with reference to the result of that referendum.

Art. 49.

(1) Federal laws shall be published by the Federal Chancellor in the Federal Law Gazette. Unless explicitly provided otherwise, their entry into force begins with expiry of the day of their promulgation and it extends to the entire Federal territory.

(2) The state treaties according to Art. 50 para 1 are to be published by the Federal Chancellor in the Federal Law Gazette. In case a state treaty according to Art. 50 para 1 subpara 1 has been laid down in more than two languages authentically, it is sufficient if

1- two authentic language versions and a translation into the German language,

2- if, however, the German language version is authentic, such and a further authentic language version are published. The National Council can on the occasion of the approval of state treaties pursuant to Art. 50 para 1 resolve in which other way than in the Federal Law Gazette the publication of the state treaty or single parts exactly to be specified shall take place; such resolutions of the Federal Council are to be published by the Federal Chancellor in the Federal Law Gazette. Unless explicitly provided otherwise, state treaties according to Art. 50 para 1 enter into force upon expiry of the day of its publication – in the case of the third phrase upon expiry of the date of proclamation of the resolution of the National Council – and extend to the entire Federal territory; this does not apply to state treaties to be implemented by passing laws (Art. 50 para 2 subpara 4).

(3) Announcements in the Federal Law Gazette and according to para 2 second phrase must be accessible to the general public and be ascertained completely and forever in the published form.

(4) The detailed provisions on the proclamation of the republication on the Federal Law Gazette shall be made by federal Law.

Art. 49a.

(1) The Federal Chancellor is empowered jointly with the competent Federal Ministers to restate federal laws, with the exception of this law, and treaties published in the Federal Law Gazette in their valid version by promulgation in the Federal Law Gazette.

(2) In the proclamation of the republication

1- obsolete terminological expressions can be rectified and outdated spelling assimilated to the new manner of writing;

2- references to other regulations which no longer tally with current legislation as well as other inconsistencies can be rectified;

3- provisions which have been nullified by later regulations or otherwise rendered void can be declared no longer valid;

4- title abridgements and alphabetical abbreviations of titles can be laid down;

5- the designations of articles, sections, paragraphs, and the like can in case of elimination or insertion be correspondingly altered and in this connection references thereto within the text of the regulation be appropriately rectified;

6- interim provisions as well as earlier still applicable versions of the federal law (treaty) can by specification of their purview be summarized.

(3) Unless explicitly provided otherwise republished federal law (the republished treaty) and the other regulations contained in the promulgation enter into force upon expiry of the day of promulgation.

Art. 49b.

(1) A consultation of the people on a matter of fundamental and overall national importance for whose settlement the legislature is competent must take place if the National Council votes it by reason of a motion from its members or from the Federal Government. Elections and matters subject to a decision by a court or an administrative authority cannot be the topic of a consultation of the people.

(2) A motion pursuant to para 1 above must include a proposal for the formulation of the question to be basically put in the consultation of the people. This must consist either of a question to be answered with “Yes” or “No” or of two alternative solution proposals.

(3) Consultations of the people shall be implemented in a manner analogous to Arts. 45 and 46. The right to vote, as to consultations of the people, appertains to those who on the day appointed for consultation possess National Council suffrage. The federal electoral board must submit the result of a consultation to the National Council and the Federal Government.

(4) Participation of the National Council and of the Federal Council in the Execution by the Federation

Art. 50.

(1) The conclusion of

1- Political state treaties and state treaties the contents of which modify or complement existent laws and do not fall under Art. 16 para 1, as well as

2- Treaties by which the contractual bases of the European Union are modified, require the approval of the National Council.

(2) To treaties according to para 1 subpara 1 additionally the following applies:

1- In case a treaty provides its simplified modification such modification does not require approval according to para 1, unless the National Council has reserved such approval.

2- To the extent a treaty settles matters falling within the autonomous sphere of competence of the provinces it requires the approval by the Federal Council.

3- In case a treaty has been laid down authentically in more than two languages, it is sufficient, if the approval under para 1 is granted

(a) on the basis of two authentic language versions and a translation into the German language,

(b) if, however, the German language version is authentic, on the basis of such and a further authentic language version.

4- At the time of approval of a treaty, the National Council can resolve to which extent the treaty in question shall be implemented by the issue of laws.

(3) Art. 42 paras 1 to 4 inclusive shall be analogously applied to resolutions of the National Council in accordance with paras 1 subpara 1 and para 2 subpara 4 above.

(4) Notwithstanding Art. 44 para 3 treaties according to para 1 subpara 2 may only be concluded with the approval of the National Council and the approval of the Federal Council. These resolutions each require the presence of at least half of its members and the majority of two thirds of the votes cast.

(5) The National Council and the Federal Council are to be informed without delay on the beginning of negotiations of a treaty according to para 1.

Art. 50a. The National Council participates in matters of the European stability mechanism.

Art. 50b. An Austrian representative in the European stability mechanism may only agree or abstain in voting to

1- a proposal for a resolution to grant stability aid to a member state in principle

2- an alteration of the approved share capital and an adaptation of the maximum loan volume of the European Stability Mechanism as well as the calling of approved share capital not having been paid in and

3- amendments of the financial aid instruments,

if the National Council has authorized him to do so on the basis of a proposal of the Federal Government. In cases of special urgency the Federal Minister in charge may consult with the National Council. Without approval by the National Council the Austrian representative must refuse the proposal for such a resolution.

Art. 50c.

(1) The Federal Minister in charge has to inform the National Council immediately in matters of the European Stability Mechanism according to the regulations in the Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council. The Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council has to provide the right of comments by the National Council.

(2) To the extent the National Council has made comments in matters of the European Stability Mechanism in due time, the Austrian representative in the European Stability Mechanism has to respect them in negotiations and votings. The Federal Minister in charge has to report to the National Council immediately after the voting and eventually to disclose the reasons for which the Austrian representative did not respect the comments.

(3) The Federal Minister in charge regularly reports to the National Council on the measures taken in the frame of the European Stability Mechanism.

Art. 50d.

(1) Further details to Art. 50b and 50c para 2 and 3 are determined in the Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council.

(2) The Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council may provide additional competences of the National Council for the participation in the exertion of the voting right by Austrian representatives in the European Stability Mechanism.

(3) For the participation in matters of the European stability mechanism the committee of the National Council in charge of preparatory advice for federal financial laws elects permanent sub-committees. At least one member of any party represented in the main committee of the National Council must sit on any of these sub-committees. Competences of the National Council under para 2, Art. 50b and 50c may be transferred to these standing sub-committees by the Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council. The Federal law on the Standing Orders of the National Council has to provide, that the permanent sub-committees can be convened and meet any time. If the National Council is dissolved by the Federal President according to Art. 29 para 1, the participation in matters of the European stability mechanism is incumbent on the permanent sub-committees.

Art. 51.

(1) The National Council votes the Federal Finance Frame Law and within its limits the Federal Finance Law. The respective federal government’s draft shall form the basis of the debates.

(2) The Federal Government has to submit to the National Council every year the latest at a deadline fixed in a federal law, the draft of a Finance frame law or the draft of a federal law by which the Federal Frame Finance Law is modified. The Federal Finance Frame Law has to contain upper limits for the financial means to be approved by the National Council in the respective Financial Frame Law to be approved on the basis of categories as well as the basics of the personal planning; exempted from this is the use of means for the repayment of financial debts and of monetary commitments for the temporary strengthening of cash funds and the use of means as result of capital exchange in case of foreign exchange agreements. For further subcategories upper limits are to be provided for the sub-sequent financial year and the next following three financial years.

(3) The Federal Government must submit to the National Council the draft of a Federal Finance Law for the ensuing fiscal year for which a Federal Finance Law is to be resolved at the latest ten weeks before the beginning of the fiscal year. Exceptionally the Federal Government may submit the draft of a Federal Finance Law also for the subsequent and the next following finance year, separate according to the years, to the National Council.

(4) In case a Federal Finance Law is passed for the subsequent and the next subsequent finance year, in the second half of the subsequent finance year, the draft of a federal law, modifying the Federal Finance Act, is to be submitted by the Federal Government the latest ten weeks before the beginning of the next subsequent finance year, to the National Council. The modifications of the Federal Finance Law contained therein have in any case to make reference to the next subsequent finance year. The draft is to be negotiated by the National Council till the end of the subsequent finance year. Art. 51 a para 1 and para 2 are to be applied accordingly.

(5) The Federal Finance Law shall include as annexes the federal budget estimates and the personal planning as well as other elements material for the management of the household.

(6) To the management of the household of the Federation apply.

1- Upper limits of the categories of the Federal Finance Frame Law may neither be exceeded nor may such exceeding the authorized.

2- The upper limits of the subcategories, to be determined by a federal law according to para 7 of the Federal Financial Frame Law for the subsequent financial year, must not be exceeded nor may such exceeding be authorized, unless a federal law according to para 9 provides, that these up-per limits may be exceeded with the approval of the Federal Minister of Finance.

If exceptionally a Federal Finance Law is passed for the subsequent and the next subsequent financial year, the regulations of para 2 are to be applied with the proviso, that the upper limits named in para 2 last phrase apply to the subsequent and the next subsequent year.

(7) The upper limits of para 6 subpara 1 and 2 may be exceeded in the following cases:

1- In case of imminent danger, on the basis of an ordinance of the Federal Government, in consent with the Committee of the National Council entrusted with preliminary consultation of Federal Financial Laws, unforeseeable and unobjectionable additional means to the extent of a maximum of 2/1000 of the means allowed for by the Federal Finance Law may be provided, if coverage is safeguarded. If the Committee of the National Council in charge of preliminary consultation does not render a decision within two weeks consent deems to be given.

2- In case of defence, for the purpose of comprehensive military defence (Art. 9a) unobjectionable additional means within the financial year up to the amount of a total of 10/100 of the means having been provided for by Federal Financial Law for spending may be provided on the basis of an ordinance of the Federal Government in consent with the Committee of the National Council in charge of preliminary consultation for Federal Finance Laws. To the extent the allocation of such additional means cannot be safeguarded by economization of means or additionally raised means the ordinance of the Federal Government has to authorize the Minister for Finance to care for the necessary allocation of means by making or con-version of financial debts.

(8) In the management of the federal budgets the principles of striving for efficiency, mainly under respect of the goal of equal treatment of women and men, transparency, efficiency and a true picture of the financial situation of the Federation as much as possible are to be respected.

(9) The more detailed provisions as to the preparation of the Federal Finance Frame Act, the Federal Finance Act and as to the other management of the federal household shall be settled in conformity with uniform principles in accordance with the provisions of para 8 by federal law. The latter shall in particular prescribe:

1- the measures for an administration striving for efficiency, especially also under respect of the goal of equal treatment of women and men;

2- the measures to safeguard transparency including the duty to render reports to the Committee of the National Council in charge of preliminary consultation regarding Federal Finance Laws;

3- the making, structuring and binding effect of the Federal Finance Frame Law;

4- the structuring of federal budget;

5- the binding effect of the Federal Financial Law, mainly regarding the aspects of time and amount;

6- the arguments for debts in advance including the preconditions which, if met, debts in advance require an ordinance of the Federal Minister for Finance in consent with the Committee of the National Council in charge of the preliminary consultation of Federal Finance Laws or statutory authorization;

7- the creation of positive and negative budget reserves;

8- disposition on federal assets including the preconditions which, if met, require an ordinance of the Federal Minister for Finance in consent with the Committee of the National Council in charge of the preliminary consultation of Federal Finance Laws or statutory authorization;

9- the assumption of liabilities by the Federation;

10- making or conversion of liabilities by procuring financial means, which are not redeemed within the same financial year or through long term financing (financial debts);

11- incentive- and sanction mechanisms;

12- controlling;

13- participation of the Court of Audit for the correctness of accountancy.

Article 51a.

(1) In case the Federal Government has not presented to the National Council in due time (Art. 51 para 2 and 3) the draft of a Federal Finance Frame Act or a Federal Finance Act, a draft of a Federal Finance Frame Act or a Federal Finance Act may also be brought in by the members of the National Council.

(2) In case the Federal Government presents the draft of a Federal Finance Frame Law or a Federal Finance law after such proposal has been brought forward, the National Council may resolve to consider either draft in its deliberations.

(3) In case the National Council has not passed a Federal Finance Frame Law in a Financial year, the upper limits of the most recent financial year, for which upper limits had been determined, continue to apply.

(4) If the National Council does not pass a Federal Finance Law for a financial year and likewise makes no temporary provision by way of a federal law, the federal household is to be managed according to the provisions of the most recently passed Federal Finance Law. Monetary debts then can only be incurred to half of the respectively anticipated ceiling amounts as well as short term commitments for the temporary reinforcement of cash holdings.

Article 51b

(1) The Federal Minister for Finance has to provide that in managing the budget first obligations due will be covered and then the other spending of means will be made, however on the condition they can be covered and under respect of the principles according to Art. 51 para 8.

(2) If the development of the federal Budget so requires or in the course of the financial year an essential change of the national economical development begins to emerge, the Federal Minister for Finance, with the approval of the Federal Government or on the basis of authorization under the Federal Finance Law, in order to control the federal Budget may earmark a certain percentage of the spending of means provided by the Federal Finance Law, to the extent this does not affect the meeting of due obligations of the Federation. Within one month after the earmarking he has to report to the Committee of the National Council in charge of the preliminary consultations for Federal Finance Laws.

(3) The Federal Minister for Finance has to regularly inform the members of the Federal Government and the other leading budgeting organs on the implementation of the budget.

Article 51c.

(1) The use of means, not provided for in the Federal Finance Law or exceeding the use of means approved by the National Council may only be made on the basis of an authorization by Federal Finance Law.

(2) The National Council may authorize the Federal Minister for Finance and the Federal Finance Law to approve the exceeding of the use of means provided for in the Federal Finance Law. Such authorization may only be granted to the extent the exceeding is linked to preconditions on material grounds and is specified or computable in amount. Furthermore, upon agreement by the Federal Minister for Finance, the use of means provided for in the Federal Finance Law may be exceeded,

1- on the basis of a statutory obligation,

2- in case of an existing financial debt or on the basis of currency exchange agreements or

3- on the basis of another obligation already existing at the time the Federal Financial Law enters into force.

The approval on the basis of the provisions of this paragraph may only be granted in case of an unforeseen requirement and only to the extent as coverage is safe-guarded and the respectively binding applicable upper limits according to Art. 51 para 2 and 6 for the relevant financial year are not exceeded. The Federal Minister for Finance may transfer the authorizations granted on the basis of the provisions of this paragraph for the approval to exceed the use of means having been provided for with the exceptions of those according to subpara 2 – in consent with the leading budgeting organs in charge, to the heads of official executive officers, to the extent this is necessary to implement an administration striving for efficiency.

(3) The Federal Minister for Finance has to report quarterly to the Committee of the National Council in charge of the preliminary consultations for Federal Finance Laws on the measures taken according to para 2.

Article 51d.

(1) A participation of the National Council in the budget management is incumbent on the Committee of the National Council in charge of the preliminary consultations for Federal Finance Laws. It may transfer certain agenda to a permanent sub-committee on which also the participation in the budget management is incumbent, in case the National Council is dissolved by the Federal President according to Art. 29 para 1. The Committee in charge of the preliminary consultations for Federal Finance Laws and its permanent sub-committee are also to be convened when the National Council (Art. 28) is not in session, if necessary. The Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council provides further details.

(2) Any further reports beyond Art. 51b para 2 and 51c para 3 are to be sub-mitted to the Committee of the National Council in charge of the preliminary consultations for Federal Finance Laws with regard to specific federal legal provisions.

Art. 52.

(1) The National Council and the Federal Council are entitled to examine the administration of affairs by the Federal Government, to interrogate its members about all subjects pertaining to execution, and to demand all relevant information as well as to ventilate in resolutions their wishes about exercise of the executive power.

(1a) The competent committees of the National Council and the Federal Council are entitled to demand the presence of the head of an executive body being not bound by instructions according to Article 20 para 2 in the sessions of the committees and to interrogate him on all subjects of the administration of affairs.

(2) Rights of control pursuant to para 1 hold good as regards the Federal Government and its members likewise in respect of enterprises in which the Federation has a participation of at least fifty per cent in the share, stock, or equity capital and which is subject to the control of the Public Audit Office. Such a financial participation shall be deemed equivalent to the domination of enterprises by way of different financial or other economic or organizational measures. This applies also to enterprises at every further level where the prerequisites pursuant to this paragraph are on hand.

(3) Every member of the National Council and the Federal Council is entitled during the sessions of the National Council and the Federal Council to address brief oral questions to members of the Federal Government.

(4) The detailed regulations respecting the right of interrogation will be settled by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders as well as in the Federal Council’s Standing Orders.

Art. 52a.

(1) The National Council’s competent committees each elect a standing sub-committee of inquiry to review measures for the safeguard of constitutionally established agencies as well as their operative capacity and intelligence measures to secure the country’s military defence. Each sub-committee must include at least one member from each of the parties represented in the Main Committee of the National Council.

(2) The standing sub-committees are empowered to require from the competent Federal Ministers all relevant information and insight into the relevant materials. This does not apply to information and material, in particular about sources, whose disclosure would endanger national security or the safety of individuals.

(3) The standing sub-committees can, if need be, meet at times others than those of National Council sessions.

(4) The Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders settles detailed provisions.

Art. 52b.

(1) For the scrutiny of a particular proceeding in a matter relating to the federal financial administration the Committee constituted pursuant to Art. 126d para 2 elects a standing sub-committee. At least one member from every party represented in the National Council’s Main Committee must belong to this sub-committee.

(2) The detailed provisions are settled by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders.

Art. 53.

(1) The National Council can by resolution set up committees of inquiry.

(2) The detailed regulations respecting the establishment of, and the procedure for, committees of inquiry will be settled by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders.

(3) The courts and all other authorities are obliged to comply with the request of these committees to take evidence; all public departments must on demand produce their files.

Art. 55.

(1) The National Council elects its main committee from its members in accordance with the principle of proportional representation.

(2) Should the need arise, the main committee shall be convoked also between sessions of the National Council (Art. 28).

(3) The Main Committee elects from its members a standing sub-committee upon which devolve the powers stipulated by this law. The election takes place in accordance with proportional representation; respect for this principle must nonetheless allow for inclusion in the sub-committee of at least one member of every party represented in the main committee. The Federal Law on the Standing Orders of the National Council must provide that the standing sub-committee can be convoked and can meet at any time. If the National Council in accordance with Art. 29 para 2 is dissolved by the Federal President, participation in the executive power which in accordance with this law otherwise lies with the National Council (main committee) devolves upon the standing sub-committee.

(4) It can be stipulated by federal law that certain general acts of the Federal Government or a Federal Minister need the agreement of the main committee as well as that reports be rendered to the main committee by the Federal Government or a Federal Minister. More detailed provisions, especially if no agreement is reached, are settled by the Federal Law on the National Council’s Standing Orders.

(5) As regards ordinances by the competent Federal minister concerning control measures for safeguarding undisturbed production or the supply of the population and other consumers with essential economic and consumer goods, provision shall be made for obtaining the consent of the National Council’s Main Committee; in an emergency and for the repeal of such ordinances, special regulations may be adopted. Resolutions of the main committee approving such ordinances can only be adopted in the presence of at least half of its members and by a two-thirds majority of the votes cast.

F- Status of Members of the National Council and the Federal Council

Art. 56.

(1) The members of the National Council and the members of the Federal Council are bound in the exercise of their function by no mandate.

(2) If a member of the Federal Government or a State Secretary has relinquished his seat as a member of the National Council, the competent electoral board shall again assign him the seat when he has left office, in the circumstances of Art. 71 after release from entrustment with continuation of the administration, provided that he has not within eight days advised the board of his disclaimer to the renewed exercise of his mandate.

(3) This renewed assignment ends the mandate of that National Council member who has held the seat of the temporarily retired member in so far as an-other, subsequent National Council member did not on the occasion of nomination to the seat in the same constituency declare to the electoral board his wish to exercise the mandate as deputy for the temporarily retired member of the National Council.

(4) Paras 2 and 3 also hold good if a member of the Federal Government or a State Secretary has not accepted his election to membership of the National Council.

Art. 57.

(1) The members of the National Council may never be made responsible for votes cast in the exercise of their function and only by the National Council on the grounds of oral or written utterances made in the course of their function.

(2) The members of the National Council may on the ground of a criminal offence – the case of apprehension in the act of committing a crime excepted – be arrested only with the consent of the National Council. Domiciliary visitations of National Council members likewise require the National Council’s consent.

(3) Legal action on the ground of a criminal offence may otherwise without the National Council’s consent be taken against members of the National Council only if it is manifestly not connected with the political activity of the member in question. The authority concerned must however seek a decision by the National Council on the existence of such a connection if the member in question or a third of the members belonging to the standing committee entrusted with these matters so demands. Every act of legal process shall in the case of such a demand immediately cease or be discontinued.

(4) In all these instances the consent of the National Council counts as grant-ed if within eight weeks it has not given a ruling on an appropriate request by the authority competent for the institution of legal action; the President, with a view to the National Council’s adoption of a resolution in good time, shall at the latest put such a request to the vote on the day but one before expiry of the deadline. The latter does not include the period when the National Council is not in session.

(5) In case of a member’s apprehension in the act of committing a crime, the authority concerned must immediately notify the President of the National Council of the occurrence of the arrest. If the National Council or when it is not in session the standing committee entrusted with these matters so demands, the arrest must be suspended or the legal process as a whole be dropped.

(6) The immunity of members ends with the day of the meeting of the newly elected National Council, that of functionaries of the National Council whose tenure of office extends beyond this date on the expiry of this term of office.

(7) The detailed provisions are settled by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders.

Art. 58. The members of the Federal Council enjoy for the whole duration of their tenure of office the immunity of the members of the Provincial Parliament which has delegated them.

Art. 59. No member of the National Council, the Federal Council or the European Parliament can simultaneously belong to one of the two other representative bodies.

Art. 59a.

(1) A public employee who seeks a seat in the National Council shall be granted the time necessary for the canvassing of votes.

(2) A public employee who is a member of the National Council or the Federal Council shall, at his request, be granted leave of absence or be retired for the time necessary for the fulfilment of his membership duties. During leave of absence, pay shall correspond to the amount of work actually performed within the framework of service duties, but shall not exceed 75 per cent of total pay; this limit also applies if no use is made either of leave of absence or retirement. Retirement entails the termination of all service-related payments.

(3) If it is not possible for a public employee to be appointed to his previous post because of the fulfilment of his membership duties, he is entitled to be as-signed a reasonably equivalent – if he agrees, also a not equivalent – activity. The pay shall be determined by the activity actually performed by the employee.

Art. 59b.

(1) To control the pay of public employees who have been elected members of the National Council or Federal Council, a Commission will be set up under the auspices of the Parliamentary Staff. The Commission consists of:

1- one representative nominated by each of the Presidents of the National Council,

2- two representatives nominated by the Chairman of the Federal Council with the consent of his deputies,

3- two representatives of the provinces,

4- two representatives of the municipalities, and

5- one member who previously exercised a judicial function.

The members in accordance with subparas 3 to 5 shall be appointed by the Federal President; in its recommendation (Art. 67) regarding subpara 3, the Federal Government shall be bound by a joint recommendation by the Provincial Governors and regarding subpara 4 by a recommendation by the Austrian Federation of Local Authorities and a recommendation by the Austrian Union of Towns. The members of the Commission according to subparas 1 to 4 must be persons who previously exercised a function within the meaning of Art. 19 para 2. A person who pursues a gainful occupation cannot be a member of the Commission. Membership in the Commission terminates with the expiry of the legislative period, but not before a new member has been nominated or appointed.

(2) At the request of a public employee, who is a member of the National Council or the Federal Council, or at the request of his employing authority, the Commission gives an opinion on disputes arising between the public employee and his employing authority in the execution of Article 59a or in respect of regulations issued in its implementation. The Commission also gives opinions on such disputes arising between a judge and chamber or a commission within the meaning of Art. 87 para 2 as well as on disputes arising between a member of the National Council or the Federal Council and the President of the National Council in the execution of Art. 30 para 3.

(3) The member of the National Council or Federal Council who is a public employee is obligated to inform the Commission each year about the arrangement he has made in respect of his leave of absence or retirement in accordance with Art. 59a and how the work to be performed by him will be reviewed. Art. 53 para 3 shall analogously apply to inquiries by the Commission. The Commission furnishes itself with standing orders. Each year, the Commission shall file a report with the National Council – as far as members of the Federal Council are concerned, with the Federal Council -, which shall be published.

Chapter III

Federal Execution

A- Administration

1- The Federal President

Art. 60.

(1) The Federal President is elected by the federal people on the basis of equal, direct, personal, free and secret suffrage by men and women having suffrage to the National Council. If there is only one candidate, the election shall take place by way of referendum. Article 26 para 5 to 8 is to be applied accordingly.

(2) The candidate who polls more than half of all valid votes has been elect-ed. If no such majority results, a second ballot takes place. Votes in this can validly be cast only for one of the two candidates who have polled the most votes in the first ballot.

(3) Only a person who is eligible to the National Council and has completed the thirty-fifth year of life on the day of the election can be elected Federal President.

(4) The result of the election of the Federal President shall be officially published by the Federal Chancellor.

(5) The Federal President holds office for six years. Reelection for the immediately following term of office is admissible once only.

(6) Before expiry of his term of office the Federal President can be impeached by referendum. The referendum shall be held if the Federal Assembly so demands. The Federal Assembly shall be convoked by the Federal Chancellor for this purpose if the National Council has passed such a motion. The National Council vote requires the presence of at least half the members and a majority of two thirds of the votes cast. By such a National Council vote the Federal President is prevented from the further exercise of his office. Rejection of the impeachment by the referendum holds good as a new election and entails the dissolution of the National Council (Art. 29 para 1). In this instance too the Federal President’s total term of office may not exceed twelve years.

Art. 61.

(1) During his tenure of office the Federal President may not belong to any general representative body nor exercise any other occupation.

(2) The title “Federal President” may not – even with an addition or in the context of another designation – be used by anyone else. It is safeguarded by law.

Art. 62.

(1) On his assumption of office the Federal President renders the following affirmation before the Federal Assembly:

“I solemnly promise that I shall faithfully observe the constitution and all the laws of the Republic and shall fulfil my duty to the best of my knowledge and belief.”

(2) The addition of a religious asseveration is admissible.

Art. 63.

(1) The institution of legal process against the Federal President is only admissible if the Federal Assembly has agreed.

(2) The application for the institution of legal process against the Federal President shall be filed by the competent authority with the National Council which votes whether the Federal Assembly shall deal with the matter. If the National Council pronounces in favour of this, the Federal Chancellor must immediately convoke the Federal Assembly.

Art. 64.

(1) All the Federal President’s responsibilities, should he be prevent-ed from their discharge, pass in the first instance to the Federal Chancellor. A sojourn in another member state of the European Union is not deemed to be an impediment. If the impediment lasts longer than twenty days or if pursuant to Art. 60 para 6 the Federal President is prevented from the discharge of his office, the President, the Second President, and the Third President of the National Council acting as a committee shall undertake the responsibilities of the Federal President. The same holds good if the position of the Federal President is continuously in abeyance.

(2) The committee entrusted according to para 1 above with the exercise of the Federal President’s functions decides by majority vote. Chairmanship of the committee devolves on the President of the National Council, likewise its representation in public.

(3) Is one or are two of the National Council’s Presidents prevented from the discharge of their responsibilities or is their position continuously in abeyance, the committee still constitutes a quorum even without their participation; in the event of a tie, the President senior in rank has the casting vote.

(4) In case the position of the Federal President is continuously in abeyance, the Federal Government shall immediately arrange the election of the new Federal President; after the ensuing election the committee shall without delay convoke the Federal Assembly for the affirmation of the Federal President.

Art. 65.

(1) The Federal President represents the Republic internationally, receives and accredits envoys, sanctions the appointment of foreign consuls, appoints the consular representatives of the Republic abroad and concludes state treaties. Upon the conclusion of a state treaty not falling under Art. 50 or a state treaty pursuant to Art. 16 para 1 which neither modifies nor complements existent laws, he can direct that the treaty in question shall be implemented by the issue of ordinances.

(2) Furthermore there is vested in him – apart from the powers assigned to him in accordance with other provisions of this constitution – authority:

(a) to appoint federal civil servants, including officers as well as other federal functionaries, and to bestow official titles on them;

(b) to create and to bestow professional titles;

(c) in individual cases: to pardon persons sentenced without further resources of appeal, to mitigate and commute sentences pronounced by the courts, as an act of grace to annul sentences and to grant remission from their legal consequences, and moreover to quash criminal proceedings in actions subject to prosecution ex officio;

(d) on the petition of parents to declare illegitimate children legitimate.

(3) Special laws provide to what extent powers are additionally vested in the Federal President with respect to the grant of honorary privileges, extraordinary gratifications, allowances and pensions, the right to nominate and confirm persons in appointments and to exercise other powers in personnel matters.

Art. 66.

(1) The Federal President can assign to the competent members of the Federal Government the right vested in him to appoint certain categories of federal civil servants and empower them to delegate, as regards certain categories of federal civil servants, this competence to authorities subordinate to him.

(2) The Federal President can authorize the Federal Government or the competent members of the Federal Government to conclude certain categories of state treaties which neither fall under Art. 16 para 1 nor under Art. 50; such an authorization extends also to the power to order that these treaties shall be implemented by the issue of ordinances.

(3) The Federal President can on the recommendation of a Land Government and with the counter-signature of the Governor authorize the Land Government to conclude treaties in accordance with Art. 16 para 1 when they neither modify nor complement existing laws; such an authorization extends also to the power to direct that these treaties shall be implemented by the issue of ordinances.

Art. 67.

(1) Save as otherwise provided by the Constitution, all official acts of the Federal President shall be based on recommendation by the Federal Government or the Federal Minister authorized by it. The law provides to what extent the Federal Government or the competent Federal Minister is herein dependent on recommendations from other quarters.

(2) Save as otherwise provided by the Constitution, all official acts of the Federal President require for their validity the countersignature of the Federal Chancellor or the competent Federal Minister.

Article 67a.

(1) The office of the Federal President, being sub-ordinate to the Federal President is called to assist him performing his official affairs. Details on the course of business in the president´s office may be regulated by a standing order to be issued by the Federal President.

(2) Article 67 does not apply to the standing order of the president’s office, for the appointment of employees of the president’s office and the bestowing of official titles in exerting the supervise.

Art. 68.

(1) Pursuant to Art. 142, the Federal President is responsible to the Federal Assembly for the exercise of his functions.

(2) To assert this responsibility, the Federal Assembly shall on the vote of the National Council or the Federal Council be convoked by the Federal Chancellor.

(3) The presence of more than half the members of each of the two representative bodies and a majority of two thirds of the votes cast is requisite to a vote whereby a charge, consonant with Art. 142, is preferred against the Federal President.

2- The Federal Government

Art. 69.

(1) The Federal Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor and the other Federal Ministers are entrusted with the highest administrative business of the Federation in so far as this is not assigned to the Federal President. They constitute as a body the Federal Government under the chairmanship of the Federal Chancellor.

(2) The Vice-Chancellor is entitled to deputize for the Federal Chancellor in his entire sphere of competence. Should the Federal Chancellor and the Vice-Chancellor simultaneously be prevented from the discharge of their responsibilities, the most senior – in the case of equal seniority, the eldest – member of the Federal Government who is not prevented from the discharge of his duties shall deputize for the Federal Chancellor.

(3) The Federal Government has a quorum when more than half of its members are present.

Art. 70.

(1) The Federal Chancellor and, on his recommendation, the other members of the Federal Government are appointed by the Federal President. No recommendation is requisite to the dismissal of the Federal Chancellor or the whole Federal Government; the dismissal of individual members of the Federal Government ensues on the recommendation of the Federal Chancellor. The appointment of the Federal Chancellor or the whole Federal Government is counter-signed by the newly appointed Federal Chancellor; dismissal requires no counter-signature.

(2) Only persons eligible for the National Council can be appointed Federal Chancellor, Vice-Chancellor, or Federal Minister; members of the Federal Government need not belong to the National Council.

(3) Should a new Federal Government be appointed by the Federal President at a time when the National Council is not in session, he must convoke the Nation-al Council for an extraordinary session (Art. 28 para 2), and that to meet within one week, for the purpose of introducing the new Federal Government.

Art. 71. Should the Federal Government have left office, the Federal President shall entrust members of the outgoing Government with continuation of the administration and one of them with the chairmanship of the provisional Federal Government. A State Secretary attached to an outgoing Federal Minister or a senior civil servant in the Federal Ministry concerned can likewise be entrusted with continuation of the administration. This provision applies analogously if individual members of the Federal Government have left office. Whoever is entrusted with continuation of the administration bears the same responsibility as a Federal Minister (Art. 76).

Art. 72.

(1) Before their assumption of office the members of the Federal Government render an affirmation to the Federal President. The addition of a religious asseveration is admissible.

(2) The instruments of appointment for the Federal Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor, and the other Federal Ministers are executed by the Federal President on the day of the affirmation and are countersigned by the newly appointed Federal Chancellor.

(3) These provisions shall apply analogously to the cases mentioned in Art. 71 above.

Art. 73.

(1) Should a Federal Minister be temporarily prevented from discharging his responsibilities, he instructs, in consent with another Federal Minister, the very, a state secretary attached to him or a senior civil servant of the respective Federal Ministry to deputize for him. Such instruction to deputize is to be notified to the Federal President and the Federal Chancellor. A sojourn in another member state of the European Union is not deemed to be an impediment. If a Federal Minister is not in the situation to deputize in the sense of the first phrase, the Federal Chancellor, in consent with the deputy chancellor, instructs another Federal Minister, a state secretary attached to the prevented Federal Minister or a senior civil servant of the respective Federal Ministry to deputize. Such instruction to deputize is to be notified to the Federal President. The deputy carries the same responsibility as a Federal Minister (Art.76).

(2) The Federal Minister competent for a matter can assign to another Federal Minister or a State Secretary the power to participate in the sessions of the council and within this framework to conduct the negotiations respecting a particular project and to vote thereon.

(3) A member of the Federal Government who is staying in another member state of the European Union may let his business in the National Council or Federal Council be taken care of by a State Secretary attached to him or another Federal Minister. A member of the Federal Government, who is not deputized for, may assign his right to vote in the Federal Government to another Federal Minister; this does not affect his accountability. The voting right may only be assigned to a member of the Federal Government who has not already been entrusted with deputizing for another member of the Federal Government and whom a voting right has not already been assigned to.

Art. 74.

(1) If the National Council passes an explicit vote of no confidence in the Federal Government or individual members thereof, the Federal Government or the Federal Minister concerned shall be removed from office.

(2) The presence of half the members of the National Council is requisite to a vote of no confidence in the National Council. Voting shall however be adjourned until the next working day but one if the number of members stipulated by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders so demands. A fresh adjournment of the voting can ensue only from a decision by the National Council.

(3) Notwithstanding the power otherwise vested in the Federal President in accordance with Art. 70 para 1, the Federal Government or its individual members shall in the legally specified contingencies or at their own wish be removed from office.

Art. 75. The members of the Federal Government as well as the State secretaries are entitled to participate in all deliberations by the National Council, the Federal Council, and the Federal Assembly as well as the committees (subcommittees) of these representative bodies, but only at special invitation in the deliberations by the standing sub-committee of the national council’s main committee and by the national council’s committees of inquiry. On each occasion they must, in accordance with the detailed provisions of the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders and of the Federal Council’s Standing Orders, at their request be given a hearing. The National Council, the Federal Council, and the Federal Assembly as well as their committees (subcommittees) can require attendance by members of the Federal Government and request them to initiate investigations.

Art. 76.

(1) Pursuant to Art. 142, the members of the Federal Government (Arts. 69 and 71) are responsible to the National Council.

(2) The presence of more than half the members is requisite to a motion which prefers a charge pursuant to Art. 142.

Art. 77.

(1) The Federal Ministries and the authorities subordinate to them shall perform the business of the federal administration.

(2) The number of the Federal Ministries, their competence, and their internal organization will be prescribed by federal law.

(3) The Federal Chancellor is entrusted with the direction of the Federal Chancellery and a Federal Minister is entrusted with the direction of each of the other Federal Ministries. The Federal President can assign to special Federal Ministers the direction of particular matters which fall within the federal chancellery’s competence, including the personnel establishment and organization of such business, notwithstanding that these matters continue to appertain to the Federal Chancellery; such Federal Ministers have in respect of the matters in question the status of a competent Federal Minister.

(4) The Federal Chancellor and other Federal Ministers can exceptionally be entrusted with the direction of a second Federal Ministry.

Art. 78.

(1) In special cases Federal Ministers can be appointed without at the same time being put in charge of a Federal Ministry.

(2) State Secretaries, who are appointed and leave office in the same way as Federal Ministers, can be attached to Federal Ministers for assistance in the con-duct of business and to deputize for them in parliament. The Federal Chancellor may let his business in the National Council and in the Federal Council in accord with the vice chancellor being entrusted to head a Federal Ministry be taken care of by a state secretary attached to him. The vice chancellor, being entrusted to head a Federal Ministry may let his business in the National Council and in the Federal Council be taken care of by a state secretary attached to him, in consent with the Federal Chancellor.

(3) The Federal Minister can with his consent likewise entrust the State Secretary with the conduct of certain functions. In the fulfilment of these the State Secretary is also subordinate to the Federal Minister and bound by his instructions.

3- The Federal Security Authorities

Art. 78a.

(1) The supreme security authority is the Federal Minister of the Interior. Subordinate to him are the police directorates of the provinces followed by the district administrative authorities in their capacity as security authorities.

(2) If the life, health, freedom or property of individuals are actually in danger or such danger is directly impending, security officials are, irrespective of the competence of another authority for repulse of the hazard, competent to render primary assistance till the intervention of the respective competent authority.

(3) Federal laws provide to what extent municipalities authorities must take action as security authorities.

Art. 78b.

(1) Every province has a police directorate. Its head is the provincial police director. In Vienna the provincial police director of the police directorate of the province bears the title „President of the police of the Province“.

(2) The Federal Minister of the Interior appoints the police director of the province in agreement with the Governor.

(3) The Federal Minister of the Interior must inform the Governor of every nationally important instruction or such as is crucial for the maintenance of peace, order and security throughout the province which he issues to a director of the police of the province.

Art. 78c. Federal law provides to which extent the police directorate of a province simultaneously is security authority in first instance for the area of a municipality.

Art. 78d.

(1) Constabularies are armed or uniformed or otherwise militarily patterned units invested with tasks of a police character. In particular not to be counted among the constabularies are guard personnel established for the protection of certain branches of soil cultivation, such as agriculture and forestry (field, crops, and forest protection), for mining, hunting, fishing or other licensed water usages, market supervision officials, and fire brigades.

(2) In the area of a municipality, where the police directorate of the province simultaneously is security authority in first instance no other regional authority may set up a constabulary.

4- The Federal Army

Art. 79.

(1) The country’s military defence is the duty of the Federal Army. It shall be conducted on the principles of a militia system.

(2) The Federal Army, as the civil power is in accordance with the law and claims its cooperation, has furthermore

1- also beyond above the sphere of the country’s military defence

(a) to protect the constitutionally established institutions as well as their capacity to operate and the population’s democratic freedoms,

(b) to maintain order and security inside the country in general;

2- to render assistance in the case of natural catastrophes and disasters of exceptional magnitude.

(3) Additional tasks of the Federal Army will be prescribed by federal constitutional law.

(4) The Defence Law regulates which officials and authorities can lay direct claim to the co-operation of the Federal Army for the purposes mentioned in para 2 above.

(5) Intervention by the military on its own initiative for the purposes mentioned in para 2 above is admissible only if circumstances outside their control have put it beyond capacity of the competent officials to effect intervention by the military and irreparable damage the community at large would arise from a further wait or if it concerns the repulse of an actual attack, or the elimination of active resistance directed against a section of the Federal Army.

Art. 80.

(1) Commander-in-Chief of the Federal Army is the Federal President.

(2) Save in so far as the Defence Law reserves disposal over the Federal Army to the Federal President, disposal over it lies with the competent Federal Minister within the limits of the authorization conferred on him by the Federal Government.

(3) Supreme command over the Federal Army is exercised by the competent Federal Minister (Art. 76 para 1).

Art. 81. Federal law prescribes to what extent the provinces participate in the recruitment, provisioning and accommodation for the Army and the supply of its other requirements.

5- The Federal School Authorities

Art. 81a.

(1) The administration of the Federation in the field of schooling and in the field of education in matters pertaining to student hostels shall be undertaken by the competent Federal Minister and – insofar as neither the university and tertiary education system nor the agricultural and forestry school system, including the agricultural and forestry educational system in matters pertaining to student hostels, nor central teaching institutions are concerned – by the school authorities of the Federation subordinate to the competent Federal Minister. The municipalities can, as part of the Federation’s assigned sphere of competence, be called upon to maintain registers of those who are of school-attendance age.

(2) A school authority shall be established in each province and be known as the provincial school board. In Vienna the provincial school board shall be known as the “Vienna City School Board”. The applicable sphere of competence for members of the provincial school boards shall be prescribed by federal law.

(3) The following guiding principles shall hold good for the establishment, to be prescribed by law, of the Federal school authorities:

(a) Within the provincial school boards, committees shall be appointed whose members, who have the right to vote, shall be appointed in proportion to party strength in the Provincial Parliament. The appointment of all or some of the committee members by the Provincial Parliament is admissible.

(b) The Governor shall be the president of the provincial school board. Should the appointment of an executive provincial school board president be foreseen by law, he shall deputize for the president in all business which the president does not reserve to himself. Should the appointment of a vice-president be foreseen by law, he is entitled to inspect documents and to proffer advice; such a vice-president shall in any case be appointed for those five provinces which, in accordance with the result of the last census taken prior to this Federal constitutional law coming into force, have the largest number of inhabitants.

(c) The terms of reference for the committees and the presidents of the provincial school boards shall be regulated by law. The committees shall be competent to issue rules and general instructions, to appoint officials and to render proposals for nominations as well as to render opinions on drafts of laws and ordinances.

(d) In cases of urgency which do not admit of postponement until the committee’s next meeting, the president shall take action in the sphere of competence allocated to the committee as pertaining to its business and with-out delay inform the committee of this.

(e) Should for more than two months a committee lack a quorum the tasks of the committee for the further period of its numerical incapacity devolve upon the president. In these cases the president replaces the committee.

(4) Instructions (Art. 20 para 1) cannot be given on matters which fall into the committees sphere of competence. This does not hold good for instructions which forbid the implementation of a committee resolution as being contrary to law or which direct the repeal of an ordinance issued by the committee. The reasons for such instructions shall be stated.

(5) The competent Federal Minister can satisfy himself in person or through officials of the Federal Ministry in his charge about the condition and performance of those schools and student hostels which are subordinate to the Federal Ministry by way of the provincial school board. Established shortcomings – in so far as they do not concern such in the sense of Art. 14 para 8 – shall be notified to the provincial school board for the purpose of their redress.

Art. 81b.

(1) The provincial school board shall render a proposal of three candidates:

(a) for the filling of federal vacancies for headmasters/headmistresses as well as other teachers and educational assistants at schools and student hostels subordinate to the provincial school boards;

(b) for the filling of federal vacancies for the school supervisory officials serving with the provincial school boards as well as for the appointment of teachers with school supervisory functions;

(c) (Note: repealed by Federal Law Gazette I No. 164/2013)

(2) The proposals in accordance with para 1 above shall be rendered, pursuant to Art. 66 para 1 or Art. 67 para 1 or by reason of other provisions, to the competent Federal Minister. The selection of individuals from among those proposed is incumbent on the Federal Minister.

(3) Every provincial school board shall establish eligibility and disciplinary school boards for headmasters/headmistresses and other teachers as well as educational assistants who are employees under public law of the Federation and are employed at a school (student hostel) subordinate to the provincial school board. The details shall be prescribed by federal law.

6- Universities

Art. 81c.

(1) The public universities are places of free scientific research, tuition and revelation of the arts. The act in the frame of the laws autonomously and may render statutes. The members of university collegial bodies are dispensed from instructions.

(2) Federal law may provide that the activity at the university as well as the participation in bodies of the university and the representation of the students by persons not having the Austrian nationality is admissible.

(3) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 51/2012)

B- Jurisdiction of the Courts of Justice

Art. 82.

(1) The Federation is the source of the jurisdiction of the Courts of Justice.

(2) Judgements and decisions are pronounced and drawn up in the name of the republic.

Art. 83.

(1) The organization and competence of the Courts of Justice is laid down by federal law.

(2) No one may be deprived of his lawful judge.

(3) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. No. 73/1968)

Art. 84. Military jurisdiction – except in time of war – is repealed.

Art. 85. Capital punishment is abolished.

Art. 86.

(1) Save as provided otherwise by this law, judges are appointed pursuant to the proposal of the Federal Government by the Federal President or, by reason of his authorization, by the competent Federal Minister; the Federal Government or the Federal Minister shall obtain proposals for appointment from the chambers competent according to federal law.

(2) If a sufficient number of candidates is available, the proposal for appointment to be submitted to the competent Federal Minister and to be forwarded by him to the Federal Government shall comprise at least three names, but if there is more than one vacancy to be filled at least twice as many names as there are judges to be appointed.

Art. 87.

(1) Judges are independent in the exercise of their judicial office.

(2) A judge is in the exercise of his judicial office during the performance of any judicial function properly his by law and the allocation of business, though to the exclusion of the judiciary’s administrative business which in accordance with the provisions of the law shall not be discharged by chambers or commissions.

(3) Business shall be allocated in advance among the judges of the Court of justice for the period provided by federal law on the organization of the courts. A matter devolving upon a judge in accordance with this allocation may be removed from his jurisdiction only by decree of the chamber competent, in case of his being prevented from the discharge of his responsibilities or his being unable to cope with his duties, due to their extent, within a reasonable time.

Art. 87a.

(1) The performance of certain kinds of business, which shall be exactly specified and fall within the jurisdiction of a court of first instance, can by federal law be assigned to specially trained personnel of the Federation who are not judges.

(2) The judge competent in accordance with the allocation of business can however at any time reserve to himself or take over the discharge of such business.

(3) The personnel of the Federation which is not a judge is bound in the performance of business specified in para 1 above only by instructions from the judge competent in accordance with the allocation of business. Art. 20 para 1 third sentence shall apply.

Art. 88.

(1) A federal law will determine an age limit upon whose attainment judges will permanently retire.

(2) Otherwise judges may be removed from office or transferred against their will or superannuated only in the cases and ways prescribed by law and by reason of a formal judicial decision. These provisions do not however apply to transfers and retirements which become necessary through a change in the organization of the courts. In such a case the law will lay down within what period judges can without the formalities otherwise prescribed be transferred and superannuated.

(3) The temporary suspension of judges from office may take place only by decree of the head of a district court or president of a court or the superior judicial authority together with simultaneous reference of the matter to the competent court of justice.

Art. 88a. Federal law may provide for posts of substitute judges assigned to a superior court of justice. The number of such posts may not exceed three per cent of the number of judge posts assigned to the subordinate courts of justice. The employment of the substitute judges in charge at subordinate courts of justice and eventually at the superior court itself shall be determined by the competent chamber of the superior court, defined by federal law. Substitute judges may be entrusted only with the substitution of judges of subordinated courts of justice resp. of judges at the superior court of justice itself and only if these judges are prevented from the discharge of their responsibilities or are unable to cope with their duties, due to the extent of these, within a reasonable time.

Art. 89.

(1) Save as otherwise provided by the following paragraphs, the courts of justice are not entitled to examine the validity of duly published ordinances, proclamations of the republication of a law (treaty), laws and treaties.

(2) Should a court of justice have concerns regarding the application of an ordinance on the ground of its contrary to law, regarding the proclamation of a republication of a law (treaty) on the ground of its contrary to law, regarding a law on the ground of its being unconstitutional or regarding a treaty on the ground of its being unlawful, the court shall file an application with the Constitutional Court to repeal that piece of legislation.

(3) If the legal regulation to be applied by the court of justice has already become ineffective, the court of justice’s application to the Constitutional Court must request a decision that the legal regulation was contrary to law, unconstitutional or unlawful.

(4) Federal law shall determine what effects an application pursuant to para 2 or para 3 above has on the proceedings pending at the court of justice.

Art. 90.

(1) Hearings in civil and criminal cases at the court of justice are oral and public. Exceptions are regulated by law.

(2) In criminal proceedings the procedure is by indictment.

Art. 90a. Public prosecutors are functionaries of the jurisdiction. They represent the investigation and prosecution in cases for acts carrying a penalty by court. Federal law determines the detailed regulations on their being bound to instructions of their superior functionaries.

Art. 91.

(1) The people shall participate in the jurisdiction.

(2) A jury returns a verdict upon the guilt of the accused in crimes entailing severe penalties, to be specified by law, and in all cases of political felonies and misdemeanours.

(3) In criminal proceedings for other punishable offences lay assessors take part in the administration of justice if the penalty to be imposed exceeds a limit to be determined by law.

Art. 92.

(1) The Supreme Court is the court of final instance in civil and criminal suits.

(2) Members of the Federal Government, a Land Government, a general representative body or the European parliament cannot be members of the Supreme Court. For members of a general representative body or the European parliament elected for a fixed term of legislation or office such incompatibility continues until the expiry of that term of legislation or office even though they prematurely renounce their seat. Anyone who during the preceding five years has exercised one of the aforesaid functions cannot be appointed President or Vice-President of the Supreme Court.

Art. 93. General amnesties for acts punishable by the courts are extended by federal law.

Art. 94.

(1) Judicial and administrative powers shall be separate at all levels of proceedings.

(2) Federal or provincial legislation may provide in specific matters an appeal from the administrative authority to a court of justice instead of an appeal to the administrative court. In the matters of execution of the Federation not directly handled by federal authorities, as well as in the matters of Art. 11, 12, 14 para 2 and 3 and 14a para 3 and 4 federal laws may, in accordance with the first phrase, only be published upon approval by the provinces. To provincial legislation ac-cording to the first phrase Art. 97 para 2 applies accordingly.

Chapter IV

Legislation and Execution by the Provinces

A- General Provisions

Art. 95.

(1) The legislation of the provinces is carried out by the Provincial Parliament. The Provincial Parliaments are elected by equal, direct, personal, free and secret suffrage on the basis of proportional representation by the male and female provincial citizens who in accordance with the Provincial Parliament electoral regulations are entitled to vote. Provincial law regulates the detailed provisions respecting the electoral procedure and, if need be, the compulsory voting. This provincial law shall in particular prescribe the grounds on which non-participation in the election notwithstanding compulsory voting is deemed to be excused. The constitution of a province may provide that nationals, who had a residence in the province, before moving their domicile abroad are entitled to vote for the duration of this sojourn abroad, for a maximum period of ten years.

(2) The Provincial Parliament electoral regulations may not impose more stringent conditions for suffrage and electoral eligibility than does the federal constitution for elections to the National Council.

(3) The voters exercise their franchise in self-contained constituencies which can be divided into self-contained regional constituencies. The number of deputies shall be divided among the constituencies in proportion to the numbers of inhabitants. The Provincial Parliament electoral regulations can provide for a final distribution procedure throughout the province whereby a balance between the seats allocated to the candidate parties in the constituencies and likewise a distribution of the as yet unallocated seats is effected in accordance with the principles of proportional representation. A division of the electorate into other electoral bodies is not admissible.

(4) Detailed regulations on the election procedure shall be determined by the Provincial Parliament´s Standing Orders. Art. 26 para 6 is to be applied accordingly.

(5) To public employees who seek a seat in the Provincial Parliament or who are elected to membership of a Provincial Parliament, Art. 59a shall apply, stricter regulations are admissible. Provincial constitutional law can create an institution with the same powers and the same obligation to publicize a report as those of the Commission under Art. 59b.

Art. 96.

(1) The members of a Provincial Parliament enjoy the same immunity as the members of the National Council; the provisions of Art. 57 are applied analogously.

(2) The provisions of Arts. 32 and 33 hold good also for the meetings of Provincial Parliament and their committees.

(3) Provincial law can determine upon a settlement in according with Art. 56 paras 2 to 4 for Provincial Parliament members who resign their seat on the occasion of their election to membership of the Federal Council or Land Government.

Art. 97.

(1) A provincial law requires a vote by a Provincial Parliament, authentication and countersignature in accordance with the provisions of the province concerned, and publication by the Governor in the Provincial Law Gazette.

(2) Inasmuch as a provincial law foresees in its execution the cooperation of Federal authorities the approval of the Federal Government must be obtained. Such enactments are to be notified immediately after the resolution of the Provincial Parliament by the Governor to the office of the Federal Chancellor. The approval shall be deemed granted if within eight weeks after the day of the enactment’s receipt at the Federal Chancellery the Federal Government has not in-formed the governor that the co-operation of the federal authorities is refused. Before the expiry of this deadline publication of the enactment may only ensue if the Federal Government has expressly agreed.

(3) If the immediate enactment of measures which constitutionally require the adoption of a resolution by the Provincial Parliament becomes necessary to avert manifest, irreparable harm to the community as a whole in circumstances where the Provincial Parliament is unable to meet in time or is impeded in its function by events beyond its control, the Land Government can in agreement with a Provincial Parliament committee appointed in accordance with the principle of proportional representation take these measures by way of temporarily law-amending ordinances. The Land Government must inform the Federal Government thereof without delay. The Provincial Parliament shall be convened as soon as the impediment to its meeting has ceased to be operative. Art. 18 para 4 holds good analogously.

(4) The ordinances specified in para 3 above may in any case not signify an alteration to provincial constitutional provisions and may neither comprise a permanent financial burden for the province nor a financial burden for the Federation or the municipalities, nor financial commitments for the state’s nationals, nor a disposal of provincial property, nor measures pertaining to the matters specified in Art. 12 para 1 subpara 6, nor lastly such as relate to the affairs of the chambers of labour engaged in agriculture and forestry.

Art. 99.

(1) The provincial constitution to be enacted by a provincial constitutional law can, inasmuch as the Federal Constitution is not affected thereby, be amended by provincial constitutional law.

(2) A provincial constitutional law can be passed only in the presence of half the members of the Provincial Parliament and with a two thirds majority of the votes cast.

Art. 100.

(1) Every Provincial Parliament can be dissolved by the Federal President on the request of the Federal Government and with the sanction of the Federal Council; such a dissolution may however be decreed only once for the same reason. The motion in the Federal Council must be carried in the presence of half the members and with a two thirds majority of the votes cast. The representatives of the province whose Provincial Parliament is to be dissolved may not participate in the division.

(2) In case of dissolution writs for new elections shall within three weeks be issued in accordance with the provisions of the provincial constitution; the convocation of the newly elected Provincial Parliament must ensue within four weeks after the election.

Art. 101.

(1) The executive power in each province is exercised by a Land Government to be elected by the Provincial Parliament.

(2) The members of a Land Government need not belong to the Provincial Parliament. Nevertheless only persons eligible for the Provincial Parliament can be elected to membership of the Land Government.

(3) The Land Government consists of the Governor, the requisite number of deputies, and other members.

(4) Before assumption of office the Governor renders to the Federal President, the other members of the Land Government render to the Governor an affirmation with respect to the federal constitution. The addition of a religious asseveration is admissible.

Art. 101a. The publication of the legal provisions to be published in the Law Gazette of the province can be made in the frame of the legal information system of the Federation.

Art. 102.

(1) In the sphere of the provinces, in so far as no federal authorities exist (direct federal administration), the Governor and the provincial authorities subordinate to him exercise the executive power of the Federation (indirect federal administration). In so far as federal authorities are entrusted with the execution of matters which are performed as indirect federal administration, these federal authorities are subordinate to the governor and bound by his instructions (Art. 20 para 1); whether and to what extent such federal authorities are entrusted with executive acts is regulated by federal laws; these may, in so far as they do not concern the mandate stated in para 2 below, only be published with the sanction of the provinces concerned.

(2) The following matters can within the framework of the constitutionally established sphere of competence be directly performed by federal authorities:

demarcation of frontiers, trade in goods and livestock with other countries, customs, regulation and control of entry into and exit from federal territory, the right of abode for humanitarian reasons; passports, banishment, expulsion and deportation; asylum; extradition, federal finances, monopolies, the monetary-, credit-, stock exchange, banking, the weights and measures, standards and hallmark system, administration of justice, press affairs, the maintenance of peace, order and security, including the extension of primary assistance in general, but excluding those of the local public security administration, matters pertaining to association and assembly, the aliens police and matters pertaining to residence registration, matters pertaining to weapons, ammunition and explosives as well as the use of firearms, antitrust law; patent matters and the protection of designs, trademarks, and other commodity description, the traffic system, river and navigation police, the postal and telecommunications system, mining, Danube control and conservation, regulation of torrents, construction and maintenance of waterways, surveying, labour legislation social and contractual insurance, nursing care allowance; social compensation legislation; commercial transactions in seed and plant commodities, in fodder and fertilizer as well as plant preservatives, and in plant safety appliances including their admission and, in the case of seed and plant commodities, the preservation of monuments, organisation and command of the federal police likewise their acceptance; military affairs, matters of civilian service; population policy in so far as it concerns the grant of children’s allowances and the organization of burden equalization on behalf of families; schooling as well as education in matters pertaining to pupil and student hostels with the exception of agricultural and forestry education in matters pertaining to student hostels, public tendering.

(3) The Federation remains entitled to delegate to the governor its executive power also in the matters enumerated in para 2 above.

(4) The establishment of federal authorities for matters other than those specified in para 2 above can ensue only with the sanction of the provinces concerned.

(5) If in a province the immediate enactment of measures in matters pertaining to the direct federal administration becomes necessary to avert manifest, irreparable harm to the community as a whole in circumstances where the highest authorities of the federal administration are impeded by events beyond their control, the governor must take the measures on their behalf.

Art. 103.

(1) In matters of the indirect federal administration the governor is bound by instructions from the Federal Government and individual Federal Ministers (Art. 20) and he is obliged, in order to effect the implementation of such instructions, also to employ the powers available to him in his capacity as a functionary of the province’s autonomous sphere of competence.

(2) A Land Government, when it draws up its standing orders, can decide that specific categories of business pertaining to the indirect federal administration shall be conducted by members of the Land Government in the name of the governor because of their substantive relationship with matters pertaining to the province’s autonomous sphere of competence. In such business the members concerned of the Land Government are as much bound by the instructions of the governor (Art. 20) as is the latter by the instructions of the Federal Government or individual Federal Ministers.

(3) Instructions issued by the Federal Government or individual Federal Ministers in accordance with para 1 above shall also in instances falling under para 2 above be addressed to the Governor. The latter, should he not himself be conducting the relevant business of the indirect federal administration, is responsible (Art. 142 para 2 subpara e) for passing the instruction in writing without delay and unaltered to the Land Government member concerned and for supervising its implementation. If the instruction is not complied with, although the governor has made the necessary arrangements, the Land Government member concerned is pursuant to Art. 142 responsible to the Federal Government as well.

(4) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 51/2012)

Art. 104.

(1) The provisions of Art. 102 shall not apply to agencies for the performance of federal business specified in Art. 17.

(2) Nonetheless the Federal Minister entrusted with the administration of federal assets can assign the performance of such business to a governor and the authorities subordinate to him. Such an assignment can at any time be revoked in part or in whole. To what extent in exceptional instances the Federation makes recompense for the accrued costs of performing such business will be regulated by federal law. Art. 103 paras 2 and 3 apply analogously.

Art. 105.

(1) The Governor represents the province. In matters pertaining to the indirect federal administration he is pursuant to Art. 142 responsible to the Federal Government. The governor has a member of the Land Government to substitute for him (deputy governor) who is designated by the Land Government. This appointment shall be notified to the Federal Chancellor. Should the need for substitution occur, the member of the Land Government appointed as substitute is pursuant to Art. 142 likewise responsible to the Federal Government in matters pertaining to the indirect federal administration. Immunity is no bar to the assertion of such responsibility on the part of the governor or the member of the Land Government who substitutes for him. Immunity is likewise no bar to the assertion of responsibility on the part of a member of the Land Government in a case arising under Art. 103 para 3.

(2) The members of the Land Government are responsible to the Provincial Parliament pursuant to Art. 142.

(3) A vote to prefer a charge within the meaning of Art. 142 requires the presence of half the members.

Art. 106. An administrative civil servant with legal training will be appointed to take charge as the provincial administration’s chief executive of the Land Government Office’s internal services. He is also the official assistant of the governor in matters pertaining to the indirect federal administration.

B- The Federal Capital Vienna

Art. 108. For the federal capital, Vienna, in its capacity as a province, the municipal council has additionally the function of the Provincial Parliament, the city senate the function of the Land Government, the mayor the function of the governor, the city administration the function of the Land Government office, and the city administration’s chief executive the function of the provincial administration’s chief executive.

Art. 109. Art. 102 para 1 applies to the federal capital Vienna with the proviso, that the execution of the Federation, to the extent separate federal authorities do not exist (direct federal administration), is exerted by the mayor as governor and by his subordinate city administration as district administration authority

Art. 112. Allowing for Art. 108 and 109 the provisions of section A of the fifth Chapter hold good in other respects for the federal capital Vienna, with the exception of Art. 117 para 6 second phrase, Art. 119 para 4 and Art. 119a. Art. 142 para 2 subpara e also applies to the conduct of the sphere of competence assigned by the Federation to the federal capital, Vienna.

Chapter V

Self-Administration

A- Municipalities

Art. 115.

(1) In so far as in the following articles the term municipality is used, the reference is to be taken as meaning local community.

(2) Save as competence on the part of the Federation is expressly stipulated, provincial legislation shall prescribe laws pertaining to municipalities in accordance with the principles of the articles contained in this section. Competence for the settlement of matters which, pursuant to Arts. 118, 118a and 119, are to be performed by the municipalities including an eventual exclusion of appeal will be determined in accordance with the general provisions of this federal constitutional law.

(3) The Austrian Association of municipalities (Austrian Communal Federation) and the Austrian Association of Cities and Towns (Austrian Municipal Federation) are competent to represent the interests of the municipalities.

Art. 116.

(1) Every province is divided into municipalities. The municipality is a territorial corporate body entitled to self-administration while being at the same time an administrative local district. Every piece of province must form part of a municipality.

(2) The municipality is an independent economic entity. It is entitled, within the limits of the general laws of the Federation and the provinces, to possess assets of all kinds, to acquire and to dispose of such at will, to operate economic enterprises as well as to manage its budget independently within the framework of the constitutional finance provisions and to levy taxation.

(3) A municipality with at least 20,000 inhabitants shall at its own request, if provincial interests are not thereby jeopardized, be awarded its own charter by way of provincial legislation (town charter). Such an enactment may only be published with Federal Government approval. This shall be deemed given if the Federal Government within eight weeks from the day of the enactment’s arrival at the competent Federal Ministry has not informed the governor that the approval is refused. A town with its own charter shall perform besides its municipal administrative duties also those of the district administration.

(4) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. No. 490/1984)

Art. 116a.

(1) For the performance of their matters municipalities can by agreement associate in municipality associations. Such an agreement requires the sanction of the supervisory authority. The sanction shall be conferred by ordinance if a lawful agreement between the municipalities concerned is on hand and the formation of the municipal association

1- does not in the case of performance of matters appurtenant to the sovereign administration jeopardize the function of the municipalities concerned as self-administering corporate bodies,

2- in the case of performance of matters appurtenant to the municipalities as holders of private rights it lies for reasons of expediency, economic efficiency, and thrift in the interest of the municipalities concerned.

(2) In the interest of expediency the competent legislation (Arts. 10 to 15) can provide for the performance of matters in the sphere of competence of the municipality by the formation of municipal associations, but the function of the municipalities as self-administrative corporate bodies and administrative local districts may not thereby be jeopardized. The municipalities concerned shall by way of an executive measure be given a hearing prior to the formation of municipal associations.

(3) The organs of the municipal associations which are to undertake matters pertaining to the municipality’s own sphere of competence are to be formed according to democratic principles.

(4) The provincial legislature shall prescribe the organization of the municipal association and in this connection it shall provide for an association board, which must in any case consist of elected representatives from all member municipalities, and an association chairman. Rules shall moreover be established, in the case of municipal associations formed by agreement, as regards admission to and withdrawal from the municipal association as well as its dissolution.

(5) Competence as to the regulation of matters to be undertaken by the municipal associations is governed by the general provisions of this federal constitutional law.

(6) The merger of municipalities of different provinces to municipal associations is permitted under the proviso of an agreement between the respective provinces according to Art. 15a, in which mainly provisions on the approval of the formation of municipal associations and the implementation of supervision must be contained.

Art. 116b. Municipalities of a province may conclude agreements among each other on their respective sphere of competence, to the extent, provincial legislature so provides. Doing so, provincial legislature also has to provide provisions on the publication of such agreements as well as on the solution of disagreements. Art. 116a para 6 applies accordingly to the agreements of municipalities of different provinces.

Art. 117.

(1) The authorities of the municipality shall in every instance include:

(a) the municipal council, being a general representative body to be elected by those entitled to vote in the municipality;

(b) the municipal executive board (city council), or in towns with their own charter the city senate;

(c) the mayor.

(2) The municipal council is elected on the basis of proportional representation by equal, direct, personal and secret suffrage by the male and female federal nationals who have their principal domicile in the municipality. The election regulations laws can however stipulate that also national who have a domicile, but not their principal domicile, in the municipality, are entitled to vote. In the electoral regulations the conditions for suffrage and electoral eligibility may not be more restrictive than in the electoral regulations for the Provincial Parliament; the provision can however be made that individuals who have not yet been a year resident in the municipality shall not be entitled to vote or to stand for election to the municipal council if their residence in the municipality is manifestly temporary. Among the conditions to be laid down by the election regulation is the entitlement to suffrage and electoral eligibility also for nationals of other European member states. The electoral regulation can provide that the voters exercise their suffrage in self-contained constituencies. A division of the electorate into other electoral bodies is not admissible. Article 26 para 6 is to be applied accordingly. The electoral regulations can, in cases where no election proposals are brought forward, decree that individuals shall be deemed elected whose names appear most frequently on the ballot papers.

(3) A simple majority by members present in sufficient numbers to form a quorum is requisite to a vote by the municipal council; for certain matters, though, other requirements for the adoption of resolutions can be provided.

(4) Meetings of the municipal council are public, but provision can be made for exceptions. The public may not be excluded when the municipal budget or the municipal final accounts are on the agenda.

(5) Electoral parties represented in the municipal council have a claim to representation on the municipal executive board in accordance with their strength.

(6) The mayor shall be elected by the municipal council. Provincial constitution can however stipulate that the mayor shall be elected by those with municipal council suffrage. In this case Article 26 para 6 is to be applied accordingly.

(7) The business of the municipalities will be performed by the local administrative office (city administrative office), that of towns with their own charter by the City administration. A civil servant with legal training shall be appointed to take charge as city administration’s chief executive of the City administration’s internal services.

(8) The provincial legislature can in matters pertaining to the municipality’s own sphere of competence provide for the direct participation and assistance of those entitled to vote in the municipal council election.

Art. 118.

(1) A municipality has its own sphere of competence and one assigned to it either by the Federation or the province.

(2) Its own sphere of competence comprises, apart from the matters mentioned in Art. 116 para 2, all matters exclusively or preponderantly the concern of the local community as personified by a municipality and suited to performance by the community within its local boundaries. Legislation shall expressly specify matters of that kind as being such as fall within the municipality’s own sphere of competence.

(3) A municipality is guaranteed official responsibility in its own sphere of competence for performance of the following matters in particular:

1- appointment of the municipal authorities, notwithstanding the competence of election boards at a higher level; settlement of the internal arrangements for performance of the municipal functions;

2- appointment of the municipal staff and exercise of the service prerogative over them, notwithstanding the competence of disciplinary, eligibility, and exam commissions at a higher level;

3- local public security administration (Art. 15 para 2), local events control;

4- administration of municipal traffic areas, local traffic police;

5- crops protection police;

6- local market police;

7- local sanitary police, especially in the field of emergency and first aid services as well as matters pertaining to deaths and interment;

8- public decency;

9- local building police; local fire control; local development planning;

10- public services for extra-judicial settlement of disputes;

11- voluntary-sale of movables.

(4) The municipality shall perform the business for which it is competent within the framework of the laws and ordinances of the Federation and the province on its own responsibility free from instructions and under exclusion of legal redress to administrative authorities outside the municipality. In the matters of the own sphere of competence there is a two-stage channel of appeal; this can be excluded by law. In matters of the own sphere of competence the Federation and the province have a right of supervision over the municipality (Art. 119a).

(5) The mayor, the members of the municipal executive board (city council, city senate) and, if appointed, other executive officials are responsible to the municipal council for the performance of their functions relating to the municipality’s own sphere of competence.

(6) The municipality is entitled in matters pertaining to its own sphere of competence to issue on its own initiative local police ordinances for the prevention of imminently to be expected or existent nuisances interfering with local communal life as well as to declare non-compliance with them an administrative contravention. Such ordinances may not violate existent laws and ordinances of the Federation and province.

(7) On application by a municipality the performance of certain matters in its own sphere of competence can, in accordance with Art. 119a para 3, be assigned by ordinance of the Land Government or by ordinance of the governor to a state authority. In so far as such an ordinance is meant to assign competence to a federal authority, it requires the approval of the Federal Government. In so far as such an ordinance by the governor is meant to assign competence to a provincial authority, it requires the approval of the Land Government. Such an ordinance shall be rescinded as soon as the reason for its issue has ceased. Assignment does not extend to the right to issue ordinances in accordance with para 6 above.

(8) The establishment of a municipal constabulary or a change in its organization must be notified to the Federal Government.

Art. 118a.

(1) Federal or provincial law may provide that with the approval of the municipality the members of a municipal constabulary may be empowered to perform executive services for the competent authority.

(2) With the approval of the municipality, the district administrative authority may empower members of a municipal constabulary to participate in the application of administrative penal law to the same extent as the other organs of the public safety service. This mandate can be issued only to the extent to which the organs of the public safety service have to supervise the compliance with the administrative regulations in the matter that constitutes the subject of the administrative penal proceedings or to the extent to which this matter falls into the municipality’s sphere of competence.

Art. 119.

(1) The assigned sphere of competence comprises those matters which the municipality in accordance with federal laws must undertake at the order and in accordance with the instructions of the Federation or in accordance with provincial laws at the order and in accordance with instructions of the province.

(2) The business of the assigned sphere of competence is performed by the mayor. In doing so, he is in matters pertaining to federal execution bound by instructions from the competent federal authorities, in matters pertaining to provincial execution by instructions from the competent provincial authorities; he is responsible in accordance with para 4.

(3) The mayor can – without detraction from his responsibility – on account of their factual connection with matters pertaining to the municipality’s own sphere of competence transfer individual categories of matters pertaining to the assigned sphere of competence to members of the municipal executive board (city council, city senate), other authorities created in accordance with Art. 117 para 1 or members of official bodies for performance in his name. In these matters the authorities concerned or their members are bound by the instructions of the mayor and responsible in accordance with para 4.

(4) In so far as intent or gross negligence can be laid to their charge, the authorities named in paras 2 and 3 above can on account of breach of law as well as on account of noncompliance with an ordinance or instruction be declared to have forfeited their office, by the governor if they were acting in the field of federal execution, by the Land Government if they were acting in the field of provincial execution. Should such a person belong to the municipal council, the membership is not thereby affected.

Art. 119a.

(1) The Federation and the province exercise the right of supervision over a municipality to the purpose that it does not infringe laws and ordinances in dealing with its own sphere of competence, in particular does not overstep its sphere of competence, and fulfils the duties legally devolving upon it.

(2) The province has furthermore the right to examine the financial administration of a municipality with respect to its thrift, efficiency, and expediency. The result of the examination shall be conveyed to the mayor for submission to the municipal council. The mayor shall within three months inform the supervisory authority of the measures taken by reason of the result of the check.

(3) In so far as a municipality’s own sphere of competence comprises matters deriving from the sphere of federal execution, the right of supervision and its legislative regulation lie with the Federation, in other respects with the provinces; the right of supervision shall be exercised by the authorities of the ordinary public administration.

(4) The supervisory authority is entitled to inform itself about every kind of municipal business. The municipality is bound to impart the information demanded in individual cases by the supervisory authority and to allow examination to be conducted on the spot.

(5) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 51/2012)

(6) The municipality shall without delay advice the supervisory authority of ordinances issued in its own sphere of competence. The supervisory authority shall after a hearing of the municipality rescind ordinances which are contrary to law and simultaneously advise the municipality of the reasons.

(7) In so far as the competent legislature (para 3) contemplates the dissolution of the municipal council as a supervisory expedient, this measure rests with the Land Government in exercise of the province’s right of supervision, with the governor in exercise of the Federation’s right of supervision. The admissibility of effecting a substitution shall be confined to cases of absolute necessity. Supervisory expedients shall be applied with greatest possible consideration for third parties’ acquired rights.

(8) Individual measures to be taken by a municipality in its own sphere of competence but which to a special degree affect extra-local interests, particularly such as have a distinct financial bearing, can be tied by the competent legislature (para 3) to a sanction on the part of the supervisory authority. Only a state of affairs which unequivocally justifies the preference of extra-local interests may come into consideration as a reason for withholding the sanction.

(9) The municipality is party to supervisory authority proceedings and is entitled to lodge complaint with the Administrative Court (Art. 130 to 132). It is party of the proceedings before the Administrative Court and is entitled to file for final complaint at the Administrative Court (Art. 133) and complaint at the Constitutional Court (Art. 144).

(10) The provisions of this article shall find corresponding application to supervision of municipal associations in so far as these perform matters pertaining to a municipality’s own sphere of competence.

Art. 120. The combination of local communities into territorial communities, their establishment in line with the pattern of self-administration, and the determination of other principles for the organization of the ordinary public administration in the provinces is the business of federal constitutional legislation; its implementation devolves upon the provincial legislatures. Settlement of the competence in matters pertaining to the service code for and staff representation rights of the territorial community employees is the business of federal constitutional legislation.

B- Other Self-Administration

Art. 120a.

(1) People may be united by law to self-administrating bodies to autonomously take care of public interests being in their exclusive or preponderant common interest and qualified to be handled jointly by them.

(2) The republic recognizes the role of the social partners. It respects their autonomy and supports the social partners´ dialogue by instituting self-administration bodies.

Art. 120b.

(1) The self-administrating bodies are authorized to take care of their tasks in own responsibility without instructions and to render statutes in the frame of the laws. The Federation or the province has a right of supervision over them on the basis of the legal regulations with regard to the legality of the handling of the administration. Such right of supervision may also extend to the expedience of the handling of the administration, if such is required because of the tasks of the self-administrating body. By law ways of participation of the self-administering bodies in the public execution maybe provided.

(2) Upon the self-administrating bodies tasks of administration of the state may be conferred. The laws have to expressly indicate that such matters belong to the assigned executive responsibility and to provide a binding effect of the instructions by the supreme administrative authorities.

(3) The laws may provide forms of participation of self-administering bodies in the execution of state affairs.

Art. 120c.

(1) The organs of the self-administering bodies are to be established according to democratic principles out of its members.

(2) Thrifty and economical performance of the tasks of the self-administrating bodies is to be safeguarded of the basis on the legal regulations by contributions of its members or other means.

(3) The self-administering bodies are independent business entities. In the frame of the laws they may, in order to fulfil their tasks, acquire, possess and dis-pose of all kinds of assets.

Chapter VI

Control of Public Accounts and Administration of Public Funds

Art. 121.

(1) Competent to examine the administration of public funds by the Federation, the provinces, the municipal associations, the municipalities and other legal entities determined by law is the Public Audit Office.

(2) The Public Audit Office draws up the final federal budget accounts and submits them to the National Council.

(3) All vouchers about financial debts of the Federation, in so far as they remit in liability on the part of the Federation, shall be countersigned by the President of the Public Audit Office or, should he be impeded, by his deputy. The countersignature guarantees only the legality of the borrowing and the correct registration in the ledger of the national debt.

(4) Every second year the Public Audit Office shall in the case of undertakings and agencies subject to its control and on which it has a duty to report to the National Council ascertain by a request for information from these undertakings and agencies the average incomes, including all social service payments, contributions in kind, and additional retirement benefits, of members of the management board and the supervisory board as well as of all employees and report thereon to the National Council. The average incomes of the foregoing categories of persons shall in this connection be shown separately for each undertaking and each agency.

Art. 122.

(1) The Public Audit Office is directly subordinate to the National Council. It acts as agent for the National Council in matters pertaining to federal administration of public funds and the financial administration of professional corporations in so far as they come under the executive authority of the Federation, as agent for the Provincial Parliament concerned in matters pertaining to provinces, municipal associations, and municipal administration of public funds as well as the financial administration of professional corporations in so far as they come under the executive authority of the provinces.

(2) The Public Audit Office is independent of the Federal Government and the Land Governments and subject only to the provisions of the law.

(3) The Public Audit Office consists of a President and the requisite officials and auxiliary personnel.

(4) The President of the Public Audit Office is elected on the proposal of the main committee of the National Council for a twelve years period of office; re-election is inadmissible. Before his assumption of office he renders an affirmation to the Federal President.

(5) The president of the Public Audit Office may neither belong to any general representative body nor the European Parliament during the past five years have held office in the Federal or a Land Government.

Art. 123.

(1) With regard to accountability the president of the Public Audit Office has the same status as members of the Federal Government or of members of the Land Government concerned, depending on whether the Public Audit Office acts as executive officer of the National Council or a Provincial Parliament.

(2) He can be relieved of office by a vote of the National Council.

Art. 123a.

(1) The president of the Public Audit Office is entitled to participate in the debate by the National Council and its committees (sub-committees) on reports by the Public Audit Office, on the final federal budget accounts, on motions concerning implementation of specific actions in the Public Audit Office’s examination of the administration of public funds, and on the subdivisions relating to the Public Audit Office in the Federal Finance Act.

(2) The president of the Public Audit Office has, in accordance with the detailed provisions of the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders, always the right at his own request to be heard in the debates on the subjects listed in para 1 above.

Art. 124.

(1) Should the president of the Public Audit Office be prevented from the discharge of his responsibilities, the senior official of the Public Audit Office will act for him. This also holds well if the office of president is vacant. Who shall act in the National Council as deputy for the president of the Public Audit Office is settled by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders.

(2) If someone deputizes for the president, the provisions of Art. 123 para 1 apply to the deputy.

Art. 125.

(1) The officials of the Public Audit Office are appointed by the Federal President upon the recommendation and with the countersignature of the president of the Public Audit Office; the same holds good for the conferment of the official titles. The Federal President may however authorize the president of the Public Audit Office to appoint officials of certain categories.

(2) The president of the Public Audit Office appoints the auxiliary personnel.

(3) The federal service prerogative with regard to employees of the Public Audit Office is exercised by the president of the Public Audit Office.

Art. 126. No member of the Public Audit Office may be a participant in the management and administration of enterprises subject to control by the Public Audit Office. Just as little may a member of the Public Audit Office participate in the management and administration of any other enterprises operating for profit.

Art. 126a. Should divergences of opinion arise between the Public Audit Office and a legal entity (Art. 121 para 1) on interpretation of the legal provisions which prescribe the competence of the Public Audit Office, the Constitutional Court decides the issue upon application by the Federal Government or a Land Government or the Public Audit Office. All legal entities must in accordance with the legal opinion of the Constitutional Court render possible a scrutiny by the Public Audit Office.

Art. 126b.

(1) The Public Audit Office shall examine the entire management of the Federation and furthermore the financial administration of endowments, funds and institutions administered by federal authorities or persons (groups of persons) appointed for the purpose by authorities of the Federation.

(2) The Public Audit Office also examines the financial administration of enterprises where the Federation, either as the sole participant or together with other legal entities falling within the competence of the Public Audit Office, at any rate holds at least fifty per cent of the share, stock, or equity capital or where the Federation is either their sole or joint operator with other such legal entities. The Public Audit Office also examines the financial administration of enterprises of which the Federation, either as the sole participant or together with legal entities falling within the competence of the Public Audit Office, has de facto control by other financial, other economic, or organizational measures. The competence of the Public Audit Office extends moreover to enterprises of any additional category where the conditions pursuant to this paragraph exist.

(3) The Public Audit Office is competent to examine the financial administration of corporations under public law using federal funds.

(4) The Public Audit Office shall on a vote by the National Council or at the request of National Council members carry out special measures of investigation into financial administration which falls into its sphere of competence. The more detailed regulation will be laid down by the Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders. The Public Audit Office shall likewise carry out such measures at the substantiated request of the Federal Government or a Federal Minister and report the result to the applicant authority.

(5) Examination by the Public Audit Office shall extend to arithmetical correctness, compliance with existing regulations, and the employment of thrift, efficiency and expediency.

Art. 126c. The Public Audit Office is competent to examine the financial administration of the social insurance institutions.

Art. 126d.

(1) The Public Audit Office annually renders the National Council not later than 31 December in any year a report on its activities. The Public Audit Office can moreover at any time report to the National Council its observations on individual matters and, if necessary, make proposals. The Public Audit Office must simultaneously with its submission to the National Council inform the Federal Government of every report. The Public Audit Office’s reports shall be published after submission to the National Council.

(2) A standing committee shall be appointed by the National Council to discuss the reports of the Public Audit Office. Its appointment shall maintain the principle of proportional representation.

Art. 127.

(1) The Public Audit Office shall examine the financial administration of the provinces in their autonomous sphere of competence as well as the financial administration of endowments, funds and institutions administered by the executive officers of a province or persons (groups of persons) appointed for the purpose by authorities of the province. The examination shall extend to arithmetical correctness, compliance with existing regulations, and the employment of thrift, efficiency and expedience in the financial administration; it shall not how-ever include the resolutions passed by the constitutionally competent representative bodies with respect to the financial administration.

(2) The Land Governments shall annually transmit to the Public Audit Office the budget estimates and the final budget accounts.

(3) The Public Audit Office also examines the financial administration of enterprises where the province is either the sole participant or holds at least fifty per cent of the share, stock, or equity capital together with other legal entities falling within the competence of the Public Audit Office or where the province is either their sole or joint operator with other such legal entities. As regards the powers of examination in case of de facto control Art. 126b para 2 holds good analogously. The competence of the Public Audit Office extends moreover to enterprises of any additional category where the conditions pursuant to this paragraph exist.

(4) The Public Audit Office is competent to examine the financial administration of corporations under public law using provincial funds.

(5) The result of its examination is communicated by the Public Audit Office to the province concerned. The latter shall comment upon this and within three months advice the Public Audit Office of the measures taken by reason of the examination’s result.

(6) The Public Audit Office annually renders the Provincial Parliament, at the latest by 31 December in any year, a report on those of its activities relating to the province. The Public Audit Office can moreover at any time report to the Provincial Parliament its observations on individual matters. The Land Government and the Federal Government must be informed of every report by the Public Audit Office simultaneously with its submission to the Provincial Parliament. The Public Audit Office’s reports shall be published after submission to the Provincial Parliament.

(7) On a vote by the Provincial Parliament or at the request of Provincial Parliament members, their numbers regulated by provincial constitutional law but not permitted to exceed one third, the Public Audit Office shall carry out special measures of investigation which fall into its sphere of competence. As long as the Public Audit Office has by reason of such a motion not rendered the Provincial Parliament a report, no additional motion of such kind may be proposed. The Public Audit Office must likewise carry out such measures at the substantiated request of a Land Government and report the result to the applicant authority.

(8) The provisions of this article also hold good for the examination into the financial administration of the city of Vienna, the municipal council taking the place of the Provincial Parliament and the city senate taking the place of the Land Government.

Art. 127a.

(1) The Public Audit Office shall examine the financial administration of municipalities with at least 10.000 inhabitants as well as the financial administration of endowments, funds and institutions administered by the authorities of a municipality or persons (groups of persons) appointed for the purpose by the authorities of a municipality. The examination shall extend to the arithmetical correctness, compliance with existing regulations, and the employment of thrift, efficiency and expediency in the financial administration.

(2) The mayor shall annually transmit to the Public Audit Office and simultaneously to the Land Government the budget estimates and the final budget ac-counts.

(3) The Public Audit Office also examines the financial administration of enterprises where a municipality with at least 10.000 inhabitants is either the sole participant or holds at least fifty per cent of the share, stock, or equity capital together with other legal entities falling within the competence of the Public Audit Office or where the municipality is either their sole or joint operator with other such legal entities. As regards the powers of examination in case of de facto control Art. 126b para 2 holds good analogously. The competence of the Public Audit Office extends moreover to enterprises of any additional category where the conditions pursuant to this paragraph exist.

(4) The Public Audit Office is competent to examine the financial administration of corporations under public law using funds of a municipality with at least 10.000 inhabitants.

(5) The result of its examination is transmitted by the Public Audit Office to the mayor. The latter shall comment upon this and within three months advice the Public Audit Office of the measures taken by reason of the examination’s result. The Public Audit Office shall advise the Land Government and the Federal Government of the result of its examination into the financial administration together with any possible comment by the mayor.

(6) The Public Audit Office annually renders the municipal council, at the latest by 31 December, a report on its activities in so far as they concern the municipality. The Land Government and the Federal Government must likewise be informed of every report by the Public Audit Office simultaneously with its sub-mission to the municipal council. The reports shall be published after submission to the municipal council.

(7) The Public Audit Office shall also at the substantiated request of the Land Government examine the financial administration of municipalities with less than 10.000 inhabitants. Paras 1 and 3 to 6 of this Article are applied analogously. Each year only two such requests may be filed. Such requests are only allowed regarding such municipalities which, compared to other municipalities, show a conspicuous development in debts or liabilities.

(8) The Public Audit Office has to examine the financial administration of certain municipalities with less than 10.000 inhabitants upon resolution of the Land Government. Paras 1 and 3 to 6 are to be applied under the proviso, that the report of the Public Audit Office also is to be communicated to the Provincial Parliament. Each year only two such requests may be filed. Such requests are only allowed regarding such municipalities which, compared to other municipalities, show a conspicuous development in debts or liabilities.

(9) The provisions holding good for the examination of the financial administration of municipalities shall apply analogously to the examination of the financial administration of municipal associations.

Art. 127b.

(1) The Public Audit Office is entitled to examine the financial administration of the professional corporations.

(2) The professional corporations shall annually transmit to the Public Audit Office the budget estimates and the final budget accounts.

(3) The examination by the Public Audit Office shall extend to arithmetical correctness, compliance with existing regulations, and the employment of thrift and efficiency in the financial administration; this examination does not however include resolutions by the competent authorities of the professional corporations governing the financial administration on behalf of tasks relating to representation of their members’ interests.

(4) The Public Audit Office shall notify the Chairman of the constituent authority (representative body) of the professional corporation of the result of the examination together with any possible opinion thereon to the constituent authority (representative body) of the professional corporation. The Public Audit Office shall at the same time inform likewise the authority competent at the highest level for supervision of the professional corporation as regards the result of its examination. The reports of the Public Audit Office shall be published after submission to the constituent authority (representative body).

Art. 127c. In case a land has established a Public Audit Office of the province, the constitutional law of the province may provide the following provisions:

1- a provision corresponding to Art. 126a first phrase under the proviso, that Art. 126a second phrase also applies in this case;

2- provisions corresponding to Art. 127a para 1 to 6 concerning municipalities with less than 10.000 inhabitants;

3- provisions corresponding to Art. 127a para 7 and 8 concerning municipalities with at least 10.000 inhabitants

4- (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 51/2012)

Art. 128. The more detailed provisions about the establishment and activity of the Public Audit Office will be laid down by federal law.

Chapter VII

Constitutional and Administrative Guarantees

A- Administrative Jurisdiction

Art. 129. In all provinces are administrative courts of the province. For the Federation there is an administrative court of the Federation, to be named Federal Court of Administration and an administrative court of the Federation for finance to be named Federal Financial Court.

Art. 130.

(1) The administrative courts pronounce judgement on complaints

1- against rulings by administrative authorities for unlawful;

2- against the exercise of direct administrative power and compulsion for unlawful;

3- on the ground of breach of the duty to reach a decision by an administrative authority;

4- against instructions under Art. 81a para 4.

(2) Federal or provincial legislation may provide other competences of the administrative courts for decision on

1- complaints for unlawful of the conduct of an administrative authority in executing the law or

2- complaints for unlawful of conduct of a contract placing authority in matters of public contracts or

3- disputes in civil service law matters of civil servants

In the matters of the execution of the Federation, not directly handled by federal authorities, as well as in the matters of Art. 11, 12, 14 para 2 and 3 and 14a para 3 and 4 federal laws under subpara 1 may only be published upon approval by the provinces.

(3) Except in administrative penal proceedings and in legal matters pertaining to the competence of the administrative court of the Federation for finance unlawful does not exist to the extent the law permits the administrative authority to apply discretion and the authority has done so in the sense of the law.

(4) The administrative court is to decide in the matter itself on complaints according to para 1 subpara 1 in administrative penal matters. The administrative court is to decide on complaints according to para 1 subpara 1 in other legal matters upon the merits itself if

1- the relevant facts have been established or

2- the establishment of the relevant facts by the administrative court itself is in the interest of a speedy procedure or connected with substantial cost saving.

(5) Save as provided otherwise by this law, legal matters pertaining to the competence of courts of justice or of the constitutional court are excluded from the competence of the administrative courts .

Art. 131.

(1) To the extent paras 2 and 3 do not provide otherwise, the administrative courts of the provinces pronounce judgement on complaints according to Art. 130 para 1.

(2) To the extent para 3 does not provide otherwise, the administrative court of the Federation pronounces judgement on complaints according to Art. 130 para 1 in legal matters, in matters of the execution of the Federation, directly executed by federal authorities. To the extent a law provides the competence of administrative courts according to Art. 130 para 2 subpara 2, the Administrative Court of the Federation pronounces judgement on complaints in legal matters and matters of public contract placing, which pertain to execution by the Federation according to Art. 14b para 2 subpara 1. To the extent a law provides the competence of administrative courts according Art. 130 para 2 subpara 3, the Administrative Court of the Federation pronounces judgement on disputes in civil service law matters of civil servants

(3) The Administrative Court of the Federation for Finance pronounces judgement according to Art. 130 para 1 subpara 1 to 3 in legal matters, in matters of public duties (with the exception of administrative fees of the Federation, the provinces and municipalities) and of Financial Penal Law as well as in other matters determined by law, to the extent the matters named are directly handled by the revenue- or financial penal authorities of the Federation.

(4) By federal law may be provided

1- a competence of the administrative courts of the provinces: in legal matters, in matters according to para 2 und 3;

2- a competence of the administrative courts of the Federation:

(a) in legal matters in matters of environmental compatibility examinations for projects, where material effects on the environment are to be anticipated (Art. 10 para 1 subpara 9 and Art. 11 para 1 subpara 7);

(b) in other legal matters in matters of the execution by the Federation, not directly handled by federal authorities, as well as in the matters of Art. 11, 12, 14 para 2 and 3 and 14a para 3.

Federal laws under para 1 and para 2 subpara b may only be published upon approval by the provinces.

(5) Provincial law may provide a competence of the administrative courts of the Federation in legal matters, in matters of the autonomous sphere of competence of the provinces. Art. 97 para 2 applies accordingly.

(6) The administrative courts competent according to para 1 to 4 of this article pronounce judgement in matters on complaints in legal matters, in which a law provides the competence of an administrative court according to Art. 130 para 1 subpara 1. To the extent no competence is given according to the first phrase, the administrative courts of the provinces pronounce judgement on such complaints.

Art. 132.

(1) Complaint against the ruling of an administrative authority for illegality may be raised by:

1- someone who alleges infringement of his rights;

2- the competent Federal Minister in legal matters in matters of Art. 11, 12, 14 para 2 and 3 and 14a para 3 and 4 or in legal matters, in which the ruling of a provincial school board is based on the resolution of a committee.

(2) Against the exercise of direct administrative power or compulsion complaint may be raised by someone who alleges infringement of his rights because of them.

(3) For breach of the duty to reach a decision appeal may be raised by someone who alleges as party in an administrative procedure to be entitled to get a decision.

(4) The provincial school board may raise an appeal against instructions according to Art. 81a para 4 on the basis of a resolution of the committee.

(5) Federal and provincial laws provide who can raise complaint for illegality in other cases than those named in para 1 and 2 and in those cases, in which the law provides the competence of administrative courts according to Art. 130 para 2.

(6) In the matters of the own sphere of competence of the municipality, complaint may be raised before the administrative court only after all appeals have been exhausted.

Art. 133.

(1) The Administrative Court pronounces ruling on:

1- final complaints against the decision of an administrative court for illegality;

2- motions to set a deadline for violation of the breach of the duty to reach a decision by an administrative court;

3- conflicts of competence between administrative courts or between an administrative court and the (Federal) Administrative Court.

(2) Federal or provincial law may provide other competences of the Administrative Court to decide on requests by a court of justice to establish the unlawful of an ordinance or the ruling of an administrative court.

(3) Unlawful does not exist to the extent the administrative court has applied discretion in the sense of the law.

(4) Final complaint against the ruling of an administrative court is admissible, if the solution depends from a legal question of essential importance, mainly because the ruling deviates from the established court practise of the (Federal) Administrative Court, such established court practise does not exist or the legal question to be solved has not been answered in uniform manner by the previously established court practise of the (Federal) Administrative Court. If the ruling only is on a small fine, federal law may provide that the revision is inadmissible.

(5) Excluded from the competence of the (Federal) Administrative Court are legal matters pertaining to the competence of the Constitutional Court.

(6) Final complaint against a ruling of an administrative court for illegality may raise:

1- who alleges to have been infringed in his rights by the ruling;

2- the authority involved in the proceedings before the administrative court;

3- the competent Federal Minister in the legal matters named in Art. 132 para 1 subpara 2;

4- the Land school board on the basis of a resolution of the committee in the legal matters named in Art. 132 para 4.

(7) For violation of the onus to decide someone may request a deadline who alleges to be entitled as party in the proceedings before the administrative court to claim the onus to decide.

(8) Federal or provincial laws provide who can raise revision for unlawful in other cases then those named in para 6.

(9) The provisions of this article applicable to their rulings are to be applied to the resolutions of the administrative court accordingly. The specific federal law determining the organization and the procedure of the (Federal) Administrative Court provides to which extent revision may be raised against resolutions of the administrative courts.

Art. 134.

(1) The administrative courts and the (Federal) Administrative Court each consist of one President, one Vice-President and the requisite number of other members.

(2) The President, the Vice-President and the other members of the administrative court of a province are appointed by the government of the province; to the extent it does not concern the position of the President or the Vice-President, it has to call for proposals of three candidates of the plenary assembly of the administrative court or of a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and the minimum of five other members of the administrative court of the province, listing three candidates. The members of the administrative courts of the provinces must have completed legal studies or legal- and political science studies and have had at least five years of legal professional experience.

(3) The President, the Vice-President and the other members of the administrative courts of the Federation are appointed by the Federal President on the proposal of the Federal Government; to the extent it does not concern the position of the President or the Vice-President, it has to call for proposals of the plenary assembly of the of the administrative court of the Federation or of a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and the minimum of five other members of the administrative court of the Federation, listing three candidates. The members of the administrative court of the Federation must have completed legal studies or legal- and political science studies and have had at least five years of legal professional experience, the members of the administrative court of the Federation for finance must have completed an appropriate study and have had at least five years of legal professional experience.

(4) The President, the Vice-President and the other members of the (Federal) Administrative Court are appointed by the Federal President on the proposal of the Federal Government; to the extent it does not concern the position of the President or of the Vice-President it renders its proposals on the basis of the plenary assembly of the (Federal) Administrative Court or of a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and at least five other members of the (Federal) Administrative Court, listing three candidates. The members of the (Federal) Administrative Court must have completed legal studies or legal- and political science studies and have had at least ten years of legal professional experience. At least twenty-five percent should come from professional positions in the provinces, preferably the administrative service of the provinces.

(5) Members of the Federal Government, a government of a province, the National Council, the Federal Council, a Provincial Parliament or the European Parliament cannot belong to the administrative courts and the (Federal) Administrative Court, also members of another general representative body cannot belong to the (Federal) Administrative Court; the incompatibility lasts for members of a general representative body or of the European Parliament, having been elected for a certain legislature- or function period, till the end of the legislature- or function period even in case of early resignation of the mandate.

(6) Who has had one of the functions named in para 5 during the last five years cannot be elected President or Vice-President of an Administrative Court or of the (Federal) Administrative Court.

(7) The members of the administrative courts and of the (Federal) Administrative Court are judges. Art. 87 para 1 and 2 and Art. 88 para 1 and 2 are to be applied with the proviso, that the age-limit at which the members of the administrative courts of the provinces retire for good or their service status ends, is deter-mined by provincial law.

(8) The President of the (Federal) Administrative Court supervises its employees.

Art. 135.

(1) The administrative courts pronounce judgement by single judges. The law on the procedures by the administrative courts or federal or provincial law may provide, that the administrative courts pronounces judgement through chambers. The size of the chambers is determined by the law on the organization of the administrative Court. The chambers are to be constituted by the plenary assembly or by a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and a number of other members of the administrative court, to be determined by law, among the members of the administrative court, and, to the extent federal- or provincial law provides the participation of expert lay-judges in the jurisdiction among a number, to be determined by the law, of expert lay-judges. To the extent a federal law provides that an administrative court of the province shall pronounce judgement in chambers or that expert lay-judges participate in the jurisdiction, the approval of the respective provinces must be obtained. The (Federal) Administrative Court pronounces judgement by chambers to be constituted by the plenary assembly or a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and a number of other members of the (Federal) Administrative Court, to be determined by law, among the members of the (Federal) Administrative Court.

(2) The business to be done by the administrative court shall be allocated to single judges and the chambers for the period provided by law in advance by the plenary assembly or a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and a number of other members of the administrative court to be determined by law. The business to be done by the (Federal) Administrative Court shall be allocated to the chambers for the period provided by law in advance by the plenary assembly or a committee to be elected among its members, consisting of the President, the Vice-President and a number of other members of the (Federal) Administrative Court to be determined by law.

(3) A matter devolving upon a member may only be removed from him by the organ in charge according to para 2 and only in case of his being prevented or if he is impeded to handle it within due time because of the extent of his tasks.

(4) Art. 89 is to be applied accordingly to administrative courts and the (Federal) Administrative Court.

Art. 135a.

(1) The law on the organization of the administrative court may provide that certain kinds of businesses, which shall be exactly specified, can be assigned to specially trained persons who are not judges.

(2) The member of the administrative court competent in accordance with the allocation of business can however at any time reserve to himself or take over discharge of such business.

(3) The employees who are not judges are in the performance of business only bound by instructions from the member of the administrative court competent in accordance with the allocation of business. Art. 20 para 1 third sentence shall apply.

Art. 136.

(1) The organization of the administrative courts of the provinces is determined by provincial law, the organization of the administrative courts of the Federation by federal law.

(2) The procedure of the administrative courts, with the exception of the Administrative Court of the Federation for Finance shall be governed by a separate federal law. The Federation has to grant the provinces opportunity to participate in the preparation of such bill. The federal- or provincial law may provide provisions on the procedure of the administrative courts, to the extent necessary to organize the matter or the separate federal law mentioned in the first phrase gives authorisation to do so.

(3) The procedure of the Administrative Court of the Federation for Finance will be governed by federal law. Federal law may also determine the revenue procedure before the administrative courts of the provinces.

(4) The organization and the procedure of the (Federal) Administrative Court are governed by a separate federal law.

(5) The plenary assemblies of the administrative courts and of the (Federal) Administrative Court adopt standing orders on the basis of the laws enacted according to the paras above.

B- Constitutional Jurisdiction

Art. 137. The Constitutional Court pronounces on pecuniary claims against the Federation, the provinces, the municipalities and municipal associations which cannot be settled by ordinary legal process nor be liquidated by the ruling of an administrative authority.

Art. 138.

(1) The Constitutional Court pronounces on conflicts of competence

1- between courts and administrative authorities;

2- between Courts of Justice and administrative courts or between the (Federal) Administrative Court as well as between the Constitutional Court itself and all other courts;

3- between the Federation and a province or between the provinces amongst themselves.

(2) The Constitutional Court furthermore determines at the application of the Federal Government or a Land Government whether an act of legislation or execution falls into the competence of the Federation or the provinces.

Art. 138a.

(1) The Constitutional Court establishes on application by the Federal Government or a Land Government concerned whether an agreement within the meaning of Art. 15a para 1 exists and whether the obligations arising from such an agreement, save in so far as it is a matter of pecuniary claims, have been fulfilled.

(2) If it is stipulated in an agreement within the meaning of Art. 15a para 2, the Constitutional Court also establishes on application by a Land Government concerned whether such an agreement exists and whether the obligations arising from such an agreement, save in so far as it is a matter of pecuniary claims, have been fulfilled.

Art. 139. The Constitutional Court pronounces judgment on whether or not ordinances are contrary to law

1- on application by a court

2- ex officio insofar as the court will have to apply the ordinance in a suit pending before him

3- on application by a person who alleges to have infringement in her rights directly by the contrary to law, if the ordinance has become effective without a judicial decision having been rendered or a ruling having been rendered has become effective for this person;

4- on application by a person who, as a party in a legal matter that has been decided by a court of justice of first instance, alleges infringement of his rights because of the application of an ordinance that is contrary to law, on the occasion of an appeal filed against that decision;

5- in the case of ordinances of a Federal authority also upon application by a Land Government or the Ombudsman;

6- in the case of ordinances of an authority of a province also on application of the Federal Government or, to the extent the constitutional law of a province has declared competent the Ombudsman also for the sphere of competence of the administration of the respective province, the Ombudsman or an institution according to Art. 148i para 2.

7- in the case of ordinances of a supervisory authority according to Art. 119a para 6 also on application of the municipality whose ordinance has been rescinded.

Art. 89 para 3 is to be applied accordingly to applications according to subparas 3 and 4.

(1a) If it is required to safeguard the purpose of the proceedings before the court of justice, filing an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 4 can be declared inadmissible by a federal law. A federal law has to specify the effects of an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 4.

(1b) The Constitutional Court can refuse, by order, to deal with an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 3 or 4 until the time of the hearing if the application does not have sufficient prospects of success.

(2) If the litigant in a suit lodged with the Constitutional Court, entailing application of an ordinance by the Constitutional Court, receives satisfaction, the proceedings initiated to examine the ordinance’s legality shall nevertheless continue.

(3) The Constitutional Court may rescind an ordinance as contrary to law only to the extent that its rescission was expressly requested or he would have had to apply it in the pending suit. If the Constitutional Court reaches the conclusion that the whole ordinance

1- has no foundation in law,

2- was issued by an authority without competence in the matter, or

3- was published in a manner contrary to law,

it shall rescind the whole ordinance as illegal. This does not hold well if rescission of the whole ordinance manifestly runs contrary to the legitimate interests of the litigant who has filed an application pursuant to the para 1 subpara 3 or 4 above or whose suit has been the occasion for the ex officio initiation of examination proceedings into the ordinance.

(4) If the ordinance has at the time of the Constitutional Court’s delivery of its ruling already been repealed and the proceedings were initiated ex officio or the application was filed by a court or an applicant alleging infringement of his personal rights through the ordinance’s contrary to law the Constitutional Court must pronounce whether the ordinance contravened the law. Para 3 above applies analogously.

(5) The ruling of the Constitutional Court which rescinds an ordinance as contrary to law imposes on the highest competent federal or provincial authority in the obligation to publish the rescission without delay. This applies analogously in the case of a pronouncement pursuant to para 4 above. The rescission enters into force upon expiry of the day of publication if the Constitutional Court does not set a deadline, which may not exceed six months or if legal dispositions are necessary 18 months, for the rescission.

(6) If an ordinance has been rescinded on the score of illegality or if the Constitutional Court has pursuant to para 4 above pronounced an ordinance to be contrary to law, all courts and administrative authorities are bound by the Constitutional Court’s decision, the ordinance shall however continue to apply to the circumstances effected before the rescission, the case in point excepted, unless the Constitutional Court in its rescissory judgment decides otherwise. If the Constitutional Court has in its rescissory judgment set a deadline pursuant to para 5 above,

the ordinance shall apply to all the circumstances effected, the case in point excepted, till the expiry of this deadline.

(7) For legal matters that gave reason to file an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 4, a federal law has to specify that the decision by the Constitutional Court with which the ordinance is rescinded as contrary to law allows for a new decision to be made in that matter. The same shall apply accordingly in the case of a pronouncement pursuant to para 4.

Art. 139a. The Constitutional Court pronounces on the illegality of proclamation of province the republication of a law (state treaty). Art. 139 is to be applied accordingly.

Art. 140.

(1) The Constitutional Court pronounces judgment on the unconstitutionality

1- of laws

(a) on application by a court;

(b) ex officio in so far as he will have to apply such a law in a suit pending before him;

(c) on application by a person who alleges to have infringement of his rights directly by unconstitutionality, if the ordinance has become effective without a judicial decision having been rendered or a ruling having been rendered has become effective for this person;

(d) on application by a person who, as a party in a legal matter that has been decided by a court of justice of first instance, alleges infringement of his rights because of the application of an unconstitutional law, on the occasion of an appeal filed against that decision;

2- of federal laws also on application by the government of a province, a third of the members of the National Council or a third of the members of the Federal Council.

3- of provincial legislation also on application by the Federal Government or, if the constitutional law of a province so provides, on application of a third of the members of the Provincial Parliament.

Art. 89 para 3 is to be applied accordingly to applications according to subpara 1 (c) and (d).

(1a) If it is required to safeguard the purpose of the proceedings before the court of justice, filing an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 1 (d) can be declared inadmissible by a federal law. A federal law has to specify the effects of an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 1 (d).

(1b) The Constitutional Court can refuse, by order, to deal with an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 1 (c) or (d) until the time of the hearing if the application does not have sufficient prospects of success.

(2) If the litigant in a suit lodged with the Constitutional Court, entailing application of a law by the Court, receives satisfaction, the proceedings initiated to examine the law’s constitutionality shall nevertheless continue.

(3) The Constitutional Court may rescind a law as unconstitutional only to the extent that its rescission was expressly requested or the Constitutional Court would have to apply the law in the suit pending with it. If however the Constitutional Court concludes that the whole law was enacted by a legislative authority unqualified in accordance with the allocation of competence or published in an unconstitutional manner, it shall rescind the whole law as unconstitutional. This does not apply if rescission of the whole law manifestly runs contrary to the legitimate interests of the litigant who has filed an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 1 (c) or (d) above or whose suit has been the occasion for the ex officio initiation of examination proceedings into the law.

(4) If the law has at the time of the Constitutional Court’s delivery of its judgment already become ineffective and the proceedings were initiated ex officio or the application filed by a court or an applicant alleging infringement of his rights through the law’s unconstitutionality, the Constitutional Court must pronounce whether the law was unconstitutional. Para 3 above applies analogously.

(5) The judgment by the Constitutional Court which rescinds a law as unconstitutional imposes on the Federal Chancellor or the competent Governor the obligation to publish the rescission without delay. This applies analogously in the case of a pronouncement pursuant to para 4 above. The rescission enters into force upon expiry of the day of publication if the Constitutional Court does not set a deadline for the rescission. This deadline may not exceed eighteen months.

(6) If a law is rescinded as unconstitutional by a judgment of the Constitutional Court, the legal provisions rescinded by the law which the Constitutional Court has pronounced unconstitutional become effective again unless the judgment pronounces otherwise, on the day of entry into force of the rescission. The publication on the rescission of the law shall also announce whether and which legal provisions again enter into force.

(7) If a law has been rescinded on the score of unconstitutionality or if the Constitutional Court has pursuant to para 4 above pronounced a law to be unconstitutional, all courts and administrative authorities are bound by the Constitutional Court’s decision. The law shall however continue to apply to the circumstances effected before the rescission the case in point excepted, unless the Constitutional Court in its rescissory judgment decides otherwise. If the Constitutional Court has in its rescissory judgment set a deadline pursuant to para 5 above, the law shall apply to all the circumstances effected, the case in point excepted till the expiry of this deadline.

(8) For legal matters that gave reason to file an application pursuant to para 1 subpara 1 (d), a federal law has to specify that the decision by the Constitutional Court with which the law is rescinded as unconstitutional allows for a new decision to be made in that matter. The same shall apply accordingly in the case of a pronouncement pursuant to para 4.

Art. 140a. The Constitutional Court pronounces whether state treaties are contrary to law. Art. 140 shall apply to political, to law-modifying and to law-amending state treaties and to state treaties modifying the contractual bases of the European Union, Art. 139 to all other state treaties with the following proviso,

1- A state treaty of which the Constitutional Court establishes, that it is contrary to law or unconstitutional shall not be applied any more by the authorities competent for its execution from the expiry of the day of the judgment‘s publication unless the Constitutional Court determines a dead-line prior to which the treaty shall continue to be applied; such deadline must not exceed two years for the political, law-modifying and law-amending treaties and the treaties modifying the contractual bases of the European Union and one year in the case of all other treaties.

2- In addition, a provision, that the treaty is to be implemented by issuing ordinances or a resolution, that the treaty is to be implemented by the issuance of laws, becomes ineffective upon expiration of the day of the judgment’s publication.

Art. 141.

(1) The Constitutional Court pronounces upon

(a) challenges to the election of the Federal President and elections to the general representative bodies, the European Parliament and the constituent authorities (representative bodies) of statutory professional associations;

(b) challenges to elections to a Land Government and to municipal authorities entrusted with executive power;

(c) application by a general representative body for the loss of seat by one of its members; application by at least the half of the members of the European Parliament having been elected in Austria for a loss of seat by such a member of the European Parliament ;

(d) application by a municipal council for loss of seat of a member of the organ of the municipality, in charge of execution, and by a constituent organ (representative body) of a statutory professional association for loss of seat by one of the members of such organ;

on the challenge of the result of referenda, plebiscites, public opinion polls and European citizen action groups;

(f) on the registration of persons in electoral registers and deletion of persons from electoral registers;

(g) on the challenge of individually appealable rulings and decisions of administrative authorities and – if provided for in federal or provincial legislation – of the administrative courts in the cases of (a) to (f).

The challenge according to subpara a, b, e, f and g can be based on the alleged illegality of the procedure, the application according to subpara c and d on a reason provided by law for the loss of membership in a general representative body, in the European Parliament, in a municipal authority entrusted with executive power, or in a constituent authority (representative body) of a statutory professional association. The Constitutional Court shall allow challenge if the alleged illegality has been proven and was of influence on the result of the procedure. In proceedings before the administrative authority the general representative body and the statutory organ (representative body) of the statutory professional association has litigant status.

(2) If a challenge pursuant to para 1 subpara a above is allowed and it thereby becomes necessary to hold the election to a general representative body, to the European Parliament or to a constituent authority of a statutory professional association in whole or in part again, the representative body’s members concerned lose their seat at the time when it is assumed by those elected at the ballot which has to be held within a hundred days after delivery of the Constitutional Court’s decision.

(3) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 51/2012)

Art. 142.

(1) The Constitutional Court pronounces on suits which predicate the constitutional responsibility of the highest federal and provincial authorities for legal contraventions culpably ensuing from their official activity.

(2) Suit can be brought:

(a) against the Federal President, for contravention of the Federal Constitution: by a vote of the Federal Assembly;

(b) against members of the Federal Government and the authorities placed with regard to responsibility on an equal footing with them, for contravention of the law: by a vote of the National Council;

(c) against an Austrian representative in the Council for contravention of law in matters where legislation would pertain to the Federation: by a vote of the National Council for contravention of law in matters where legislation would pertain to the provinces: by identically worded votes of all the Provincial Parliament;

(d) against members of a Land Government and the authorities placed by the present law or the provincial constitution with regard to responsibility on an equal footing with them, for contravention of the law: by a vote of the competent Provincial Parliament;

(e) against a governor, his deputy (Art. 105 para 1) or a member of the Land Government (Art. 103 paras 2 and 3) for contravention of the law as well as for non-compliance with ordinances or other directives (instructions) of the Federation in matters pertaining to the indirect federal administration, in the case of a member of the Land Government also with regard to instructions from the governor in these matters: by a vote of the Federal Government;

(f) against the authorities of the federal capital Vienna, in so far as within its autonomous sphere of competence they perform functions from the domain of the federal executive power, for contravention of the law: by a vote of the Federal Government;

(g) against a Governor for non-compliance with an instruction pursuant to Art. 14 para 8: by a vote of the Federal Government;

(h) against a president or executive president of a provincial school board, for contravention of the law as well as for noncompliance with ordinances or other directives (instructions) of the Federation: by a vote of the Federal Government.

(i) against members of a Land Government for contravention of the law and for impediment of the powers conferred by Art. 11 para 9, in so far as matters of Art. 11 para 1 subpara 8 are concerned: by a vote of the National Council or of the Federal Government.

(3) If pursuant to para 2 subpara e above the Federal Government brings a suit only against a governor or his deputy and it is shown that another member of the Land Government in accordance with Art. 103 para 2 concerned with matters pertaining to the indirect federal administration is guilty of an offence within the meaning of para 2 subpara e above, the Federal Government can at any time pending the passing of judgment widen its suit to include this member of the Land Government.

(4) The condemnation by the Constitutional Court shall pronounce forfeiture of office and, in particularly aggravating circumstances, also a temporary forfeiture of political rights. In the case of minor legal contraventions in the instances mentioned in para 2 subparas c, e, g and h above the Constitutional Court can con-fine itself to the statement that the law has been contravened. From forfeiture of the office of president of the provincial school board ensures forfeiture of the office with which pursuant to Art. 81a para 3 subpara b it is linked.

(5) The Federal President can avail himself of the right vested in him in accordance with Art. 65 para 2 subpara c only on the request of the representative body or the representative bodies which voted for the filing of the suit, but if the Federal Government has voted for the filing of the suit only at its request, and in all cases only with the approval of the defendant.

Art. 143. A suit can be brought against the persons mentioned in Art. 142 also on the score of actions involving penal proceedings connected with the activity in office of the individual to be arraigned. In this case competence lies exclusively with the Constitutional Court; any investigation already pending in the ordinary criminal courts devolves upon it. The Constitutional Court can in such cases, in addition to Art. 142 para 4, apply the provisions of the criminal law.

Art. 144.

(1) The Constitutional Court pronounces on rulings by an administrative court in so far as the appellant alleges an infringement by the ruling of a constitutionally guaranteed right or on the score of an illegal ordinance, an illegal pronouncement on the republication of a law (treaty), an unconstitutional law, or an unlawful treaty.

(2) The Constitutional Court can refuse, by order, to deal with a complaint until the hearing if the complaint by does not sufficiently seem to be successful or if the decision cannot be expected to clarify a constitutional problem.

(3) In case the Constitutional Court finds that the decision of the administrative court has not violated a right in the sense of para 1, it has, on appeal by the appellant, to decide whether the appellant has been violated in another right, to forward the complaint to the (Federal) Administrative Court. To resolutions according para 2 the first phrase is to be applied accordingly.

(4) To resolutions of the administrative courts the provisions of this article to be applied to their decisions are to be applied accordingly. The specific law determining the organization and the procedure of the Constitutional Court provides, to which extent complaints may be raised against resolutions of the administrative court.

(5) To the extent the decision or the resolution of the administrative court concerns the admissibility of the revision, an appeal according to para 1 is not admissible.

Art. 145. The Constitutional Court pronounces judgment on contraventions of international law in accordance with the provisions of a special federal law.

Art. 146.

(1) The enforcement of judgments pronounced by the Constitutional Court made in accordance with Art. 126a, Art. 127c subpara 1 and Art. 137 is implemented by the ordinary courts.

(2) The enforcement of other judgments by the Constitutional Court is incumbent on the Federal President. Implementation shall in accordance with his instructions lie with the federal or provincial authorities, including the Federal Army, appointed at his discretion for the purpose. The request to the Federal President for the enforcement of such judgments shall be made by the Constitutional Court. The afore-mentioned instructions by the Federal President require, if it is a matter of enforcements against the Federation or against federal authorities, no countersignature in accordance with Art. 67.

Art. 147.

(1) The Constitutional Court consists of a President, a Vice-President, twelve additional members and six substitute members.

(2) The President, the Vice-President, six additional members and three substitute members are appointed by the Federal President on the recommendation of the Federal Government; these members and the substitute members shall be selected from among judges, administrative officials, and professors holding a chair in law. The remaining six members and three substitute members are appointed by the Federal President on the basis of proposals submitted by the National Council for three members and two substitute members and by the Federal Council for three members and one substitute member. Three members and two substitute members must have their domicile outside the federal capital, Vienna. Administrative officials on active service who are appointed members or substitute members shall be exempted, with their pay terminating, from all official duties. This shall not apply to administrative officials appointed substitute members who for the term of such exemption have been freed from all activities in the pursuit of which they are bound by instructions.

(3) The members and substitute members of the Constitutional Court must have completed legal studies or studies in law and political science and have had ten years of professional experience.

(4) The following cannot belong to the Constitutional Court: members of the Federal Government, or a Land Government furthermore members of a general representative body or of the European Parliament; for members of a general representative body or of the European Parliament; who have been elected for a fixed term of legislation or office such incompatibility continues until the expiry of that term of legislation or office. Finally persons who are in the employ of or hold office in a political party cannot belong to the Constitutional Court.

(5) Anyone who during the preceding five years has exercised one of the functions specified in para 4 above cannot be appointed President or Vice-President of the Constitutional Court.

(6) Art. 87 paras 1 and 2 and Art. 88 para 2 apply to members and substitute members of the Constitutional Court; detailed provisions will be prescribed in the federal law to be promulgated pursuant to Art. 148. 31 December of the year in which a member or substitute member completes his seventieth year of life is fixed as the age limit on whose attainment his term of office ends.

(7) If a member or substitute member disregards without satisfactory excuse three successive requests to attend a hearing of the Constitutional Court, the Constitutional Court shall formally establish the fact after listening to his testimony. Establishment of the fact entails loss of membership or the status of substitute membership.

(8) The President of the Constitutional Court supervises the employees of the Constitutional Court.

Art. 148. Detailed provisions about the organization and procedure of the Constitutional Court will be prescribed by a special federal law and in standing orders to be voted by the Constitutional Court on the basis of this.

Chapter VIII

Ombudsman Board

Art. 148a.

(1) Everyone can lodge complaint with the ombudsman board (Commission for Complaints from the Public) against alleged maladministration by the Federation, including its activity as a holder of private rights, mainly for alleged violation of human rights, provided that they are affected by such maladministration and in so far as they do not or no longer have recourse to legal remedy. All such complaints must be investigated by the ombudsman board. The complainant shall be informed of the investigation’s outcome and what action, if necessary, has been taken.

(2) The ombudsman board is ex officio entitled to investigate its suspicions of maladministration by the Federation including its activity as a holder of private rights, mainly of violations of human rights it assumes.

(3) For the protection and the advancement of human rights it is incumbent on the Ombudsman Board and the commissions appointed by it (Art. 148h para 3) in the area of the administration of the Federation including its activity as holder of private rights

1- to visit and inspect the location of deprivation of liberty,

2- to watch and check in advisory manner the conduct of the organs authorized to exert direct administrative power and compulsion as well as

3- to check respectively visit certain institutions and programs for handicapped persons

(4) Notwithstanding para 1 anyone can complain with the Ombudsman board for alleged delay of a Court to hear a case, if being personally affected. Para 2 applies accordingly.

(5) It is moreover incumbent on the ombudsman board to assist in the disposal of petitions and group memorials presented to the National Council. The Federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders stipulates the details.

(6) The ombudsman board is independent in the exercise of its authority.

Art. 148b.

(1) All federal, provincial, municipal authorities and municipal associations as well as other self-administrating bodies shall support the ombudsman board in the performance of its tasks, allow it inspection of its records, and upon request furnish the information required. Official confidentiality is inoperative towards the ombudsman board.

(2) The ombudsman board must observe official confidentiality to the same degree as the authority who it has approached in the fulfilment of its tasks. The ombudsman board is however bound by the observation of official confidentiality in its reports to the National Council only in so far as this is requisite on behalf of the interest of the parties concerned or of national security.

(3) Paras 1 and 2 apply accordingly to the members of the commissions and the members and substitute members of the Human Rights Council.

Art. 148c. The ombudsman board can issue to the authorities entrusted with the Federation’s highest administrative business recommendations on measures to be taken in or by reason of a particular case. In matters of autonomous administration or of administration by agents not bound by instructions the ombudsman board can issue recommendations to the autonomous administrative authority or to the agency not bound by instructions the Federation’s highest administrative authority shall likewise have its attention drawn to such recommendations, the authority concerned must within a deadline to be settled by federal law either conform to the recommendations and inform the ombudsman board accordingly or state in writing why the recommendations have not been complied with. The Ombudsman board may in a specific case at the occasion of a certain case request a deadline to cure the delay by a court (Art. 148a para 4) and suggest measures of supervisory control.

Art. 148d.

(1) The ombudsman board shall annually render the National Council and the Federal Council a report on its activity. In addition, the ombudsman board can report on singular observations any time to the National Council and the Federal Council. The reports by the ombudsman board, after having been presented to the National Council and the Federal Council, are to be published.

(2) The members of the ombudsman board are entitled to participate in the debates by the National Council and the Federal Council and by their committees (sub-committees) on the ombudsman board’s reports and on each occasion to be given at their request a hearing. The members of the ombudsman board shall have this right also in respect of the debates by the National Council and its committees (sub-committees) on the draft Federal Finance Law´s chapter subdivisions concerning the ombudsman board. Details are stipulated in the federal law on the National Council’s Standing Orders and the Standing Orders of the Federal Council.

Art. 148f. If differences of opinion arise between the ombudsman board and the Federal Government or a Federal Minister on the interpretation of legal provisions. The Constitutional Court on application by the Federal Government or the ombudsman board decides the matter.

Art. 148g.

(1) The ombudsman board has its seat in Vienna and consists of three members one of whom acts in turn as chairman. The term of office lasts six years. Re-election of the ombudsman board’s members more than once is inadmissible.

(2) The ombudsman board members are elected by the National Council on the basis of a joint recommendation drawn up by the main committee in the presence of at least half its members. Each of the three parties with the largest number of mandates in the National Council is entitled to nominate one member for this recommendation. In case of equal number of mandates the number of votes cast in the last National Council election is decisive. The members of the ombudsman board render an affirmation to the Federal President before their assumption of office.

(3) The ombudsman board chairmanship rotates annually between the members in the sequence of the number of mandates, in case of equal number of man-dates in the sequence of number of votes possessed by the parties who have nominated them. This sequence remains unchanged during the ombudsman board’s term of office.

(4) Should an ombudsman board member retire prematurely, the party represented in the National Council which nominated this member shall nominate a new member. The new election for the remaining term of office shall be effected pursuant to para 2 above. The allocation of business in force is to be applied to the new member till an eventual new allocation of business is rendered.

(5) Ombudsman board members must be eligible for the National Council and have knowledge of the organization and functioning of administration and knowledge in the field of human rights; during their service in office they may belong neither to a general representative body nor to the European Parliament, not be member of the Federal Government or the government of a province and not practise any other profession.

Art. 148h.

(1) Ombudsman board officials are appointed by the Federal President on the recommendation and with the countersignature of the ombudsman board chairman. The Federal President can however authorize him to appoint officials in certain categories. Auxiliary-personnel is appointed by the chairman who is to this extent the highest administrative authority and exercises these powers in his own right.

(2) The federation’s supervise with regard to ombudsman board-employees is exercised by the ombudsman board chairman.

(3) In order to fulfil the tasks according to Art. 148a para 3 the ombudsman board has to appoint commissions and create a Human Rights Council as its advisor. The Human Rights Council consists of a Chairman, a Deputy Chairman and other members and substitute members being appointed by the ombudsman board. Federal law provides to which extent the ombudsman board in appointing members and substitute members of the Human Rights Council is bound by proposals of other institutions. The Chairman, the Deputy Chairman and the other members of the Human Rights Council are not bound by any instructions in exerting their activity.

(4) The ombudsman board resolves standing orders and on allocation of business, which mainly has to provide, which tasks are to be handled individually by the members of the ombudsman board. The resolution on the standing orders and the allocation of business requires unanimity of the members of the ombudsman board.

Art. 148i.

(1) The provinces can by provincial constitutional law declare the ombudsman board competent also in the sphere of the particular provincial administration. In such case Art. 148f shall apply analogously.

(2) If provinces create agencies in the sphere of provincial administration with tasks similar to the ombudsman board, provincial constitutional law can prescribe a provision corresponding to Art. 148f above.

(3) A province not making use of the authorization of para 1 regarding the tasks according to Art 148a para 3, has to create by constitutional law of the province an agency for tasks similar to Art. 148a para 3 for the sphere of the administration of the province and to provide the corresponding provisions in order to handle the tasks according to Art. 148c and Art. 148d.

Art. 148j. Detailed provisions relating to the implementation of this chapter shall be made by federal law.

Chapter IX

Final Provisions

Art. 149.

(1) In addition to the present law, the following laws, with the modifications necessitated by this law, shall within the meaning of Art. 44 para 1 be regarded as constitutional law:

Basic Law of 21 December 1867, RGBl. No. 142, on the general rights of nationals in the kingdoms and provinces represented in the Council of the Realm;

Law of 27 October 1862, RGBl. No. 88, on Protection of the Rights of the Home;

Resolution of the Provisional National Assembly of 30 October 1918, StGBl. No. 3;

Law of 3 April 1919, StGBl. No. 209, respecting the banishment and expropriation of the House of Habsburg-Lothringen;

Law of 3 April 1919. StGBl. No. 211, on the abolition of the nobility, the secular orders of chivalry, male and female, and of certain titles and dignities;

Section V of Part III of the Treaty of Saint-Germain of 10 September 1919, StGBl. No. 303 of 1920.

(2) Art. 20 of the basic law of 21 December 1867, RGBl. No. 142 as well as the law of 5 May 1869, RGBl. No. 66, issued on the basis of this article, become ineffective.

Art. 150. The transition to the federal constitution introduced by this law will be prescribed in a special law entering into force simultaneously with the present law.

(2) Laws in accordance with a new formulation of federal constitutional law provisions may be issued as from the promulgation of the constitutional law rendering the change effective. They may not however enter into force prior to the entry into force of the new federal constitutional legal provisions in so far as they do not solely stipulate measures requisite for their incipient implementation upon the entry into force of the new federal constitutional law provisions.

Art. 151.

(1) Art. 78d and Art. 118 para 8, as amended by the Federal Constitutional Law published in Federal Law Gazette. No 565/1991, enter into force on 1 January 1992. The existence of constabularys existent on 1 January 1992 remains unaffected; this provision enters into force on 1 January 1992.

(2) Art. 10 para 1 No 7, Art. 52a, Arts. 78a to 78c, Art. 102 para 2 as well as the designation changes in Chapter III and in Art. 102, as formulated in the federal constitutional law published in Federal Law Gazette No 565/1991, enter into force on 1 May 1993.

(3) Art. 102 para 5 second sentence as well as paras 6 and 7 are repealed as of midnight 30 April 1993. The words “, excluding the local security administration,” in Art. 102 para 2 are repealed as of midnight 30 April 1993.

(4) Art. 26, Art. 41 para 2, Art. 49b para 3, Art. 56 paras 2 to 4, Art. 95 paras 1 to 3, Art. 96 para 3, and moreover the new designation of para 1 in Art. 56, as formulated in the Federal constitutional law published in Federal Law Gazette No 470 /1992, enter into force on 1 May 1993.

(5) Art. 54, as formulated in the Federal constitutional law published in Federal Law Gazette No 868 of 1992, enter into force on 1 January 1993.

(6) The following provisions, as formulated in the Federal constitutional law published in Federal Law Gazette No 508 of 1993, enter into force as follows:

1- Art. 10 para 1 subpara 9, Art. 11 para 1 subpara 7 as well as Art. 11 paras 6, 7, 8 and 9 on 1 July 1994;

2- Art. 28 para 5, Art. 52 para 2, the designation of the former Art. 52 paras 2 and 3 as paras 3 and 4, as well as Art 52b on 1 October 1993;

3- (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 114/2000)

(7) (Note: repealed by F.L.G. I No. 127/2009)

(7a) Art. 102 para 2, as amended by Federal Constitutional, Law Federal Law Gazette I No. 2/1997, enter into force on 1 January 1994. Art.102 para 2, in the version of the Federal Law Gazette No. 532/ 1993, ceases to be effective simultaneously.

(8) Art. 54 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 268/1994 enter into force on 1 April 1994.

(9) Art. 6 paras 2 and 3, Art. 26 para 2, Art. 41 para 2, Art. 49b para 3 and Art. 117 para 2 first sentence, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 504/1994 enter into force on 1 January 1995. In the federal and provincial legal regulations the term “domicile” in all its grammatical versions is replaced by the term “principal residence” as of 1 January 1996 unless the term “domicile” is replaced by the term “principal residence” until midnight 31 December 1995. The term “domicile” must not be used any more in federal and provincial legal regulations as of 1 January 1996; for as long as provincial law does not stipulate that Provincial Parliament or municipal council suffrage depends on the principal residence or the residence it depends on the domicile. As regards the division of the number of deputies among the constituencies (electoral bodies) and as regards regional constituencies (Art. 26 para 2) and the representation of the provinces in the Federal Council (Art. 34) the domicile as established by the last general census holds good as principal residence up to the time when the results of the next general census will be at hand.

(10) Art. 87 para 3 and Art. 88a in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 506/1994 enter into force on 1 July 1994.

(11) The following holds good for the entry into force of provisions newly formulated or inserted by the Federal Constitutional Law published in Federal Law Gazette No. 1013/1994, the abrogation of provisions revoked by this same federal constitutional law as well as the transition to the new legal status:

1- the title of this law, Art. 21 paras 6 and 7, Art. 56 paras 2 and 4, Art. 122 paras 3 to 5, Art. 123 para 2, Art. 123a para 1, Art. 124, Art. 147 para 2 second sentence as well as Art. 150 para 2 enter into force on 1 January 1995.

2- The heading of chapter I, the heading of section A in chapter I, Art. 10 para 1 subpara 18, Art. 16 para 4, section B of chapter I, Art. 30 para 3, Art. 59, Art. 73 para 2, Art. 117 para 2, Art. 141 paras 1 and 2, Art. 142 para 2 subpara c and designations of the henceforth subparas d to i as well as Art. 142 paras 3 to 5 enter into force simultaneously with the Treaty on the Accession of the Republic of Austria to the European Union.

3- Art. 10 paras 4 to 6 and Art. 16 para 6 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 276/1992 ceases to be effective simultaneously with the entry into force of the provisions specified in subpara 2.

4- Art. 122 para 1 and Art. 127b enter into force on 1 January 1997. They apply to acts of administration of public funds subsequent 31 December 1994.

5- For as long as the representatives of Austria in the European Parliament have not been elected in a general election, they shall be delegated by the National Council from among the members of the Federal Assembly. This delegation ensues on the basis of proposals by the parties represented in accordance with their strength pursuant to the principle of proportional representation. For the period of their delegation members of the National Council and of the Federal Council can simultaneously be members of the European Parliament. If a member of the National Council delegated to the European Parliament relinquishes his seat as a member of the National Council, Art. 56 paras 2 and 3 apply. Art. 23b paras 1 and 2 hold well analogously as well.

6- Subpara 5 enters into force on 22 December 1994.

(11a) Art. 112 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 1013/ 1994 and Art. 103 para 3 and Art. 151 para 6 subpara 3 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 8/ 1999 enter into force on 1 January 1995.

(12) Art.59a, Art.59b and Art.95 para 4 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 392/1996, enter into force on 1 August 1996. Until provincial legal regulations are passed pursuant to Art. 59a and Art. 95 para 4, the appropriate federal legal regulations shall analogously apply in the provinces concerned unless the provinces have already passed regulations within the meaning of Art. 59a and Art. 95 para 4.

(13) Art. 23e para 6 and Art. 28 para 5, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 437/1996, enter into force on 15 September 1996.

(14) Art. 49 and Art. 49a paras 1 and 3, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette No. 659/1996, enter into force on 1 January 1997.

(15) Art. 55, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 2/1997, enter into force on 1 January 1997. Art. 54 is repealed simultaneously.

(16) Art. 147 para 2, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 64/1997, enters into force on 1 August 1997.

(17) Art. 69 paras 2 and 3, Art. 73 para 1, Art. 73 para 3 and Art. 148d in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I 87/1997, enter into force on 1 September 1997. Art. 129, section B of chapter VI, Art. 131 para 3 and the new designations of the sections in chapter VI enter into force on 1 January 1998.

(18) Art. 9a para 4, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 30/1998, enters into force on 1 January 1998.

(19) Article 23f enters into force simultaneously with the Treaty of Nice The Federal Chancellor shall announce this date in the Federal Law Gazette.

(20) In Art. 149 para 1, the following parts are repealed:

1- the adding of the Constitutional Law of 30 November 1945, Federal Law Gazette No.6 of 1946, concerning the Act on the Protection of Personal Liberty of 27 October 1862, RGBl. No. 87, in the proceedings before the People’s Court upon expiry of 30 December 1955;

2- the words “Law of 8. May 1919, StGBl. No. 257, on the coat of arms and seal of state of the Republic of German-Austria, with the modifications effected by Arts. 2, 5 and 6 of the law of 21 October 1919, StGBl. No. 484;” upon expiry of 31 July 1981.

(21) The words “or through the exercise of direct administrative power and compulsion” in Art. 144 para 3 are repealed as of midnight 31 December 1990.

(22) The Arts. 10 para 1 subpara 14, Art. 15 paras 3 and 4, 18 para 5, 21, 37 para 2, 51b para 6, 52 b para 1, 60 para 2, 78d para 2, 102 para 1, the new designation of Art. 102 para 6 and the Arts. 118 para 8, 118a and 125 para 3, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 8/1999 enters into force on 1 January 1999. Art. 102 para 5 is repealed upon expiry of 31 December 1998.

(23) The Arts. 30 para 3 first sentence, 127c, 129c para 4, 147 para 2 fourth and fifth sentence, and 147 para 6 first sentence, in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 148/ 1999 enter into force on 1 August 1999.

(24) Art. 8 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 68/2000 enter into force on 1 August 2000.

(25) Art. 11 para 8 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 114/2000 enters into force on 1. December 2000. Art. 151 para 6 subpara 3 ceases to be effective upon expiry of 24 November 2000.

(26) In the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 121/2001 enter into force:

1- Art. 18 para 3 and Art. 23e para 5 on 1 January 1997.

2- Art. 21 para 1 and para 6 on 1 January 1999;

3- Art. 147 para 2 first sentence on 1 August 1999;

4- Art. 18 para 4, Art. 23b para 2, Art 39 para 2 and Art. 91 para 2 on 1 January 2002;

5- Art. 23f para 1 to 3 simultaneously with the treaty of Nice. The Federal Chancellor has to publish this date in the Federal Law Gazette I.

(27) Art. 14b, Art. 102 para 2 and Art. 131 para 3 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 99/2002 enter into force on 1 January 2003. § 2, § 4 para 1, § 5 and § 6 para 1 and 2 of the transition Law Gazette No 368/1925 apply accordingly. A provincial law having become federal law according to the second sentence per 1 January 2003 ceases to be effective with the entering into force of a provincial law passed on the basis of Art. 14b para 3, the latest upon expiry of 30 June 2003; simultaneously the corresponding regulations of the Federal Tender Law 2002, Federal Law Gazette I No. 99/2002 enter into force to this extent.

(28) Art. 23a para 1 and 3, Art. 26 para 1 and 4, Art. 41 para 2, Art. 46 para 2, Art. 49b para 3 and Art 60 para 3 first sentence in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 90/2003 enter into force on 1 January 2004.

(29) Art. 11 para 8 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 114/2000 and Federal Law Gazette I No. 100/2003 enters into force on 1 December 2000, Art. 151 para 7 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 100/2003 upon expiry of the day of publication of this Federal Law. Art. 7 para 1, Art. 8, Art. 8a, Art. 9a, Art. 10 para 1 subpara 10, Art. 13 para 1, Art. 14 para 1, para 5 subpara a and para 8, Art. 14a, Art. 15 para 4, Art. 18 para 4 und 5, Art. 23 para 1 and 5, Art. 23e para 6, Art. 26, Art. 30 para 2, Art. 34 para 2, Art. 35 para 1, Art. 42 pa-ra 4, Art. 47 para 1, Art. 48, Art 49, Art. 49a, Art. 51, Art. 51a, Art. 51 b, Art. 51c, Art. 52b, Art. 57, Art.71, Art.73, Art.81a para.1, 4 and 5, Art. 87a, Art. 88a, Art.89, Art.97 para 1 and 4, Art.102 para 2, Art. 112, Art. 115, Art.116, Art. 116a, Art. 117, Art. 118, Art. 118a, Art. 119, Art. 119a, Art. 126a, Art. 126b para 2, Art. 127 para 3, Art. 127a, Art. 127c, Art. 134 para 3, Art. 135, Art. 136, Art. 137, Art. 139, Art. 139a, Art. 140, Art. 140a, Art. 144, Art. 146 para 1, Art. 147 para 3, Art. 148, Art. 148a, Art. 148b, Art. 148e to Art. 148j and Art. 149 as well as the headings and the other regulations in the version of the Federal Law Gazette No. 100/2003 enter into force on 1 January 2004.

(30) Art. 11 para 1 subpara 7 and 8 as well as para 9 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 118/2004 enter into force on 1 January 2005, however not before the expiry of the day of the publication of the federal law named in the Federal Law Gazette. To the extent the federal legislation does not provide other-wise, simultaneously the existing provincial regulations in the matters of Art. 11 para 1 subpara 8 cease to be effective.

(31) Art. 10 para 1 subpara 9 and Art. 151 para 7 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 153/2004 enter into force on 1 January 2005.

(32) Art. 14 para 5a, 6, 6a, 7a and 10 and Art. 14a para 7 and 8 enter into force upon expiry of the day of the publication of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 31/2005 in the Federal Law Gazette.

(33) In the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 81/2005 enter into force:

1- Art. 151 para 31 upon expiry of 30 December 2004;

2- Art 8 para 3 upon expiry of the month of the publication of this Federal Constitutional Act.

(33a) Art. 129 a, Art. 129b and Art. 129c para 1, 3, 5 and 7 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 100/2005 enter into force on 1 January 2006.

(34) Art. 9a para 3 and 4, Art. 10 para 1 subpara 15 and Art. 102 para 2 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 106/2005 enter into force on 1 January 2006.

(35) Art. 88a in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No 121/2005 enters into force on 1 November 2005.

(36) The following applies to the entering into force of the regulations modified or added by the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No 27/2007 and the ceasing to be effective of the regulations deleted by this federal constitutional law as well as to the transition for the new legal situation:

1- Art. 23a para 1, 3 and 4, Art. 26 Abs. 1, 4, 6 and 8, Art. 30 para 3, Art.41 para 3, Art. 46, Art. 49b para 1 first sentence and para 3 second sentence, Art. 60 para 1 and para 3 first sentence, Art. 95 para 1, 2, 4 and 5, Art. 117 para 2 and 6 as well as Art. 151 para 33a enter into force on 1 July 2007; simultaneously Art. 23 a para 5 and 6 cease to be effective. The provincial regulations are to be adjusted to the new legal situation till expiry of 31 December 2007.

2- Art. 26a enters into force on 1. July 2007. The modification of the Federal Election Board according to this regulation has to take place till expiry of 31 August 2007; the details in this regard shall be determined by the election regulations to the National Council.

3- Art. 27 para 1 enters into force at the beginning of the XXIV. legislation-period.

(37) The following applies to the entering into force of the regulations added or newly determined by Art. 1 of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No.1/2008:

1- Art. 13 para 2 and 3, Art. 51 in the version of subpara 4, Art. 51a, Art. 51b in the version of subpara 7 to 9a, Art. 123a, para 1 and Art. 148d enter in-to force on 1 January 2009; the Federal Finance Frame Law for the financial years 2009 till 2012 and the Federal Finance Law for the financial year 2009 are to be prepared and passed already on the basis of these regulations and the draft of the Federal Finance Frame Law for the financial years 2009 till 2012 is to submitted to the National Council the latest simultaneously with the draft for the Federal Finance Law for the financial year 2009.

2- Art. 51 in the version of subpara 5, Art. 51b in the version of subpara 10, Art. 51c and 51d enter into force on 1 January 2013. Art. 51 in the version of subpara 4 and Art. 51b in the version of subpara 7 to 9a cease to be effective upon expiry of 31 December 2012. This legal situation already applies to the preparation of the Federal Finance Frame Law for the financial years 2013 till 2016 as well as of the Federal Finance Law for the Financial Year 2013 and the passing of the Law by the National Council.

Art. 51a in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 100/2003 continues to be applied till the expiration of 31 December 2012.

(38) Art. 2 para 3, Art. 3 para 2 to 4, Art. 9 para 2, Art. 10 para 3 second and third sentence, Art. 20 para 1 and 2, Art. 23f para 1 last sentence and para 3, Art. 50, Art. 52 para 1a, the sixth sub section of section A of the third chapter, Art. 67a, Art. 88 para 1, Art. 90a, Art. 112, the headings above Art. 115, section B of the (new) fifth chapter, the headings above Art. 121 and Art. 129, Art. 134 para 6, the heading above Art. 148a, Art. 148a para 3 to 5, Art. 148c last sentence and the heading above Art. 149 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 2/2008 enter into force on 1 January 2008. The federal- and provincial laws necessary for the adaptation to Art. 20 para 2 last sentence and Art. 120b para 2 are to be passed the latest till the expiry of 31 December 2009.

(39) Art. 10 para 1 subpara 1, 3, 6 and 14, Art. 78d para 2, Art 102 para 2, Art. 129, section B of the (new) seventh chapter, Art. 132a, Art 135 para 2 and 3, Art. 138 para 1, Art. 140 para 1 first sentence and Art. 144a in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 2/2008 enter into force on 1 July 2008. To the transition to the new legal situation applies:

1- Per 1 July 2008 the former independent Federal Asylum Tribunal becomes the Asylum Court.

2- Till the appointment of the president, the vice president and the other members of the Asylum Court the former chairman, the former deputy chairman and the former other members of the independent Federal Asylum Tribunal exert their functions. The measures necessary for the appointment of the president, the vice president and the other members of the Asylum Court as well as the hiring of extra judicial employees may al-ready take place upon expiry of the day of the publication of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 2/2008.

3- Members of the independent Federal Asylum Tribunal, applying for an appointment as member of the Asylum Court and having the personal and professional qualification for the appointment are entitled to appointment; the requirements of Art. 129d para 3 are deemed to be met by such applicants. The Federal Government decides on the appointment of such applicants.

4- Cases pending on 1 July 2008 at the independent Federal Asylum Tribunal are to be continued by the Asylum Court. Cases on complaints against decisions of the independent Federal Asylum Tribunal at the Administrative Court or at the Constitutional Court are to be continued by them with the proviso, that the Asylum Court is deemed to be the authority involved.

5- Starting 28 November 2007, in cases pending at the independent Federal Asylum Tribunal, a complaint for violation of the breach of the duty to reach a decision is no longer admissible. Cases already pending at the Administrative Court for violation of the onus of decision by the independent Federal Asylum Tribunal are deemed to be stayed upon expiry of 30 June 2008; the cases to which the complaint relates for violation of the onus of decision are to be continued by the Asylum Court.

(40) Art. 27, para 2, Art. 92 para 2, Art. 122 para 5, Art. 134 para 4 and 5 as well as Art. 147 para 4 first sentence and para 5 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No 2/2008 enter into force at the beginning of the XXIV legislation period. To persons, who at the beginning of the XXIV legislation period already carry a function in the sense of Art. 92 para 2, Art. 122 para 5, Art. 134 para 4 and 5 as well as Art. 147 para 4 first sentence and para 5, the regulations to be applied up to such date shall continue to be applied.

(41) Art. 28 para 4 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 31/2009 enters into force on 1 April 2009.

(42) Art. 20 para 2 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 50/2010 enters into force on 1 October 2010.

(43) Art. 23c, Art. 23d para 2, para 3 first and second phrase and para 5 first phrase, Art. 23e to Art. 23k and Art. 73 para 2 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 57/2010 enter into force on 1 August 2010.

(44) Art. 127a para 1, 3, 4 and 7 to 9, Art. 127c and Art. 146 para 1 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 98/2010 enter into force on 1 January 2011.

(45) Art. 6 para 4, Art. 26 para 5 and Art. 60 para 3 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 43/2011 enter into force on 1 October 2011. The repealing of Art. 60 para 3 second phrase so far does not affect the law concerning the expulsion of the house Habsburg-Lothringen and the takeover of their assets, StGBl. No. 209/1919.

(46) Art. 10 para 1 subpara 11 and Art. 102 para 2 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 58/2011 enter into force on 1 January 2012. For the transition to the new legal situation applies:

1- The provisions of the provincial laws governing fostering money become federal laws in the sense of this law.

2- The ordinances having been rendered on the basis of the laws named in subpara 1 become ordinances of the Federation and are deemed to be modified accordingly to the extent they contradict the organizational pro-visions of this law.

3- Federal law provides, to which extent the laws and ordinances named in subpara 1 and subpara 2 continue to be applied in proceedings pending on 1 January 2012; the implementation of such proceedings is the matter of the provinces. The provisions of this law to be applied in matters of Art. 11 are to be applied accordingly to this extent.

4- Federal law may provide detailed provisions for the transition to the new legal situation.

5-The Federal Minister in charge reports to the National Council and the Federal Council the latest till 31 December 2014 on the execution in matters of fostering money.

(47) Art. 15 para 10 second phrase, Art. 116a para 1 first phrase, Art. 116a para 1 subpara 1 and subpara 2, Art. 116a para 2, para 3 and 6 and Art. 116b in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 60/2011 enter into force on 1 October 2011.

(48) Art. 22, Art. 148a, Art. 148b para 1 first sentence and para 3, Art. 148c last sentence, Art. 148d, Art. 148g para 2 to 5, Art. 148h para 3 and 4 and Art. 148i para 3 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette. I No. 1/2012 enter into force on 1 July 2012. The organizational and personal measures necessary for the beginning of the activity of the commissions and of the Human Rights Council can already been taken by the Ombudsman board upon expiry of the date of publication of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 1/2012. If in a province a constitutional law of the province is in force on 1 July 2012, by which the Ombudsman board has been declared to be also competent for the administration of the province according to Art. 148i para 1, it is deemed to be a province having made use from this authorization also regarding tasks according to Art. 148a para 3 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 1/2012. Constitutional laws of the provinces ac-cording to Art. 148i para 3 are to be passed the latest till the expiry of 31 December 2012.

(49) Art. 10 para 1 subpara 1a and subpara 17, Art. 26 para 3 first phrase, Art. 26a first phrase and Art. 141 para 3 first phrase in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 12/2012 enter into force on 1 April 2012. Simultaneously Art. 10 para 1 subpara 18 is repealed.

(50) Art. 15 para 3 and 4, Art. 78a para 1, Art. 78b, Art. 78c, Art. 78d para 2 and Art. 102 para 1 in the version of the Federal Constitutional Law Gazette I No. 49/2012 enter into force on 1 September 2012; simultaneously the ordinance of the Federal Government on the constitution of Federal Police Directorates and the determination of the regional competence (Federal Police Directorate ordinance), Federal Law Gazette II No. 56/1999, becomes ineffective.

(51) For the entering into force of the provisions having been modified or inserted by Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012 and for the invalidation of the provisions repealed by this federal law as well as the transition to the new legal situation, the following is to be applied:

1- The organizational and personal measures necessary for the beginning of the activity of the Administrative Courts may already be taken upon expiry of the day of publication of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012. For the appointment of members of the Administrative Courts before the 1 January 2014, Art. 134 para 2, 3, 5 and 6 in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012 apply with the proviso, that the triple proposals of the plenary assembly of the Administrative Court resp. a committee to be elected among its members are not required.

2- Entitled to be appointed as member of the respective Administrative Court of the Federation is:

(a) who is Chairman, Deputy Chairman or President of a chamber of the Federal Tender Office on 1 July 2012 and applies to be appointed member of the Administrative Court of the Federation and has the personal and professional qualification to fulfil the tasks linked with the planned employment;

(b) who is member of the Independent Finance Senate on 1 July 2012 and applies to be appointed member of the administrative court of the Federation for Finance and has the personal and professional qualification to fulfil the tasks linked with the planned employment.

3- The President and the Vice-President of the administrative court of the Federation are to be appointed by the Federal Government within six weeks after expiry of the day of publication of Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012.

4- The application to be appointed as other member of the respective administrative court of the Federation may be filed till the expiry of 31 December 2012. The preconditions of Art. 134 para 3 last phrase are deemed to be fulfilled for such applicants. The Federal Government decides on the appointment of such applicants till the expiry of 28 February 2013. Per-sons, whose application is denied, are entitled to file complaint against the refusing ruling according to Art. 130 para 1 subpara a with the (Federal) Administrative Court and according to Art. 144 with the Constitutional Court.

5- The right to appoint members for the Administrative Courts of the provinces and the procedure on the appointment are to be determined by provincial law under equal principles.

6- Art. 10 para 1 subpara 3, Art. 10 para 1, subpara 8, Art. 11 para 2, Art. 14a para 5 first phrase, Art. 14b para 5 second phrase, Art. 15 para 6 last-but-one phrase, Art 18 para 5, Art. 22, Art. 23f para 2, Art. 42a, Art. 43, Art. 49 para 2, Art. 50 para 2 and 3, Art 97 para 2 and 4, Art. 101a, Art. 102 para 2, Art. 117 para 8, Art. 118 para 3 subpara 9, Art 127c subpara 3, Art. 140a, Art. 147 para 3, Art. 148a para 3 subpara 3 and Art. 148b para 1 first phrase in the version of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012 as well as Art. 131 para 3 in the version of Art. 1 sub-para 61 and Art. 134 para 3 in the version of Art. 1 subpara 62 of this federal law enter into force upon expiry of the month of the publication; simultaneously Art. 15 para 5, Art. 98 and Art. 127c subpara 4 become ineffective. Art. 10 para 1 subpara 1, Art. 11 para 9 (para 7 new), Art. 12 pa-ra 4 (para 2 new), Art. 20 para 2, Art. 21 para 1 last phrase, Art. 81b pa-ra 3 first phrase, the headline to chapter B of the third main part, Art. 82 para 1, Art. 83 para 1, Art. 86 para 1, Art. 87 para 3, Art. 88 para 2 and 3, Art. 88a, Art. 89 para 1 to 3 and 5, Art. 90 para 1, Art. 90a, Art. 94,

Art. 109, Art. 112, Art. 115 para 2, Art. 118 para 4, Art. 119a para 9, the articles 129 to 136 including the headlines of the chapters (chapter A new of the seventh main part), the headline of chapter D (chapter B new) of the seventh main part, Art. 138 para 1 subpara 2, Art. 139 para 1, 3 and 4 first sentence, Art. 139a, Art. 140 para 1, 3 last phrase and 4 first sentence, Art. 141 para 1, Art. 144, Art. 147 para 8, Art. 148i para 1 and 2 and the exhibit in the version of Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012 enter into force on 1 January 2014; simultaneously Art. 11 para 7 and 8, Art. 12 pa-ra 2 and 3, Art. 14b para 6, Art. 15 para 7, Art. 81a para 4 last phrase, Art. 81c para 3, Art. 103 para 4, Art. 111, Art. 119a para 5, Art. 141 pa-ra 3, Art. 144a and Art. 148e become ineffective.

7- On 1 January 2014 the Asylum Court becomes Administrative Court of the Federation; the members of the Asylum Court become members of the Administrative Court of the Federation.

8- On 1 January 2014 the independent administrative senates in the provinces, the Federal Tender Office and the Independent Finance Senate (in the following: independent administrative authorities) are dissolved; in addition the administrative authorities named in the exhibit (in the following: other independent administrative authorities) are dissolved. The jurisdiction to continue the proceedings pending on the expiration of 31 December 2013 at these authorities as well as the proceedings pending at the supervisory authorities on representations (Art. 119a para 5) passes to the administrative courts; this also applies to procedures pending at other authorities in which these authorities may be superior authority on the merits or superior authority in the course of appeal, with the exception of organs of the municipality.

9- The administrative courts replace the independent administrative authorities, other independent administrative authorities and, to the extent com-plaint procedures are concerned, all other administrative authorities except those administrative authorities having decided in first and final instance or had been under the onus to decide, as well as with the exception of organs of the municipality, replace the administrative courts in procedures pending at the (Federal) Administrative Court and at the Constitutional Court upon expiry of 31 December 2013. After termination of the procedure before the (Federal) Administrative Court concerning the ruling or the lack of decision of an independent administrative authority or before the Constitutional Court concerning the ruling of such, the procedure is eventually to be continued before the administrative court.

10- Art. 131 para 3 in the version of Art. 1 subpara 61 of the Federal Law Gazette I No. 51/2012 continues to be applied in complaint procedures pending at the (Federal) Administrative Court upon expiry of 31 December 2013.

11- Further details on the transition of jurisdiction will be determined by federal law.

(52) Art. 50a to 50d in the version of Federal Law Gazette I Nr. 65/2012 enter into force simultaneously with the agreement to constitute the European stability mechanism.

(53) Art. 10 para 1 subparas 11 and 15 and Art. 102 para 2 as amended by the federal law promulgated in Federal Law Gazette I No. 59/2013 enter into force upon expiry of the month of publication of this federal law.

(54) The following provisions, as amended by the federal constitutional law promulgated in Federal Law Gazette I No. 114/2013, enter into force or cease to be effective:

1- as of 6 June 2012: para 51 subparas 4 and 6;

2- as of 1 July 2012: Art. 49 para 2 subpara 1;

3- upon expiry of the month of publication of this federal constitutional law: Art. 7 para 4, Art. 12 para 1 subpara 1, Art. 14a para 1, Art. 16 subpara 5, Art. 52 subpara 4, Art. 59b para 1 subpara 2, Art. 81a para. 1, Art. 127 para 8, Art. 147 para 6, Art. 148f and the foot note sign “*)” in para 11 sub-para 2 and the footnote to this provision;

4- as of 1 January 2014: Art. 94 para 2;

5- as of 1 January 2015: Art. 89 paras 2 to 4, Art. 139 paras 1, 1a, 1b, 3 last sentence, 4 and 7 and Art. 140 paras 1, 1a, 1b, 3 last sentence, 4 and 8.

(55) Art. 6 para 4, Art. 10 para 1 subpara 1, Art. 130 para 5 and Art. 141 para 1 (g) as amended by the federal constitutional law promulgated in Federal Law Gazette I No. 115/2013 enter into force as of 1 January 2014.

(56) The following provisions, as amended by the School Authorities Administrative Reform Act 2013 promulgated in Federal Law Gazette I No. 164/2013, enter in force:

1- upon expiry of the day of publication in the Federal Law Gazette: Art. 14 para 5 (a) and (b) and the introductory sentence of Art. 81b para 1,

2- as of 1 September 2013: Art. 81a para 1,

3- as of 1 August 2014: Art. 14 para 3 (a), para 4 (a), Art. 81a para 2 and para 3, Art. 81b para 1 (unless covered by subpara 1), Art. 132 paras 1 and 4 and Art. 133 para 6.

Art. 152. The execution of this law is entrusted to the Federal Government.

Exhibit

Dissolved Independent Administrative Authorities

Federation

1- Appellate senate in disciplinary penalty matters according to § 168 para 1 of the Law on Notaries (NO), Imp. Law Gazette No 75/1871;

2- Commission according to § 7 para 1 of the constitutional law of 8 May 1945 on the prohibition of NSDAP (Prohibition Law 1947), State Law Gazette No. 13/1945;

3- Agricultural Senates of the Provinces according to § 5 para 1 of the Agricultural Authority Law 1950, BGBl. No. 1/1951;

4- Supreme Agricultural Senate according to § 6 para 1 of the Agricultural Authority Law 1950, BGBl. No. 1/1951;

5- Appellate Commissions of the Provinces according to § 345 para 1 of the federal law of 9. September 1955 on General Social Insurance (ASVG), BGBl. No. 189;

6- Federal Arbitration Commission according to § 346 para 1 of the federal law of 9 September 1955 on General Social Insurance (ASVG), BGBl. No. 189;

7- Independent Pharmaceutical Products Commission according to § 351h para 1 of the federal law of 9 September 1955 on General Social Insurance (ASVG), BGBl. No. 189;

8- Rail-Control Commission according to § 81 para 1 of the federal law on railways, rail-vehicles on railways and the traffic on rail (Railway Law 1957 – EisbG), BGBl. No. 60;

9- Federal Compensation Commission according to § 20 para 1 of the federal law of 25 June 1958 on granting compensation for damages having occurred in connection with the occupation of Austria (Occupation Damages Law), BGBl. No. 126;

10- Commission to compensate claims under the Seventh Restitution-Law according to § 7 para 1 of the federal law of 12 December 1963 concerning the compensation of certain claims concerning employment in private economy, BGBl. No. 319;

11- Federal Distribution Commission according to § 17 of the federal law of 18 March 1964 on the distribution of incoming means concerning the agreement between the Republic of Austria and the People’s Republic of Bulgaria to settle open financial issues (Distribution Law Bulgaria), BGBl. No. 129;

12- Staff-Committee-Supervisory-Commission at the Federal Chancellor‘s Office according to § 39 para 1 of the federal law of 10 March 1967 on the Staff-Committee for government agencies (Government Agencies Staff-Committee-Law – PVG), BGBl. No. 133;

13- Disciplinary Senate according to § 49 of the federal law of 7 June 1967, governing the patent lawyers profession (Patentanwaltsgesetz), BGBl. No. 214;

14- Correctional Centre Chambers according to § 11a of the federal law of 26 March 1969 on the enforcement of confinements and preventive measures with lawful detention (Law on Detention – StVG), BGBl. No. 144;

15- Appellate Commission according to § 13a of the law of Employment of handicapped persons (BEinstG), BGBl. No. 22/1970;

16-. Supreme Patent- and Brand-Senate according to § 74 para 1 of the Patent-Law 1970, BGBl. No. 259;

17- Appellate Commission according to § 41a of the Federal law of 27 June 1979 on the Law of Professional Civil Servants (BDG 1979), BGBl. No. 333;

18- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 99 para 1 of the federal law of 27 June 1979 on the Law of Professional Civil Servants (BDG 1979), BGBl. No. 333;

19- Non-Military Service Complaints Council according to § 43 para 1 of the Federal Law on non-military service (1986 – ZDG), BGBl. No. 679;

20- Senate of Appeal according to § 64 para 2 of the federal law of 8 November 1989 on security and general commodity exchanges and on the modification of the Stockbroker Law 1949 and the Stock Exchange-Amendment 1903 (Stock Exchange Law 1989 – BörseG), BGBl. No. 555;

21- Supreme Appellate and Disciplinary Commission according to § 59 para 1 of the federal law of 2. June 1990 on the Disciplinary Statute for Lawyers and Junior Lawyers (Disciplinary Statute for Lawyers and Junior Lawyers – DSt) and on the amendment of the laws for lawyers, civil procedure and criminal procedure, BGBl. No. 474;

22- Appellate Commission in disciplinary matters according to § 58 para 1 of the federal law on the Chambers of architects and consulting engineers (Civil Technician Chamber Law 1993 – ZTKG), BGBl. No 157/1994;

23- Disciplinary Senate of The Austrian Medical Chamber at the Federal Ministry for Health according to § 180 para 1 of the federal law by which a federal law on the exertion of the medical profession and the profession-al representation of medical doctors (Medical Doctors Law 1998 – ÄrzteG 1998) has been rendered and the law on the reservation regarding education has been modified, BGBl. No. 169;

24- Superior Disciplinary Board of the Chamber of Chartered Accountants according to § 121 of the federal law on Chartered Accountants (Chartered Accountants Law – WTBG), BGBl. I No. 58/1999;

25- Data Privacy Commission according to § 35 para 1 of the federal law on the protection of person-related data (Datenschutzgesetz 2000 – DSG 2000), BGBl. I No. 165/1999;

26- Independent Environmental Senate according to § 1 para 1 of the federal law on the Environmental Senate (USG 2000), BGBl. I No. 114;

27- Federal Communication Senate according to § 1 para 2 of the federal law on the creation of a Communication Authority Austria (“KommAustria”) and a Federal Communication Senate (KommAustria-Law – KOG), BGBl. I No. 32/2001;

28- Appellate Disciplinary Senate according to § 58 para 1 of the federal law on the Austrian Chamber of Pharmacists (Pharmacy Chamber-Law 2001), BGBl. I No. 111;

29- Appellate Disciplinary Commission according to § 15 para 1 subpara 2 of the Military Disciplinary Law 2002 – HDG 2002, BGBl. I No. 167;

30- Penal action organs according to § 82 para 1 of the Military Disciplinary Law 2002 – HDG 2002, BGBl. I No. 167;

31- Quality Control Authority according to § 20 para 1 of the federal law on the quality management of auditing (Auditing Quality Management-Law – A-QSG), BGBl. I No. 84/2005;

32- Disciplinary Senate of the Austrian Odontologists Chamber according to § 65 para 1 subpara 1 of the federal law on the professional representation of the members of the odontological profession and of the dentists (Odontology Chamber-Law – ZÄKG), BGBl. I No. 154/2005:

33- Copy Right Senate according to § 30 para 1 of the federal law on exploita-tion companies (Exploitation Company-Law 2006 – VerwGesG 2006), BGBl. I No. 9.

B- Land Burgenland

1- Superior Commission for the service of teachers of the province for general compulsory schools according to § 10 para 1 of the law on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools in Burgenland (Supervision of Service-Law 1995 for male and female teachers of Burgenland – Bgld. LDHG), LGBl. No. 62;

2- Superior Commission for the service of teachers of the province for vocational schools according to § 11 para 1 of the law on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools in Burgenland (Supervision of Service-Law 1995 – Bgld. LDHG), LGBl. No. 62;

3- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province for general mandatory schools according to § 14 para 1 of the law on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools in Burgenland (Supervision of Service-Law 1995 – Bgld. LDHG), LGBl. No. 62;

4- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province for vocational schools according to 15 para 1 of the law on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools in Burgenland (Supervision of Serve-Law 1995 – Bgld. LDHG), LGBl. No. 62;

5- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 117 para 1 of the Law of 20 November 1997 on the Law of Professional Civil Servants (Law of Professional Civil-Servants 1997 for Burgenland – LBDG 1997), LGBl. No. 17/1998.

C- Land Kärnten

1- Superior Commission for the service of teachers of the province for public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools according to § 2 para 2 of the law of 28 June 1968 on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Supervision of Service-Law – K-LLDHG), LGBl. No. 62;

2- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 3 para 2 of the law of 28 June 1968 on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Supervision of Service-Law – K-LLDHG), LGBl. No. 62;

3- Superior Service Commission according to § 16 para 3 of the Carinthian Municipality Servant-Law 1992 – K-GBG. LGBl. No. 56

4- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 60 para 1 of the Carinthian Municipality Servant-Law 1992 – K-GBG. LGBl. No. 56;

5- Superior Service Commission according to § 38 para 1 of the Carinthian Town Clerk-Law 1993 – KStBG 1993, LGBl. No. 115;

6- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 111 para 1 of the Carinthian Town Clerk-Law 1993 – K-StBG 1993, LGBl. No. 115;

7- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 103 para 1 of the Carinthian Civil Servant-Law 1994 – K-DRG 1994, LGBl. No 71;

8- Superior Service Commission according to § 10 para 1 of the law of 28 September 2000 providing lists of applicants for the employment of teachers by the province, determining the competence of authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools and implementing the teachers of the province and the Supervision of Service-Law 1984 (Carinthian Teacher-Law – K-LG), LGBl. No. 80;

9- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 14 para 1 of the law of 28 September 2000 providing lists of applicants for the employment of teachers by the province, determining the competence of authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools and implementing the teachers of the province and the Supervision of Service-Law 1984 (Carinthian Teacher-Law – K-LG), LGBl. No. 80.

10- Real Estate Property Transfer-Commission of the province according to § 12 para 1 of the law of 18 December 2003 to control real estate traffic (Carinthian Real Estate Traffic-Law 2002 – K-GVG), LGBl. No. 9/2004.

D- Land Lower-Austria

1- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 181 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Civil Servant-Law (NÖ LBG), LGBl. 2100;

2- Describing Commissions according to § 22 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Municipality Servant Regulation 1976 (GBDO), LGBl. 2400;

3- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 121 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Municipality Servant Regulation 1976 (GBDO), LGBl. 2400;

4- Superior Service Commission according to § 15 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Land-Teacher-Supervision-Law 1976, LGBl. 2600;

5- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 18 para 1 of the Lower Austrian land-Teacher-Supervision-Law 1976, LGBl. 2600;

6- Superior Service Commission according to § 4 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Agricultural and Forestry Landes Teacher Supervision Law, LGBl. 2620.

7- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 7 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Agricultural and Forestry Landes Teacher Supervision Law, LGBl. 2620;

8- Commission of the province for damages by hunting and wild animals according to § 118 para 1 of the Lower Austrian Hunting-Law 1974 (NÖ JG), LGBl. 6500;

9- Real Estate Property Transfer-Commission of the province according to § 8 of the Lower Austrian Real Estate Traffic-Law 2007 (NÖ GVG 2007), LGBl. 6800;

10- Real Estate Property Transfer-Commission for Foreigners according to § 21 of the Lower Austrian Real Estate Traffic-Law 2007 (NÖ GVG 2007), LGBl. 6800.

E- Land Upper Austria

1- Superior Service Commission for teachers of the province for general mandatory schools according to § 11 para 1 of the law of 4 March 1986 concerning the competence to supervise teachers of the province for public mandatory schools (Upper Austrian Province-Teacher-Supervision-Law 1986 – Oö. LDHG 1986), LGBl. No. 18;

2- Superior Service Commission for the service of teachers of the province for vocational schools according to § 12 para 1 of the law of 4 March 1986 on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools (Upper Austrian Province-Teacher-Supervision-Law 1986 – Oö. LDHG 1986), LGBl. No. 18;

3- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province for general mandatory schools according to § 15 para 1 of the law of 4 March 1986 on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools (Upper Austrian Province-Teacher-Supervision-Law 1986 – Oö. LDHG 1986), LGBl. No. 18;

4- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province for vocational schools according to § 16 para 1 of the law of 4 March 1986 on the competences of the authorities to supervise female and male teachers of the province for public mandatory schools (Upper Austrian Province-Teacher-Supervision-law 1986 – Oö. LDHG 1986), LGBl. No. 18;

5- Superior Service Commission according to § 3 para 1 of the law of 4 March 1988 concerning the competence to supervise the teachers of the province at public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Upper Austrian Agricultural and Forestry Teachers of the Province Supervision-Law 1988 – Oö. LLDHG 1988), LGBl. No. 32;

6- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 5 para 1 of the law of 4 March 1988 concerning the competence to supervise the teachers of the provincial public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Upper Austrian Agricultural and Forestry Teachers of the Provincial Supervision-Law 1988 – Oö. LLDHG 1988), LGBl. No. 32.

7- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 119 para 1 of the law of Land of 3 December 1993 on the professional law of the clerks of the Land Upper Austria (Oö. Law on the Clerks of the Province 1993 – Oö. LBG), LGBl. No. 11/1994;

8- Real Estate Property Traffic-Commission of the Province according to § 25 para 2 of the law of the province of 7 July 1994 on real estate traffic (Oö. Real Estate Traffic-Law 1994 – Oö. GVG 1994), LGBl. No. 88;

9- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 143 para 1 of the law of the province on the professional law of the employees of the municipalities in Upper Austria (except towns with own charter) and Municipality Associations (Upper Austrian Municipality Employee-Law 2001 – Oö. GBG 2001), LGBl. No. 48;

10- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 106 para 1 of the law of the province on the professional law of male and female clerks in towns with own charter (Upper Austrian Statutory Municipalities-Clerk-Law 2002 – Oö. StGBG 2002), LGBl. No. 50;

11- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 53 para 1 of the law of the province on the service and remuneration law of the employees of the Upper Austrian municipalities (except towns with own charter) and Municipality Associations (Upper Austrian Municipality Service- and Remuneration-Law 2002 – Oö. GDG 2002), LGBl. No. 52.

F- Land Salzburg

1- Disciplinary Commission according to § 12 para 2 of the law of the province Salzburg for municipality clerks 1968, LGBl. No. 27;

2- Commission for the service of teachers of the province for agricultural and forestry schools according to § 3 para 1 of the law of 8 July 1981 on the competence to supervise the teachers of the province at agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Law of the Land Salzburg for Agricultural and Forestry Teacher Supervision 1981), LGBl. No. 80;

3- Disciplinary Commission for agricultural and forestry teachers of the province according § 5 para 1 of the law of 8 July 1981 on the competence to supervise the teachers of the province at agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Law of the Province Salzburg for Agricultural and Forestry Teacher Supervision 1981), LGBl. No. 80.

4- Commission for the service of teachers according to § 22 para 1 of the law on the Clerks of the Province Salzburg 1987 – L-BG, LGBl. No. 1;

5- Disciplinary Commission according to § 38 para 2 of the law on the Clerks of the Province Salzburg 1987 – L-BG, LBGl. No. 1;

6- Superior Service Commission according to § 4 para 1 of the law of the Province Salzburg for Supervision of Teachers of the province 1995 – LDHG 1995, LGBl. No. 138;

7- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 8 para 1 of the Province Salzburg for Supervision of Teachers of the province 1995 – LDHG 1995, LGBl. No. 138;

8- Disciplinary Commission according to § 105 para 2 of the law of 5 February 2003 on the professional law of the male and female clerks of the capital of the Province Salzburg (Municipal Administrative Clerk Law 2002 – MagBG), LGBl. No. 42/2003;

9- Tender Control Senate according to § 2 para 1 of the law of 7 February 2007 on the control of public tenders (Tender Control-Law of the Province Salzburg 2007 – S.VKG 2007), LGBl. No. 28.

G- Land Styria

1- Superior Service Commission for teachers of the province for general mandatory schools according to § 9 para 2 of the law of 30 June 1966 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province at mandatory schools in Styria (Styrian Law on supervision of the teachers of the province 1966 – LDHG.1966), LGBl. No. 209;

2- Superior Service Commission for teachers of the province at vocational mandatory schools according to § 10 para 2 of the law of 30 June 1966 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province at mandatory schools in Styria (Styrian Law on supervision of the teachers of the province 1966 – LDHG.1966), LGBl. No. 209;

3- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province for general mandatory schools according to § 16 para 2 of the law of 30 June 1966 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province at mandatory schools in Styria (Styrian Law on supervision of the teachers of the province 1966 – LDHG.1966), LGBl. No. 209;

4- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province for vocational mandatory schools according to § 17 para 2 of the law of 30 June 1966 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province at mandatory schools in Styria (Styrian Law on supervision of the teachers of the province 1966 – LDHG.1966), LBGl. No. 209;

5- Superior Service Commission of the agricultural and forestry teachers of the province according to § 3 para 2 of the law of 29 October 1969 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province at public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Supervision of Agricultural and Forestry Teachers of the provincial law), LGBl. No. 9/1970;

6- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 5 para 1 of the law of 29 October 1969 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province at public agricultural and forestry vocational and technical schools (Supervision of Agricultural and Forestry Teachers of the provincial law), LGBl. No. 9/1970;

7- Appellate Senate of the Styrian Hunters Association according to § 5 para 1 of the law of 10 November 1992 providing disciplinary rules for the Styrian Hunters Association, LGBl. No. 16/1993;

8- Duty Assessment Commission according to § 84 para 1 of the law on the service and remuneration law of the employees of the province Styria (Stmk. L-DBR), LGBl. No. 29/2003;

9- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 95 para 1 of the law on the service and remuneration law of the employees of the Province Styria (Stmk. L-DBR); LGBl. No. 29/2003;

H- Land Tyrol

1- Agricultural Farm Commission of the province according to § 9 para 3 of the law of 12 June 1900 concerning the specific legal situations of indivisible agricultural farms, effective for the Royal Shire of Tyrol, LGBl. No. 47;

2- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 74 para 1 of the law on municipality clerks 1970, LGBl. No. 9;

3- Duty Assessment Commission of the Tyrolean municipality clerks according to § 16 para 2 of the law on municipality clerks 1970, LGBl. No. 9;

4- Superior Disciplinary Commission according to § 65 para 1 of the Municipality Clerk-Law 1970 for Innsbruck, LGBl. No. 44;

5- Job Description Committees according to § 16 para 9 of the Municipality Clerk-Law 1970 for Innsbruck, LGBl. No. 44;

6- Superior Service Commission for teachers of the province according to § 8 para 1 of the law of 1 July 1998 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province Tyrol (Tyrolean Teachers of the provincial Supervision-Law 1998), LGBl. No. 74;

7- Superior Disciplinary Commission for teachers of the province according to § 11 para 1 of the law of 1 July 1998 on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province Tyrol (Tyrolean Teachers of the provincial Supervision-Law 1998), LGBl. No. 74;

8- Superior Administrative Commission for sickness and accident welfare for the clerks of the province according to § 62 of the Sickness and Welfare-Law for clerks and teachers 1998, LGBl. No. 97;

9- Superior Administrative Commission for sickness and accident welfare for the teachers of the province according to § 72 of the Sickness and Welfare-Law for clerks and teachers 1998, LGBl. No. 97;

10- Superior Administrative Commission for sickness and accident welfare for the Tyrolean municipality clerks according to § 76 of the Sickness and Welfare-Law for municipality clerks 1998; LGBl. No. 98;

11- Service Commission for clerks of the province according to § 2 lit. a of the Law on Clerks of the province 1998, LGBl. No. 65;

12- Superior Disciplinary Commission for clerks of the province according to § 2 lit. a of the law on Clerks of the province 1998, LGBl. No. 65;

13- Appellate Commission according to § 38 para 3 of the Tyrolean Tourism-Law 2006, LGBl. No. 19;

14- Appellate Commission in revenue matters according to § 5 para 1 of the law of 30 September 2009 on revenue matters of the province and the municipalities as well as penal regulations in matters of revenues governed by laws of the province (Tyrolean Revenue-Law – TAbgG); LGBl. No. 97;

15- Superior Provincial Consolidation Authority according to § 93 of the Tyrolean Development Plan-Law 2011 – TROG 2011, LGBl. No. 56;

I- Land Vorarlberg

Superior Service Commission according to § 4 para 4 of the law on the competence of authorities to supervise the teachers of the province for public mandatory schools (Supervision of Teachers of the provincial-law), LGBl. No. 34/1964.

J- Land Vienna

1- Superior Building-Control Authority according to § 138 of the Viennese City-Development-, Planning- and Construction-Law (Construction Rules for Vienna – BO for Vienna), LGBl. No. 11/1930;

2- Superior Arbitration Commission according to § 116 of the law on the regulation of hunting (Viennese Hunting-Law), LGBl. No. 6/1948;

3- Appellate Revenue Commission according to § 203 on the law of revenue organization in Vienna (WAOR), LGBl. No. 21/1962;

4- Appellate Senate according to § 48a para 1 of the Constitution of the Federal Capital Vienna (Viennese Constitution – WStV), LGBl. No. 28/1968;

5- Superior Service Commission at the School Council for Vienna according to § 4 para 1 subpara b of the law concerning the competence to supervise the male and female teachers at elementary-, mandatory-, special- and polytechnical schools as well for vocational schools for Vienna (Viennese supervision of male and female teachers of the provincial Supervision-Law 1978 – LDHG 1978), LGBl. No. 4/1979;

6- Superior Disciplinary Commission at the School Council for Vienna according to § 9 para 1 lit. c of the law concerning the competence to supervise the male and female teachers at elementary-, mandatory-, special- and polytechnical schools as well for vocational schools for Vienna (Viennese supervision of male and female teachers of the provincial Supervision-Law 1978 – LDHG 1978), LGBl. No. 4/1979;

7- Professional law-Senate according to § 74a of the law on the professional law of the clerks of the Federal Capital Vienna (Service-Rules 1994 – DO 1994); LGBl. No. 56;

8- Tender Control Senate according to § 3 of the Viennese Legal Tender Protection-Law 2007 (WVRG 2007), LGBl. No. 65/2006.

Tags

Dave Jolly

R.L. David Jolly holds a B.S. in Wildlife Biology and an M.S. in Biology – Population Genetics. He has worked in a number of fields, giving him a broad perspective on life, business, economics and politics. He is a very conservative Christian, husband, father and grandfather who cares deeply for his Savior, family and the future of our troubled nation.

Please leave your comments below

Facebook Comments

Disqus Comments